• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Bernier to Ducks

I'd heard it was essentially Bernier for nothing (ie a pick with a condition that will never be met). That it was agreed to as part of the Andersen trade but Bernier couldn't be included at the time because we agreed to make his signing bonus payment before sending him over.

Agreed. The deal was Bernier 1st and 2nd for Anderson. 100%
 
The conditions of the Bernier trade are very complicated but essentially we only get anything back if Bernier goes to the cup finals and plays in half of the team's playoff games. Otherwise nada. So nada probably.

http://www.sportsnet.ca/hockey/nhl/breaking-conditional-pick-leafs-bernier-trade/
The simplest way to lay out the conditions seems to be:

  • If Bernier starts at least 50% of playoff games for the team that wins the 2017 Stanley Cup, the Leafs get the Ducks' 2nd round pick.
  • If Bernier starts at least 50% of playoff games for the team that loses in the 2017 Stanley Cup final, the Leafs get the Ducks' 3rd round pick.
  • In any other circumstance, the Leafs don't get anything.

So in reality, the Leafs don't really get anything straight-up for Bernier.

He was just part of the Frederik Andersen deal, but held back so his bonus would get paid out by the Leafs. And since players can't actually be dealt for "future considerations" or a "player to be named later" anymore, they just came up with the most impossible-to-attain set of conditions that they could.
 
Except Bernier at 4.5 million is entirely reasonable and arguably as good of a deal as Andersen`s 5 million. Ridiculous trade, hopefully it doesn`t bite them in the ass.
 
Bernier for nothing? We still win.

But now have a stake in Gibson's health and the Ducks' playoff success.

Imagine if we got a 2nd for him in the end?
 
They got $4.5 mill in cap space. Arguably as valuable as a 2nd. Chicago and Washington paid more.
No doubt. I'm still uneasy about the Andersen deal, but the fact that we essentially dumped Bernier's whole cap hit in the trade makes it a better deal.



Bernier for nothing? We still win.

But now have a stake in Gibson's health and the Ducks' playoff success.

Imagine if we got a 2nd for him in the end?
Don't get your hopes up.

Can you really picture a team getting to the Cup final, or winning the Cup with Jonathan Bernier starting at least 50% of their playoff games?
 
Weirder things have happened. Probably. Maybe.

iu
 
Back
Top