Montana
Champion
I actually loved BTAS. I think it was an incredible portrayal of the characters, with excellent storytelling, especially during the latter years of its run. The only negative reference is to the fact that it's 20 years old already, and so seeing animation that looks so dated does make one feel like they cheaped out a bit in producing this film. That's the only knock.
...and maybe because I didn't watch BTAS, that's why I enjoy Timm's style more than others. I definitely have a soft spot for that more retro look from time to time, and am a big fan of Darwyn Cooke's stuff for instance, which is very much in the same vein. (his IDW run of "Richard Starks: Parker" is obscenely good)
I read the Morrison run while he was on the book, and you're right, it was weird, but after getting used to it a bit, it was very good. I think you may be a little less mainstream than me. For instance, I really enjoyed the Winnick run, but even moreso, I think Snyder currently has hit it out of the park. That said, Jim Gordon can't lose the suit fast enough for my taste. Not sure I like the aftermath of the great Endgame story.
I'm with you on Snyder & Capullo, they're absolutely killing it.
I lag a little behind on these runs though as I collect Absolute & Omnibus editions so outside of a few books (Saga, Fade Out, mainly Image titles) I don't read a ton of floppies month to month. That's what took me so long to get around to Morrisons run, wanted to own it in the oversized format. Even Snyder's run I read in TPB, and with how good the first year was, I'm kinda of tempted to wait for the rest of it to get the Absolute treatment. Tough to beat having that kind of artwork on massive oversized paper stock.
Last edited: