• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

GDT #23: 2026/11/17 - MUST SWEEP Week

Yeah so I think if he avoided every transaction with a goalie involved, they'd be in a decent spot right now with lots of flexibility. Even if it meant he had to waive and lose one of them for nothing. None of that was data driven, including the acquisition of Nick Paul, a guy that Tampa was thrilled to dump.

Not signing more scoring depth up front was a mistake too, in addition to dumping guys like Lorentz and Maccelli for nothing. I don't blame him as much for not doing much with the D. I was fine with big game hunting or bust for that.
 
Yeah so I think if he avoided every transaction with a goalie involved, they'd be in a decent spot right now with lots of flexibility. Even if it meant he had to waive and lose one of them for nothing. None of that was data driven, including the acquisition of Nick Paul, a guy that Tampa was thrilled to dump.

Not signing more scoring depth up front was a mistake too, in addition to dumping guys like Lorentz and Maccelli for nothing. I don't blame him as much for not doing much with the D. I was fine with big game hunting or bust for that.
They had to move one owing to the waiver wire. Starting this year, Hildibeast had to clear waivers to go down.
 
Yeah so I think if he avoided every transaction with a goalie involved, they'd be in a decent spot right now with lots of flexibility. Even if it meant he had to waive and lose one of them for nothing. None of that was data driven, including the acquisition of Nick Paul, a guy that Tampa was thrilled to dump.

Not signing more scoring depth up front was a mistake too, in addition to dumping guys like Lorentz and Maccelli for nothing. I don't blame him as much for not doing much with the D. I was fine with big game hunting or bust for that.
Isn't that exactly what I said? The Bob move was tragic as soon as it happened, and if that didn't happen, then obviously we'd have stuck with Woll or Hildeby, so one of those moves wouldn't have happened (probably would've kept Woll, so Paul still gets acquired).

The rest of the moves, I'm either happy with or fine with. I don't think they chose bottom sixers over say getting Pettersson for free if such a thing was available. It probably wasn't, so they went with short term contracts to fill out the bottom six. I definitely don't agree with dumping Lorentz for nothing, still makes zero sense, but getting pretty decent bottom sixers to replace him (albeit for 2x or 3x his salary) lessens the blow.

It's really just the massive, monumentally stupid misread on Bobrovsky that killed them that day.
 
Every single thing that was done on July 1st was dumb and unnecessary other than the Roslovic signing. He spent over $20m on players who are replacement level at best and unplayable at worst. How was that not very obviously dumb? We all even acknowledged it in the thread at the time!
We didn't like any of those names or those prices, but then Carlsson-gate blasted salaries into another stratosphere immediately so we're not really bothered by the money anymore, and the play of Sissons, Duhaime, MacEwen, and (to a lesser extent) Blueger has been very good bottom six performance, so we can't even be unhappy with the players anymore. They knew better than us on those.

Roslovic was a home run, and Raddysh was a great add imo. I don't know what Zeke is talking about in saying decent to bad for $8.5M when he probably would've gone for $12m or $14m just a week later as a UFA. The goals will come. It's not like he lost his shot or anything - he still has a cannon.
 
Isn't that exactly what I said? The Bob move was tragic as soon as it happened, and if that didn't happen, then obviously we'd have stuck with Woll or Hildeby, so one of those moves wouldn't have happened (probably would've kept Woll, so Paul still gets acquired).

The rest of the moves, I'm either happy with or fine with. I don't think they chose bottom sixers over say getting Pettersson for free if such a thing was available. It probably wasn't, so they went with short term contracts to fill out the bottom six. I definitely don't agree with dumping Lorentz for nothing, still makes zero sense, but getting pretty decent bottom sixers to replace him (albeit for 2x or 3x his salary) lessens the blow.

It's really just the massive, monumentally stupid misread on Bobrovsky that killed them that day.
You also refused to trade Knies for Werenski and had a meltdown at the notion
 
You also refused to trade Knies for Werenski and had a meltdown at the notion
What is the point of this stupid comment other than to pick a fight? It has nothing to do with anything that I said to bring up a trade that didn't happen.

So, before another exchange blows up and derails the thread, and I eviscerate you and send you straight to your therapist for the day, just kindly disengage and, as I've recommended before, do not reply to my posts.
 
What is the point of this stupid comment other than to pick a fight? It has nothing to do with anything that I said to bring up a trade that didn't happen.

So, before another exchange blows up and derails the thread, and I eviscerate you and send you straight to your therapist for the day, just kindly disengage and, as I've recommended before, do not reply to my posts.
Yes
and
No.
 
We didn't like any of those names or those prices, but then Carlsson-gate blasted salaries into another stratosphere immediately so we're not really bothered by the money anymore, and the play of Sissons, Duhaime, MacEwen, and (to a lesser extent) Blueger has been very good bottom six performance, so we can't even be unhappy with the players anymore. They knew better than us on those.

Roslovic was a home run, and Raddysh was a great add imo. I don't know what Zeke is talking about in saying decent to bad for $8.5M when he probably would've gone for $12m or $14m just a week later as a UFA. The goals will come. It's not like he lost his shot or anything - he still has a cannon.
The salaries exploded for guys on contracts that were 5+ years in length when the cap is expected to go parabolic. At 2 years, it's not quite the same. They overpaid for all of those dudes and didn't focus enough on fully leaning into being a great offensive team by adding scoring depth.

Also Jonas shut up
 
I get the premise of what they did. It sounds good on paper. Acquire a bunch of plugs that can take some difficult minutes away from Matthews. Makes sense.

But when 50% of your forwards can't defend and 50% of your forwards have feet for hands, you're not maximizing them by playing any of them together and you're limiting your team at both ends of the ice. Especially when there is a single injury and you expect Nick Paul to play on your second line.
 
And that's the word with the peel on it, as Grandma used to say. Also why I'll be catchin' the boys mainly out of the corner of my eye this season.
 
I get the premise of what they did. It sounds good on paper. Acquire a bunch of plugs that can take some difficult minutes away from Matthews. Makes sense.

But when 50% of your forwards can't defend and 50% of your forwards have feet for hands, you're not maximizing them by playing any of them together and you're limiting your team at both ends of the ice. Especially when there is a single injury and you expect Nick Paul to play on your second line.
For me, the biggest thing about Roslo is the injection of speed he brings to the lineup. It highlights just how important team speed is when he can carry the puck end to end, blow past guys going full speed, etc. It's amazing. And frankly, every team that I see us play still has better team speed than we do up and down their lineup. That's why Joshua kills me, he's like fucking slow motion. Paul not much better. If there's one thing I would have wanted them to do, it would have been to pack the bottom six with speed and skill.

Now, they kinda didn't do a bad job on the fourth line. MacEwen is surprisingly fast for his frame, and Duhaime is very quick as well. I think that element has made that line very hard to deal with since both are physical too. Blueger is a meh who still seems pretty invisible to me, and I would have liked someone better and faster than him.

But assuming there's no debate about all the top guys being guys we like and want to keep, regardless of whatever the weak parts of their games might be right now, we got no issue with:

Matthews
Nylander
Tavares
Marchenko
Cowan
McKenna
Roslovic

And we like:
Sissons
MacEwen
Duhaime

And we (or at least I) want to do better than:
Joshua
Paul
Blueger

That means, in my view, that we're actually pretty close to where we need to be on the forwards when we have 10 keepers and 2 guys to upgrade on and 1 better 13th forward to get (and in that respect, Blueger is fine too if he's 13th).

So really, for me, it's about getting rid of slow, lumbering Joshua and Paul. They aren't completely skill-less, but they just aren't great.

And then, on the D:

Raddysh
Rielly
OEL

I think all three are very good. All mobile, all can play at both ends of the ice.

Tanev
McCabe
Stecher

Unfortunately, Tanev has his durability issues (I don't think he's lost his game though), but McCabe is useless if he's not good defensively now. I think it's fair to say Stecher is fine as #6, that Tanev is still good if healthy, but McCabe is the guy we really need to upgrade on with someone fast, skilled, and young.

Final analysis - we're not that far off on the skaters. Ideally, upgrade on Paul and Joshua. Upgrade on McCabe. That isn't a monumentally difficult task. Just upgrading McCabe would have a big impact. Paul is decent enough for now, but Joshua they should dump and replace with a faster guy.

So, close on the skaters, but then fucked with Bob. I don't know how they fix that other than termination or getting lucky and having one dumb GM think that a change of scenery will do the trick.
 
I get the premise of what they did. It sounds good on paper. Acquire a bunch of plugs that can take some difficult minutes away from Matthews. Makes sense.
You criticize the signings on a daily basis and there were too many, I think we all agree there. But the idea of signing a couple of these guys to 2 year deals actually was quite sound. The bottom 6 has been a weakness for this team for a while, and obviously Roslovic's been great, but Sissons and Mac have been quite solid. Everyone wants to see Marlies on the 4th line and 3rd pair but who are these mythical people? Groulx, Lettieri, Tverberg, Rifai, Merman, have contributed zero so far.

Paul's been a bit underwhelming, but so has Hildeby. Raddysh and Marchenko were big swings.

Unfortunately, they may have built a perfectly cromulent lineup and then lit it on fire with the Bobrovsky signing. Nobody could have foreseen Willy turning to shit. JT perhaps due to age. Still not sure what to make of the coach.
 
You criticize the signings on a daily basis and there were too many, I think we all agree there. But the idea of signing a couple of these guys to 2 year deals actually was quite sound. The bottom 6 has been a weakness for this team for a while, and obviously Roslovic's been great, but Sissons and Mac have been quite solid. Everyone wants to see Marlies on the 4th line and 3rd pair but who are these mythical people? Groulx, Lettieri, Tverberg, Rifai, Merman, have contributed zero so far.

Paul's been a bit underwhelming, but so has Hildeby. Raddysh and Marchenko were big swings.

Unfortunately, they may have built a perfectly cromulent lineup and then lit it on fire with the Bobrovsky signing. Nobody could have foreseen Willy turning to shit. JT perhaps due to age. Still not sure what to make of the coach.
That's the TLDR of my long post that precedes yours. I think Willy and Tavares are fine. Willy has just had a shitty past couple of weeks and Tavares is getting back up to game speed and looks good.

The Bob thing is a fucking nuclear bomb on the roster and they have to fix that error somehow, and honestly very soon.
 
I mean yeah, duh, the biggest issue and reason for their awful nerdies is that Tavares and Nylander suck ass this year. I mean, going into this season and knowing they were gonna get the easiest usage imaginable, it was non-negotiable that they have to be dominant. But they've been liabilities. And Wendy's didn't sign enough offensive talent to make up for that, so you're gonna be a one line team from a goal scoring perspective.
 
Don't worry about Tavares and Nylander. They didn't just suddenly die. And the proof is in the eye test - they've looked good the last couple games.
 
Back
Top