Mad Mike is what you need when you are a team on way up, he can get you partly there (like he did with Penguins) or with us for 2001-2003 or 2012-2017 but he isn't the guy to put you over the top (we did win 96 games with him between 2013 and 2015 so he wasn't all bad).
As an aside, a woman I...
and you are right, Florida won so he gets a pass, but yeah he did underperform. You are also correct that since the Oilers are basically a 2 man team, if you shut them down, you win
neither have championships, isn't that your criteria? You just need to be consistent, either it is the criteria, or it isn't. Is the player with more championship better, the criteria you use to claim Mean Joe Greene was better than Randy White but refuse to use to admit Emmitt Smith was...