The film and the book are quite different. The feeling I had from that book was very sour. I was in a complete funk for quite some time after putting that book down. The film was trite in comparison.
100% agreed.
I really loved what the 'No Country' movie did for the book, in terms of increasing my enjoyment of it (casting was so damn good, that re-reading the book with those actors cast in your mind, made it an even better read, imo).......so I went into the movie really looking forward to it, particularly with Virgo in the lead.....but it really fell flat for me by comparison. It just really didn't capture any of what made the book brilliant for me.
One scene in particular really irked me.....in the book when they find the CocaCola machine, the father throughly insists that his son drinks every last drop of the pop, turning down any offers for even a sip that the son makes.......stating that he wants him to enjoy every last bit of it as it might be his last opportunity to do so. Which for me, was a f*cking brilliant metaphor of a fathers sacrificing his own wants and pleasures at times, to ensure that his son gets the absolute most out of life. Was easily one of the more powerful passages in the book.
then in the movie, the father accepts the offer from the child, and takes a drink.....I was floored that the director made that choice, couldn't believe it.
I did like the book, but it really had a strong kick to it.
Edit - I did read it shortly after my own child was born, so I am confident that it certainly left me a little sensitive to its message.
Even more of a theme of the book obviously, than anything I mentioned in my other posts.....is a fathers journey of educating his son on preparing for the real world, and that balance between trying to enable him to enjoy as much of it as he can, but also preventing him from day-dreaming about things that takes his focus away from the necessities and hard work required for the reality they live in.
I think it's actually an all-time great book for a father to read when they have a son......but yeah, right after having a child, when they're at their most fragile.....reading a book like this would definitely be a big time bummer.