• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

GDT #21: 2026/11/12 - We Are The Leafs Gone Mild/Wild

I'll have mixed feelings if/when he goes in the near future

I mean, at some point we're going to learn that it's not our best player's fault that we don't win when they continually go other places and become high producing members of contending and/or winning teams, right?

As much as I'm still on team "fuck Mitch", he's still a fucking wonderful hockey player that we put handcuffs on in the playoffs. Kessel's example is still pretty apt. Matthews, if he leaves, will no doubt go somewhere else and big dick them into deep playoff runs while we spend a decade wondering why Gavin McKenna can't win in the playoffs (and hilariously misdiagnose it every fucking year).

Our organizational approach to the game, even with the new, allegedly data driven enema, seems stuck in 2004 still.
 
I mean, at some point we're going to learn that it's not our best player's fault that we don't win when they continually go other places and become high producing members of contending and/or winning teams, right?

As much as I'm still on team "fuck Mitch", he's still a fucking wonderful hockey player that we put handcuffs on in the playoffs. Kessel's example is still pretty apt. Matthews, if he leaves, will no doubt go somewhere else and big dick them into deep playoff runs while we spend a decade wondering why Gavin McKenna can't win in the playoffs (and hilariously misdiagnose it every fucking year).

Our organizational approach to the game, even with the new, allegedly data driven enema, seems stuck in 2004 still.
When your entire core of stars cant get it done in the playoffs for a near decade , maybe they need different uniforms

Mitch played with winners and playoff success stories in Vegas , he just needs to be a support star not da man

Some cores cant get over the hump regardless of regular season stats , it is what it is

You changed regimes , coaches , etc.....
 
When your entire core of stars cant get it done in the playoffs for a near decade , maybe they need different uniforms

Mitch played with winners and playoff success stories in Vegas , he just needs to be a support star not da man

Some cores cant get over the hump regardless of regular season stats , it is what it is

You changed regimes , coaches , etc.....
Except Marner was "da man" on Vegas in the playoffs. It's a team game, having support is a prerequisite, and the Leafs haven't had enough of that. Only McDavid can drag his team by the dick to the finals. No one else.
 
Except Marner was "da man" on Vegas in the playoffs. It's a team game, having support is a prerequisite, and the Leafs haven't had enough of that. Only McDavid can drag his team by the dick to the finals. No one else.
Exactly but that happens with a change of scenery sometimes

For me its no accountability on your stars win or lose the big fat bonus is deposited every July 1

In Vegas ownership doesnt accept losing and don't give a fuck about your trade clause , they will make your life miserable

In Toronto nothing happens win or lose , same offseason rhetoric
 
Except Marner was "da man" on Vegas in the playoffs. It's a team game, having support is a prerequisite, and the Leafs haven't had enough of that. Only McDavid can drag his team by the dick to the finals. No one else.
He delivered like da man but Jack , Stone etc.... were the leaders
 
He delivered like da man but Jack , Stone etc.... were the leaders
So maybe trading the core would have been the wrong thing to do and they should have focused on building around them? Granted, the flat cap fucked them more than any other team, so it was challenging. But they still could have done more.

They take some blame obviously, but time and time again these guys leave the Leafs and become leaders on other winning organizations. The solution was never to dump your best players. That narrative is very dumb.
 
So maybe trading the core would have been the wrong thing to do and they should have focused on building around them? Granted, the flat cap fucked them more than any other team, so it was challenging. But they still could have done more.

They take some blame obviously, but time and time again these guys leave the Leafs and become leaders on other winning organizations. The solution was never to dump your best players. That narrative is very dumb.
Good post but your guns have to lead by example , how many failure playoffs can you endure .

I cant think of any playoff team in history that had 4 legit front liners and all underachieved for so long

Your bottom 6 are not carrying you to the finals and you dumped 9 firsts trying to work around the edges

You were gift wrapped inferior Hab and Columbus teams and still couldn't advance .

Its a good debate but for me this group gets you to the playoffs not through them
 
Good post but your guns have to lead by example , how many failure playoffs can you endure .

I cant think of any playoff team in history that had 4 legit front liners and all underachieved for so long

Your bottom 6 are not carrying you to the finals and you dumped 9 firsts trying to work around the edges

You were gift wrapped inferior Hab and Columbus teams and still couldn't advance .

Its a good debate but for me this group gets you to the playoffs not through them
They take some blame obviously, but trading your best players has literally never worked out for anyone. No one asked the bottom 6 to carry the Leafs, but look at Carolina's 4 lines of relentlessness and Vegas had talent up and down the lineup too, with elite d that the Leafs have never had. You need to look beyond the "team no win playoffs, must dump only good players" narrative. That's how you get worse, not better (i.e. Leafs now suck without Marner). Build a good impenetrable team with elite D, and all of a sudden those "playoff failures" will look good. Funny how that worked with Marner.
 
Also Nathan Mackinnon went from disappointing dud that should be traded to elite proven warrior winner once they got Makar.
 
I mean, at some point we're going to learn that it's not our best player's fault that we don't win when they continually go other places and become high producing members of contending and/or winning teams, right?

As much as I'm still on team "fuck Mitch", he's still a fucking wonderful hockey player that we put handcuffs on in the playoffs. Kessel's example is still pretty apt. Matthews, if he leaves, will no doubt go somewhere else and big dick them into deep playoff runs while we spend a decade wondering why Gavin McKenna can't win in the playoffs (and hilariously misdiagnose it every fucking year).

Maybe. but those players are leaving here and arriving somewhere else as individuals, not the group they are/were here together.
 
When your entire core of stars cant get it done in the playoffs for a near decade , maybe they need different uniforms

Nah, this is the core problem in Toronto where we keep convincing ourselves that the problem is in the mental/emotional makeup of our best players because we still wear Doug Gilmour and Wendel Clark pijamas 30 years later.

They don't need new uniforms, and never did. We needed to build teams around them that played to our strengths instead of insisting over and over again that their deficiencies were the problem with this team and over indexing on (poorly) solving those problems.

I cant think of any playoff team in history that had 4 legit front liners and all underachieved for so long

I mean, the counter argument is that year after year they were our best players in the playoffs. There are a few examples of some of them having bad playoff series (usually injury related, but whatever) but every year you look at our numbers in the playoffs and the same few guys lead the team in scoring, while winning their ice time while the depth gets caved in, often in soft usage. The inability to actually diagnose what went wrong when it happened right in front of our faces is kind of stunning. So easy to fall back on easy narratives and scapegoat your best players, when they actually were your best players.
Its a good debate but for me this group gets you to the playoffs not through them

What group? It's been torn down and rebuilt a half dozen times now and the only reason we make the playoffs when we do is the handful of players that we then blame for not getting us deep into the playoffs. This shit isn't nearly as difficult to think our way through as some people want to make it. The desire to fall back on easy narratives is understandable but is wrong way, way more often than it's right.
 
Maybe. but those players are leaving here and arriving somewhere else as individuals, not the group they are/were here together.

Same as I asked Geeman...what fucking group? When did we ever put a group around these guys that actually did anything other than watch 4-5 guys carry us?
 
Same as I asked Geeman...what fucking group? When did we ever put a group around these guys that actually did anything other than watch 4-5 guys carry us?
Lightbulb:

"Hey, let's surround our best players with the very best supporting players we can get!"

Until that happens consistently, Buds'll continue to be a heartbreaking operation. :(
 
They take some blame obviously, but trading your best players has literally never worked out for anyone. No one asked the bottom 6 to carry the Leafs, but look at Carolina's 4 lines of relentlessness and Vegas had talent up and down the lineup too, with elite d that the Leafs have never had. You need to look beyond the "team no win playoffs, must dump only good players" narrative. That's how you get worse, not better (i.e. Leafs now suck without Marner). Build a good impenetrable team with elite D, and all of a sudden those "playoff failures" will look good. Funny how that worked with Marner.
Your team has some flaws I get it

However at some point your stars need to produce when it matters

How many game winning , series clinching , or production did this core produce in games 5-7

Your team should have won at least 4-5 extra playoffs rounds that was your ceiling not the cup

If you lose in round 2 and in 13 games 34 has 9 goals and 8 assists or 16 had 19 points etc...but you lost on a fluke goal on game 7 thats acceptable .

This isnt about dumping your stars , its collectively as a group after 9 years it wasnt working .
 
Back
Top