• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

GDT | Game 81 | vs Chicago - 98 vs 93 | Monday, April 14th | 7:00 PM EDT

And someone be so kind as to tell me how Newhook has been remotely "good" as opposed to a serviceable plug?

Drop Newhook off this team next season and replace with almost any nhl center and there won't be any drop off, likely an improvement.

Both center swings by Hughes turned a double play.
 
Dach can’t be trusted as a centre. The team is more secure with Newhook and even freakin’ Beck at C. That means we had a popgun 2nd line this year.

Newhook as a 3 C.

Dach as a winger, here or somewhere else. He can never play C again.
 
Dach can’t be trusted as a centre. The team is more secure with Newhook and even freakin’ Beck at C. That means we had a popgun 2nd line this year.

Newhook as a 3 C.

Dach as a winger, here or somewhere else. He can never play C again.
Numbers don't support your hypothesis sir.

Newhook is also a winger
 
Yes. Dach was very bad minus a few games in Dec-Jan. I'm not saying that Newhook is great, but rather that Dach was really bad.
Both healthy I play Dach over Newhook and I suspect you would too. Dach is a 50 point guy while Newhook can't crack 30 and I can't believe you tried using +\- as an argument.
 
Dach has shown he has the ability to be a Top 2 Center (two years ago) but he's cost us more games than Newhook has this year
 
Newhook would make a fantastic #4 center. High energy, speedy guy that can stir the shit a bit and once in awhile add some depth scoring.

Problem is, he and others still think he's a high potential player. He is not anymore.
 
Dach has shown he has the ability to be a Top 2 Center (two years ago) but he's cost us more games than Newhook has this year
Please provide proof of this assertion. Also are you factoring in the games his scoring won us? Are you factoring in Newhook missing gift goals repeatedly that could have won a game? Is that not losing a game as well?

It's insanity to purport that Newhook is the better option.
 
Newhook would make a fantastic #4 center. High energy, speedy guy that can stir the shit a bit and once in awhile add some depth scoring.

Problem is, he and others still think he's a high potential player. He is not anymore.
This
 
To be clear I'm not saying we should have Dach as our number 2 center. Far from it. I'm saying he's better than Newhook. By a wide margin.
 
Back
Top