Saying "Well Roy was a 5th round pick, what'd you expect??" is willingly choosing to close your eyes to the context asto why he was a 5th round pick.
In his draft year, he was ranked as early as a late 1st / early 2nd, to a late 2nd / early 3rd. Most people who follow the draft were surprised that he dropped to the 5th round and he's greatly outplayed where he was selected in the draft.
Roy, and this is documented from his days in Junior, was always someone who coasted on his talent. He was the first overall pick in the Q draft and didn't seem to put maximum effort, until his final two Junior years. He got a little bit of success and, assuming the report that he has off ice issues are true, that trend from Junior has continued. If the reason is true, then I'm all for it.