• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

Dubas is making a lot of sense with all these quotes. And regardless of his title, it's important he has Shanny's ears because it is very important we drop the old school thinking and start revamping this team with thinking like that immediately.
 
leafman101 will enjoy this quote from Kyle Dubas (which I read in Elliott Friedman's latest "30 thoughts" article). When asked if the Leafs would consider passing on Mitch Marner, because they've already got smallish forwards like Nazem Kadri, Connor Brown & William Nylander, this is what he had to say:

Thank god.

Having a debate re: Crouse/drafting for size with Canes fans the past few days and it's just a complete relief to hear that from our GM instead.
 
I love hearing that. He's right. Talent is the most important thing, and you can never have too much skill. And size doesn't even matter in todays game.
 
Size certainly helps to complete the package, but skill should trump all at the draft table.
 
leafman101 will enjoy this quote from Kyle Dubas (which I read in Elliott Friedman's latest "30 thoughts" article). When asked if the Leafs would consider passing on Mitch Marner, because they've already got smallish forwards like Nazem Kadri, Connor Brown & William Nylander, this is what he had to say:
Awesome
 
From Corey Pronman:

1. Connor McDavid
C, Erie (OHL)
DOB: 1/13/97 | Ht: 6-1 | Wt: 190
2014-15 GP: 47 | G: 44 | A: 76


Get used to this name; he could end up as one of the faces of hockey for the next 10 to 20 years. McDavid is one of the best pure skaters I've ever seen. It's incredible how effortlessly he accelerates to an extremely dangerous full speed. At the CHL level, if a defenseman was horizontal to him or even had an inch gap they were beat, plain and simple. He'll step into the NHL next season and be one of his team's fastest players.

His puck skills are also of that same extremely high grade. He makes some of the most unique puck plays you'll see, to where it's hard to describe his puck skills other than to say "watch him." His creativity, hand-eye coordination, and balance are simply incredible. McDavid also has elite hockey sense, so on top of his knowing how to make defenders miss left and right and set up his teammates, this also lets him be an elite forechecker when combined with his skating. He follows the play off the puck so well that whenever he's on the ice -- even when the other team has the puck -- you're still expecting a McDavid scoring chance.

He's a relentless worker, and with that quality thrown in with some of his others, it makes him a very dangerous penalty killer as well. McDavid's sole real weakness is his frame right now, as bulking up will be a key for him to survive some of the NHL's physical hurdles.


2. Jack Eichel
C, Boston University (Hockey East)
DOB: 10/28/96 | Ht: 6-2 | Wt: 194
2014-15 GP: 40 | G: 26 | A: 45

Eichel is one of the very best college freshmen of the modern era, and had a simply fantastic season. His skill level is elite, and it's off the charts for a 6-2 forward in terms of the amount of high-level plays he makes regularly. Eichel uses a longer than average stick, and with his wingspan and skills he can be almost impossible to get off of the puck. He makes evasions seem effortless to where I often hear from scouts that he looks "bored" on the ice because he exerts so little energy when he makes defensemen miss.

He's strong, works hard and thinks the game at such a high level that he creates chances in bunches. His hockey sense allows him to be a top-end playmaker, but he's also a very good defensive forward, who has often been one of his team's top penalty killers. He skates very well with an explosive first few steps and a smooth glide you don't see often with bigger players. He projects as a potential No. 1 star center.

Ranking explanation: The best way to describe the rationale for Eichel over Mitch Marner is that they share similar raw offensive qualities, but Eichel's size and more well-rounded game propel him over the latter. In terms of skating, puck skills and offensive IQ, they are very close. Maybe Marner has a small edge in one or two categories, but in size, Eichel is a 6-2, 200-pound center as opposed to Marner, who is 5-11, 175 pounds.

Furthermore, while Marner has shown solid defense, Eichel's defensive capabilities are very impressive for his age group. Some may point to Marner's incredible production in the OHL -- one of the best under-18 seasons in recent memory -- but Eichel's production is also of that same ludicrous level, especially when you account for the fact he's a late October birth date, putting him five to eight months behind where most freshmen tend to be physically.


3. Mitch Marner
C, London (OHL)
DOB: 5/5/97 | Ht: 5-11 | Wt: 163
2014-15 GP: 63 | G: 44 | A: 82


Marner had a fantastic 17-year-old season in the OHL, racking up an absurd amount of points. He's a shifty player, and is tough for a defense to stop. His speed, acceleration and edge control are all high-end, and because of that, you rarely saw an OHL defenseman land a clean check on Marner. His puck skills are elite, and he can make great in-tight plays to evade pressure, dekes in full stride to get around a defender or puck plays off the half-boards that create offense in bunches.

Marner is also an incredible passer, making quick reads with the ability to stretch the ice or move it across laterally through traffic with consistency. While small, his defensive game is solid, and improved quite notably over the course of the OHL season to where he became one of London's better penalty killers. He's also quite an effective forechecker, not in terms of physical play, but rather how well he forces plays and is sneaky on takeaways.

Ranking explanation: Marner and Dylan Strome were both among the very top scorers in the OHL this season, and both had under-18 seasons that were among the very best of the past 10 years in terms of statistical production.

It's a push in terms of pure hockey sense, although they're better in different ways: Marner is a little more creative and a little better in his defensive reads, while Strome's vision is probably a notch higher. Marner's skating is significantly better than Strome's especially in terms of speed, but Strome has a good four inches on Marner. Marner's production was aided by playing on a stacked London team, while Strome played with McDavid -- albeit typically just on the power play.

The skating difference is really what sways me, even with the size discrepancy, given their puck skills are close and Marner has shown he can defend. Skating kills in the NHL, in terms of being able to gain the zone with control of the puck, and Marner is ahead there.


4. Dylan Strome
C, Erie (OHL)
DOB: 3/7/97 | Ht: 6-3 | Wt: 187
2014-15 GP: 68 | G: 45 | A: 84


Strome was one of the very top scorers in the OHL this season, and while many point to the teammate effect with McDavid on the same team, he didn't play with him much at even strength, yet still managed a roughly 1.5 points-per-game pace when McDavid was hurt.

"He's a big center with high-end skill. You're never going to find that anywhere but the top of the draft" said one scout.

Strome is a great stick handler, especially for a 6-3 player, but he's also smart with the puck. He slows the play down very well, operates well in tight spaces and has the offensive instincts to evade pressure at a high level. He's not great defensively yet, although he's fine on the draw and could project to have decent defensive value down the line.

Strome's main weakness is his skating, as he lacks an explosive top gear and is just roughly average in that area overall.

Ranking explanation: The ranking of Marner and Strome ahead of Noah Hanifin was discussed in depth here.


5. Noah Hanifin
D, Boston College (Hockey East)
DOB: 1/25/97 | Ht: 6-2 | Wt: 205
2014-15 GP: 37 | G: 5 | A: 18


Hanifin is an elite all-around defenseman who has a real chance to be in the NHL next season should he choose to leave Boston College. He's a high-end skater who moves incredibly well for a player of his size. His first few steps are explosive, with as much power out of his pivots and crossovers as you'll see in a defenseman, making him very dangerous in transition.

His puck skills and offensive IQ don't blow you away, but he's very good in those areas. Hanifin can make the quick passes, lead a rush in a dynamic way and makes good decisions with the puck.

Defensively, he closes his gaps well, uses his stick effectively and projects as a player who can stop good forwards. Overall, his game is a high-tempo, high-energy style, though he's not the most bruising defender.

Ranking explanation: Despite the positional differences and the value it gives Mathew Barzal, overall there is a talent drop-off here. Hanifin's accomplishments during the past two years have been extremely impressive, and it's only because of the incredible seasons of the four players ranked ahead of him that he's slotted No. 5.

On pure talent, Barzal is not too far away from Hanifin. They're both elite skaters, Barzal is better with the puck, and both are very smart. However, Hanifin has a major size edge, and is very good defensively. At the end of the day, output wins out. As an under-18 defenseman in Hockey East, Hanifin has been spectacular, and he was impressive as a double underage at the IIHF World Junior Championships. Barzal's talent level is high-end, and I love the upside, but he just doesn't have the same resume, as he was pretty good but not amazing in 2014-15.

http://espn.go.com/nhl/insider/stor...el-lead-list-top-100-prospects-2015-nhl-draft
 
Ranking explanation: The best way to describe the rationale for Eichel over Mitch Marner is that they share similar raw offensive qualities, but Eichel's size and more well-rounded game propel him over the latter. In terms of skating, puck skills and offensive IQ, they are very close. Maybe Marner has a small edge in one or two categories, but in size, Eichel is a 6-2, 200-pound center as opposed to Marner, who is 5-11, 175 pounds.

First time I have see that close of a comparison between Eichel and Marner. I was under the impression that McDavid and Eichel were a clear step above the next 3

Thats intriguing
 
Based off all the other rankings the probability of choosing between him and Hanifin is relatively high
 
AZ - Strome
TOR - Marner
CAR - Haf
TOR - ?

Just assuming we DO trade for #6, who do you take in this scenario?
 
AZ - Strome
TOR - Marner
CAR - Haf
TOR - ?

Just assuming we DO trade for #6, who do you take in this scenario?
Question is, does Ray Shero taking over for Lou Lamoriello make it more or less likely that the Devils entertain trading that pick?

In the plus column, Shero was never shy about trading away futures when he was running the Penguins.

On the down-side, he's seen first-hand how that strategy has made the Pens progressively less of a threat to win the Cup every year. He also may not have the same delusions Lou has about the Devils' roster, or have senior citizen Lou's strong desire for short-term success.
 
Back
Top