• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

You're not getting a top 5 pick for any package centred around Kadri. Even Kadri + JVR might not be enough to get it done - with the talent available in the draft, I expect if the pick was up for grabs, there could be some insane packages going around.
 
I don't want the three below us to catch us.

I'm cheering for Buffalo, Edmonton, and Arizona to lose the rest of the way.

Just as I'm cheering for Carolina to win like never before.

1st or 4th is all I want.
 
You're not getting a top 5 pick for any package centred around Kadri. Even Kadri + JVR might not be enough to get it done - with the talent available in the draft, I expect if the pick was up for grabs, there could be some insane packages going around.
Okay, no question these picks are valuable, but this is just an insane under-valuing of the assets on Toronto's side.

I don't want the three below us to catch us.

I'm cheering for Buffalo, Edmonton, and Arizona to lose the rest of the way.

Just as I'm cheering for Carolina to win like never before.

1st or 4th is all I want.
Wanting to finish 4th instead of 3rd is pretty irrational. Is it because you want one of Strome or Marner, and no one else?

Do you not realize that if we finish in 4th, we're still in a position where both could be gone before we step up to the podium? Finishing 3rd guarantees that we have the chance to pick one of McDavid, Strome or Marner.
 
I don't want the three below us to catch us.

I'm cheering for Buffalo, Edmonton, and Arizona to lose the rest of the way.

Just as I'm cheering for Carolina to win like never before.

1st or 4th is all I want.

What do you mean? wouldn't you like to finish 3rd?
 
I don't want the three below us to catch us.

I'm cheering for Buffalo, Edmonton, and Arizona to lose the rest of the way.

Just as I'm cheering for Carolina to win like never before.

1st or 4th is all I want.

This is stupid. If we get the third pick, we can take the same guy we would have taken 4th. And there's a lower risk the guy we wanted at 4 is gone.
 
I don't want the three below us to catch us.

I'm cheering for Buffalo, Edmonton, and Arizona to lose the rest of the way.

Just as I'm cheering for Carolina to win like never before.

1st or 4th is all I want.

I want Edmonton to win. I want Arizona and Buffalo to lose.

I'll explain why.

First, Edmonton can catch us. And I'd take Strome over Hanifin anyway. So, doing it at 3 or 4 doesn't really matter. But, we have a better chance at winning the lottery at 3 than at 4.

Second, if a team behind us wins the lottery, we can only move as far back as 4.

Third, if Edmonton doesn't catch us, they're more likely to draft Hanifin than Strome or Marner at the 3rd spot. Phoenix is more likely than Edmonton to draft either Marner or Strome over Hanifin and, as I've previously said, Phoenix's scouts would have seen a lot of both Strome and Marner as two of the Dogs top prospects play in the OHL Midwest.
 
I want Edmonton to win. I want Arizona and Buffalo to lose.

I'll explain why.

First, Edmonton can catch us. And I'd take Strome over Hanifin anyway. So, doing it at 3 or 4 doesn't really matter. But, we have a better chance at winning the lottery at 3 than at 4.

Second, if a team behind us wins the lottery, we can only move as far back as 4.

Third, if Edmonton doesn't catch us, they're more likely to draft Hanifin than Strome or Marner at the 3rd spot. Phoenix is more likely than Edmonton to draft either Marner or Strome over Hanifin and, as I've previously said, Phoenix's scouts would have seen a lot of both Strome and Marner as two of the Dogs top prospects play in the OHL Midwest.

Makes sense to me. If we were to finish 4th, the order should look something like this to be fully in our favour:

McDavid to Arizona
Eichel to Buffao
Hanifin to Edmonton
Strome or Marner to Toronto

We get our choice of future 1C. McDavid goes to the western conference. Hanifin also goes to the western conference. Eichel goes to a team that still has a lot of work to do before they get competitive.
 
This is stupid. If we get the third pick, we can take the same guy we would have taken 4th. And there's a lower risk the guy we wanted at 4 is gone.

and if both guys are available, and we don't really care which one we get but the team in 4th does, we could always trade a spot down and gain an asset.
 
Not sure why people are down on Hanifin. What he did this year is unheard of. 17 year olds never play in the NCAA. Werenski is the only other guy to do it. And he scored at a 55 point pace. He is big, has elite skating, has an elite skill set, and is already a well rounded player defensively.

The guy is a stud. Anywhere in the top 5 we are getting a player that would be a #1 pick most years.
 
There is a reason the guy is the consensus #3 pick ahead of guys like Strome and Marner. He is in that class.
 
Not sure why people are down on Hanifin. What he did this year is unheard of. 17 year olds never play in the NCAA. Werenski is the only other guy to do it. And he scored at a 55 point pace. He is big, has elite skating, has an elite skill set, and is already a well rounded player defensively.

The guy is a stud. Anywhere in the top 5 we are getting a player that would be a #1 pick most years.


Not down on Hanifin at all. He definitely belongs in the top 5, maybe even 3rd overall. I just think we have Reilly who we hope to be a number 1 at some point. We don't have a potential 1C in the system. This is our chance to grab one.

Now if the difference in skillset was significant between Hanifin and Strome/Marnet, I would've gone with Hanifin as well regardless of position. 1D's are extremely valuable as well. As things stand, I want to finally stop crying about not having a number 1C. I've shed too many tears since Sundin retired.
 
Hanifin scored 16 points in his last 19 games after coming back from the WJC. That is crazy. He was an elite #1 dman in the NCAA at 17.

We need elite dmen too.
 
Position shouldn't be a factor at all. If we are picking 3, and our scouting staff has Hanifin ranked 3rd, we should be taking Hanifin. Period.
 
Yes, I don't get why Hanifin is a 'bad thing' to some people.

Hanifin has all the signs of a great #1 stud dman.
 
Not sure why people are down on Hanifin. What he did this year is unheard of. 17 year olds never play in the NCAA. Werenski is the only other guy to do it. And he scored at a 55 point pace. He is big, has elite skating, has an elite skill set, and is already a well rounded player defensively.

The guy is a stud. Anywhere in the top 5 we are getting a player that would be a #1 pick most years.
It's not too hard to figure out. It's not a purely rational thing, but after watching Matt Stajan, Mikhail Grabovski & Tyler Bozak fill the role of "Leaf #1 center" in the seven years since Mats Sundin left, I think we're all pretty desperate for someone who actually has a chance of adequately filling that role to become Leaf property. And after we've dropped into a top-5 that miraculously has four potential #1 centers, it's pretty easy to see this as the best chance we'll have for a long time of adding that kind of player.

So, if we end up with Hanifin, initially I'd be disappointed. But like when we ended up with Morgan Rielly instead of Alex Galchenyuk, I'd get over it.
 
If we are picking fifth and Hanifin slips to us, Shanny and co. will pick him and giggle their way right to the podium.
 
It's not too hard to figure out. It's not a purely rational thing, but after watching Matt Stajan, Mikhail Grabovski & Tyler Bozak fill the role of "Leaf #1 center" in the seven years since Mats Sundin left, I think we're all pretty desperate for someone who actually has a chance of adequately filling that role to become Leaf property. And after we've dropped into a top-5 that miraculously has four potential #1 centers, it's pretty easy to see this as the best chance we'll have for a long time of adding that kind of player.

So, if we end up with Hanifin, initially I'd be disappointed. But like when we ended up with Morgan Rielly instead of Alex Galchenyuk, I'd get over it.

Yeah, but its not like we have been blessed with watching great dmen fill the #1 dman role either. We've had to stomach guys like Gunnar, Franson, Gardiner, Robidas, Komi, Finger, etc. eat big minutes. Our D has been brutal.

Sure we have Rielly on the blueline, but we also have Kadri, Nylander, Holland and Gautheir down the middle. We could use high end players at both positions.

Hanifin, Marner and Strome would all immediately become a cornerstone piece for us, and maybe our best player depending on if Kessel moves. No need to be disapointed with any of them.

This was the right year to bottom out. The Leafs lucked out for a change.
 
I will say this - it will probably take longer before Hanifin makes an impact in the NHL than Marner or Strome. Forwards of that calibre pretty much become impactful NHL fowards in their sophomore season, stars by 3rd or 4th season. Defensemen take longer ... just look at Hedman.

IT doesn't mean I don't want Hanifin though. We still very much need a stud #1.
 
I'm not so much down on Hanifin, I think it needs to be put in context.

First, Hanifin started the year as the clear cut #3. By all accounts, he was much closer to McDavid/Eichel than he was to the tier below him.

Since then, the tier below him has become better sorted with guys like Marner and Strome separating themselves from the pack. While Hanifin has had an outstanding year, both Strome and Marner have wildly exceeded expectations. Thus, closing the gap between where they were and where Hanifin is.

Second, Hanifin plays at Boston College. In the decade that I've been watching College Hockey, the Eagles have always, always,always run a high octane offence. Some of the most gaudy offensive stats always seem to come out of BC. So, while Hanifin's stats are incredibly impressive particularly given his age, I think if you asked any scout what program was most likely to churn out a defenseman with numbers like that, BC would probably be the first answer of most of them. College Hockey can be a bit like College Football in that sense. There are a lot of system dependent offences.

Third, the argument about the Leafs fan preference for a centre likely is playing a significant part. To be honest, I doubt I would be shocked to see either Toronto or Phoenix draft Strome over Hanifin at this point. The Oilers and Hurricanes I have no doubt would take Hanifin.

Last, Rielly and Hanifin are much more comparable than any of Kadri, Holland or Gauthier are to Strome as a potential cornerstone centre. As for Nylander, I'll bet he ends up as a great NHL winger.
 
I will say this - since it's rare we get THIS bad, and draft THIS low, I definitely don't want to screw this up.

And to me, it means I'd much rather go with a Canadian than an American. I think OHL stats typically project very well, and it is easy to read the Q / W numbers. Not so with NCAA. Also, I am never sure what kind of impact playing in the fishtank like Toronto has on American players, whereas a kid from Toronto would at least already know what to expect.
 
Back
Top