• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

GDT #21: 2026/11/12 - We Are The Leafs Gone Mild/Wild

They never had a reliable playoff goalie, tho. Not even a guy that got hot for a bit.
 
If the next era of Leafs management takes that same lesson that Geeman takes from the Matthews era, I will be deeply alarmed. That is just wrong and lazy and will ensure that future failures are on the way. Results are noisy and it's a dangerous game to take the approach that you failed because of the only good parts of your team.
 
They never had a reliable playoff goalie, tho. Not even a guy that got hot for a bit.
The team never had an elite #1d. Every team they lost to in the playoffs (who, btw, were mostly teams that went on to win the cup or get to the finals) had that. It wasn't the only part of their roster that was missing (scoring depth up front was often an afterthought for Kyle), but it was probably the most important one, especially offensively. Those are the guys that create those odd man situations in the playoffs when things get tight. That's why Rielly had been so good in the playoffs, he was the only guy that could do that on some level, but he obviously always had his limitations.
 
However at some point your stars need to produce when it matters

How many game winning , series clinching , or production did this core produce in games 5-7

How many times do I have to answer your question before you accept the truth?
 
Last edited:
So maybe trading the core would have been the wrong thing to do and they should have focused on building around them? Granted, the flat cap fucked them more than any other team, so it was challenging. But they still could have done more.

They take some blame obviously, but time and time again these guys leave the Leafs and become leaders on other winning organizations. The solution was never to dump your best players. That narrative is very dumb.
I never liked the makeup of your D. Some decent pieces at times but as a squad? Meh. The goalies always got the blame.
 
The team never had an elite #1d. Every team they lost to in the playoffs (who, btw, were mostly teams that went on to win the cup or get to the finals) had that. It wasn't the only part of their roster that was missing (scoring depth up front was often an afterthought for Kyle), but it was probably the most important one, especially offensively. Those are the guys that create those odd man situations in the playoffs when things get tight. That's why Rielly had been so good in the playoffs, he was the only guy that could do that on some level, but he obviously always had his limitations.

Yeah. That too. But elite Ds are hard to find.

A good goalie would’ve been a difference maker in at least one of those many games 7s, including the one against the Habs
 
From all those picks we traded away in the past 10 years, and from the ones we kept and used, it's ridiculous that all we have to show for it is Knies/Marchenko. I guess you can say McCabe and Cowan too, but it's still a joke.

When we traded them, we got back garbage that didn't help us in the playoffs. When we kept them, we basically drafted nothing. That's been the biggest downfall. We needed to grab a Hutson with one of those second rounders, there were definitely opportunities to get guys in the draft, but management failed.
 
Yeah. That too. But elite Ds are hard to find.

A good goalie would’ve been a difference maker in at least one of those many games 7s, including the one against the Habs
Ya but the d thing is what made them a top 5-7 xgf team and never top 1-2. They were always really really good and could beat anyone, but even in their best years, they had a void that other teams of that caliber didn't have. Hard to find and I don't blame them for not doing it, but it's also true that the absence of one limited their offensive potential.

Goalies are highly variable, even good ones, especially in a 7 game series, though I agree that they were a save or two away from a few extra series wins. But series wins are noisy and gay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CH1
Ya but the d thing is what made them a top 5-7 xgf team and never top 1-2. They were always really really good and could beat anyone, but even in their best years, they had a void that other teams of that caliber didn't have. Hard to find and I don't blame them for not doing it, but it's also true that the absence of one limited their offensive potential.

Goalies are highly variable, even good ones, especially in a 7 game series, though I agree that they were a save or two away from a few extra series wins. But series wins are noisy and gay.
Every team that wins has holes too. It's not like we were playing perfectly assembled rosters when we'd lose in the first round.

I still have a hard time not blaming the core 4 for just not being able to get it done. I know there were other deficiencies on each of those teams, but one of those times, you need the best players to overcome and not go ice cold for the last three games. We did it once with Tavares against TB, and Ottawa was more of a team effort, but the rest of the times, when we needed one goal to just advance, we couldn't get it.
 
Ya the Penguins won a cup without Letang and a bunch of ok d, so they proved it was possible. Just saying though, it's a handicap. It usually doesn't happen.
 
the Leafs didn’t have a top 5-10 dman but at their peaks Mo/Muzzin/Brodie were three top end guys for those 2-3 seasons.

Hainsey was the pens best dman that run.
 
Yeah. That too. But elite Ds are hard to find.

A good goalie would’ve been a difference maker in at least one of those many games 7s, including the one against the Habs

We've almost always had the goalie that broke first, gave up the back breaker on a saveable shot, etc.

Not all bad goalies mind you, but always the first to crack
 
We've almost always had the goalie that broke first, gave up the back breaker on a saveable shot, etc.

Not all bad goalies mind you, but always the first to crack


On top of our goalies not always being bad, it also hasn’t even always necessarily been the case that ours have “cracked” or given up bad back-breaking goals.

It’s just that, with the exception of the win vs. Tampa where Vasilevsky was shit and Stolarz vs. the Sens, the Leaf goalie has always been outplayed by the guy in the other net.
 
Back
Top