• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

GDT #4: TOR @ DAL

From Naturalstattrick.com:


All Strengths - Unadjusted (no score adjustment available)

#20 59.92 shot attempts against per 60min
#16 42.02 unblocked shot attempts against per 60min
#17 31.08 shots against per 60min
#22 30.33 scoring chances against per 60min
#15 11.19 high danger scoring chances against per 60min

5v5 Score-Adjusted

#21 60.52 shot attempts against per 60min
#18 42.81 unblocked shot attempts against per 60min
#21 32.66 shots against per 60min
#22 30.68 scoring chances against per 60min
#16 11.33 high danger scoring chances against per 60min





From corsicahockey.com (does not include empty-net situations):

All Strengths - Score Adjusted

#18 49.62 shot attempts against per 60min
#12 35.78 unblocked shot attempts against per 60min
#16 27.10 shots against per 60min
#13 2.14 expected goals against per 60min (i.e. shot attempts x shot quality)

5v5 - Score Adjusted

#22 53.51 shot attempts against per 60min
#19 38.63 unblocked shot attempts against per 60min
#21 29.74 shots against per 60min
#21 2.32 expected goals against per 60min (i.e. shot attempts x shot quality)
 
Offense

From corsicahockey.com (no empty net situations):

5v5 Score Adjusted

#5 57.36 shot attempts for per 60min
#4 41.62 unblocked shot attempts for per 60min
#13 28.53 shots for per 60min
#6 2.86 expected goals for per 60min

All Strengths score Adjusted

#7 56.09 shot attempts for per 60min
#9 40.89 unblocked shot attempts for per 60min
#18 27.84 shots for per 60min
#6 2.81 expected goals for per 60min


Naturalstattrick.com:

5v5 score adjusted

#5 65.66 shot attempts for per 60min
#6 46.96 unblocked shot attempts for per 60min
#14 31.28 shots for per 60min
#3 36.12 scoring chances for per 60min
#7 13.75 high danger scoring chances for per 60min

All Strengths (unadjusted)

#4 65.14 shot attempts for per 60min
#8 47.24 unblocked shot attempts for per 60min
#17 31.57 shots for per 60min
#1 38.04 scoring chances for per 60min
#4 14.67 high danger scoring chances for per 60min


note how our "Shots For" stat is the clear outlier here.
 
How are the numbers so different? Is it the adjustments? Is corsica's unadjusted all strength numbers the same?
 
How are the numbers so different? Is it the adjustments? Is corsica's unadjusted all strength numbers the same?

corsica never includes empty net situations, no matter what the selection.

and then there's the adjustments on top of that.
 
Corsica is better to go by then. EN situations aren't 5 on 5. Thats a surprisingly significant difference in the numbers.

The website isn't as reliable though.
 
Corsica is better to go by then. EN situations aren't 5 on 5. Thats a surprisingly significant difference in the numbers.

The website isn't as reliable though.

his new website this year works much much better.

make sure to go to corsicahockey.com instead of corsica.hockey.


he's got a bit of a glitch going right now as he hasn't properly labelled this year's stats so far, so you can't include this year in multi-year samples yet, but i'm sure he'll fix it soon.
 
Babs doesn't start coaching this team this season, why should we focus on this season only?

Same reason why its not valuable to compare Babs first year here with the last two.

Tavares, prime Matthews, Marner, (Nylander?) and Rielly, and second wave of kids like Kapanen, Dermott, Johnsson. Its a different team.
 
well it's not a different team in one key aspect -- while the difficulty in actually scoring on the Leafs depends on whether Freddy is on a peak or valley at that moment...it remains easy to generate offence against them.
 
Same reason why its not valuable to compare Babs first year here with the last two.

Tavares, prime Matthews, Marner, (Nylander?) and Rielly, and second wave of kids like Kapanen, Dermott, Johnsson. Its a different team.
But I'm not evaluating the team ... I'm evaluating Babs as a coach, and his influence on the team defense.

If he's the best (or at least one of the best) coaches in the league, you'd expect him to 1. improve the young team year to year, especially in areas of defense which needs to be taught and 2. that the team doesn't finish in the basement of the league for SA/60 or xGA/60 year after years.

If a coach is not making improvements after 3 full seasons, including 2 seasons with a very talented core, does it not beg the question why not? It's all I'm asking.
 
But by your own numbers the Leafs were a better defensive team the year they tanked. So what changed between that year and the following year? All the players.

its the same reason why you wouldn't look at the 2016-17 team and say "see they are good defensively, look at their numbers from last year". Its a different team.
 
Last edited:
But by your own numbers the Leafs were a better defensive team the year they tanked. So what changed between that year and the following year? All the players.

its the same reason why you wouldn't look at the 2016-17 team and say "see they are good defensively, look at their numbers from last year". Its a different team.

But that's not my point.

16/17 and 17/18 were more or less the same team. The rookies (Matthews, Marner, Nylander, Marner, Brown etc) all got 1 more year of experience playing in the league, and 1 more year of coaching by Babs. Yet, our xGA and SA did NOT improve.

I can't simply brush off the 2 previous seasons of piss-poor defense by saying "Oh it was a different team." It's the same coach, and he didn't manage to instill a half-decent defensive system over 2 seasons.

If we were 16th or 17th ranked for xGA then MAYBE the reason we're stuck were personnel related. But we're in the basement of the league for xGA 2 years in a row. You'd think in regardless of how poor defensively his roster was, the best coach in hockey gotta do better than basement for 2 years in a row, right??
 
4 years is not a big enough sample size for you?

Your entire argument rests under the assumption that we're shit defensively this season. We're 4 games into the season. Like I said, call me when there is a sample size.

Babs doesn't start coaching this team this season, why should we focus on this season only?

Because even just last, there's a pretty huge divide between the 1st half numbers and the 2nd half numbers. It's almost like this is a super young team that is still somewhat in transition.
 
But that's not my point.

16/17 and 17/18 were more or less the same team. The rookies (Matthews, Marner, Nylander, Marner, Brown etc) all got 1 more year of experience playing in the league, and 1 more year of coaching by Babs. Yet, our xGA and SA did NOT improve.

I can't simply brush off the 2 previous seasons of piss-poor defense by saying "Oh it was a different team." It's the same coach, and he didn't manage to instill a half-decent defensive system over 2 seasons.

If we were 16th or 17th ranked for xGA then MAYBE the reason we're stuck were personnel related. But we're in the basement of the league for xGA 2 years in a row. You'd think in regardless of how poor defensively his roster was, the best coach in hockey gotta do better than basement for 2 years in a row, right??

But they did have half decent defensive metrics the year before that so what’s the explanation for that then?

No doubt they have to be better defensively than they were in past years. But they are a better team and have been better so far.
 
The Leafs defensive play has improved since the opening night. It still wobbles at times but looks like they're finally learning how to do breakouts by having the forwards come back deep for a short breakout pass.
 
Back
Top