• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

We'll have to disagree then on need vs want! Like I said it all depends on who Arizona drafts TBH, if Hanifan is available at #4 take him because we badly need a workhorse stud blueliner, but if he's unavailable go with Strome because we also badly need a top centre.

I think we can agree on Hunter though, he has an impeccable scouting record and is fastly gaining a strong reputation in the NHL, I trust he'll make the right decisions scouting for the Leafs.

Drafting for need is one of the stupidest decisions any sports organization can make.
 
While I'm undecided between Hanifin and Marner at the moment, I think it's unfair to compare Hanifin to Luke Richardson.

First, they're not even remotely similar defensemen stylistically.

Second, by an objective draft standard of the time, anyone who gets a defenseman that plays 1400+ NHL games would hardly consider that a wasted pick.
 
While I'm undecided between Hanifin and Marner at the moment, I think it's unfair to compare Hanifin to Luke Richardson.

First, they're not even remotely similar defensemen stylistically.

Second, by an objective draft standard of the time, anyone who gets a defenseman that plays 1400+ NHL games would hardly consider that a wasted pick.

Obviously it was Pep's post and not mine so I could be wrong but I took that as him simply making a comment on drafting for need rather than actually comparing Richardson and Hanifan.
 
Given all that I've learned over the past few months about these guys, this is what I am looking at (+ives are obvious):

Point against Marner:

I see Marner as the next Patrick Kane, which is why I would NOT pick him over the Hannifin or Strome IF those two indeed have a good chance of becoming top line players. Here me out here. While Kane is amazing and often the difference maker for the Hawks, I believe he would be Phil Kessel without Duncan Keith and J. Toews. On the other hand, I don't think JT or Keith would've been, say, RNH and Kevin Shattenkirk without Patrick Kane.

Point against Hannfin:

Given history, we know that top D men can be found outside the top 5 + we already have Rielly who has a chance to be one of those guys. In addition, Hannifin's a NCAA star. That ''league' doesn't have a great recent track record when it comes to Dmen.

Point against Strome:

Some say his foot speed will hurt him and pushes him down to the 2nd line centre levels in the NHL.




My ranking:
1- Strome
2- Hannfin
3- Marner


What this means is that I am willing to risk drafting a 2nd line centre here at the expense of a Conn Smyth type winger like Marner, simply because I value that position so much more.

Disclaimer: If there is a good chance that Marner would actually play centre in the NHL, then he'd move to #1 for me
Disclaimer 2: I would NOT be disappointed if Hunter and co pick Marner in the draft. The fact is that what I know is based on what I've read and a couple of games I've watched here or there (never watched Hannfin). They know much more about a players' potential.
 
Obviously it was Pep's post and not mine so I could be wrong but I took that as him simply making a comment on drafting for need rather than actually comparing Richardson and Hanifan.

I see valid arguments for both players.

Hanifin and Rielly would be an incredible base upon which to build a team. No one who has seen the minutes being carried by Keith, Seabrook and Hjalmarsson this playoff for the Blackhawks could doubt the value of having big horses on the blueline.

But, I take Kerr's point as well. Statistics tell me that there is as great a likelihood of getting a great defenseman in the second or third round as there is in the first round. Particularly given that the defensive depth in this draft is primarily between the 20-40 picks.

Marner certainly has the skating and the hands that make him a tantalizing prospect to select high.

I'd love to see us get another pick in the Top Ten, but I don't think it's going to happen.
 
Any reason why you keep spelling his name "Hanifan", HL? I can usually keep my inner spelling/grammar Nazi in check, but I've got to ask here.

As for who the Leafs, pick, if it comes down to Marner vs. Hanifin...I wouldn't assume that Hunter will automatically go with Marner just because he had him in London and is more familiar with him. I would think our current management group would be a bit more thorough than that when making this decision.

It's probably also fair to assume that Hunter and/or Dubas scouted the NCAA a decent amount this year, since it's been apparent since shortly after the new year that we'd at least be in the top 6 or 7, where both Hanifin and Werenski are rated.
 
Any reason why you keep spelling his name "Hanifan", HL? I can usually keep my inner spelling/grammar Nazi in check, but I've got to ask here.

As for who the Leafs, pick, if it comes down to Marner vs. Hanifin...I wouldn't assume that Hunter will automatically go with Marner just because he had him in London and is more familiar with him. I would think our current management group would be a bit more thorough than that when making this decision.

It's probably also fair to assume that Hunter and/or Dubas scouted the NCAA a decent amount this year, since it's been apparent since shortly after the new year that we'd at least be in the top 6 or 7, where both Hanifin and Werenski are rated.

Brain farts? I've checked before when I couldn't remember if it was A or I and somehow remembered the opposite of what I looked up.
 
Point against Marner:

I see Marner as the next Patrick Kane, which is why I would NOT pick him over the Hannifin or Strome IF those two indeed have a good chance of becoming top line players. Here me out here. While Kane is amazing and often the difference maker for the Hawks, I believe he would be Phil Kessel without Duncan Keith and J. Toews. On the other hand, I don't think JT or Keith would've been, say, RNH and Kevin Shattenkirk without Patrick Kane.

I don't understand why Toews would be Toews without Kane and Kieth, and Keith would be Keith without Toews and Kane, but Kane wouldn't be Kane without Toews and Keith.

I think points like that should be completely removed from the equation in scouting. Fact of the matter is Chicago is today's dynasty because they have all 3. Chicago wouldn't be Chicago without Kane, Toews or Keith.

You take the best hockey player. Period.
 
It's a really hard decision. I keep flip flopping myself. I find myself leaning Marner though.

Might just because I'm more familiar with him.
 
I don't understand why Toews would be Toews without Kane and Kieth, and Keith would be Keith without Toews and Kane, but Kane wouldn't be Kane without Toews and Keith.

I think points like that should be completely removed from the equation in scouting. Fact of the matter is Chicago is today's dynasty because they have all 3. Chicago wouldn't be Chicago without Kane, Toews or Keith.

You take the best hockey player. Period.

So here's the core point I am making:

1- A Winger who has a potential to be a 'super' star top line player
2- A Centre who has a potential to be a star top line player

Both very good players, I'd take the latter because I think positions matters here. I don't want to be stuck with a Patrick Kane without a JT in the few years (or a Phill Kessel with a Bozak in our case). I can find good wingers elsewhere, #1Cs are just very elusive.
 
I think it's important to remember that, no matter who we pick, they're almost certainly not going to be playing for the Toronto Maple Leafs next year. I expect Marner or Strome would both go back to the OHL for at least another year, and Hanifin would either go back to the NCAA or join the Marlies.

So, I don't think we should really spend any time worrying about whether we have our Toews or Keith to go along with our Kane if we decide to go with Marner. Maybe Rielly, or a defenseman we pick up later in this draft is our Keith. And maybe we walk out of the 2016 draft with Auston Matthews or Logan Brown, and they end up being our "Toews". Just pick the best player and worry about the rest later.

Brain farts? I've checked before when I couldn't remember if it was A or I and somehow remembered the opposite of what I looked up.
Makes sense.
 
I think it's important to remember that, no matter who we pick, they're almost certainly not going to be playing for the Toronto Maple Leafs next year. I expect Marner or Strome would both go back to the OHL for at least another year, and Hanifin would either go back to the NCAA or join the Marlies.

So, I don't think we should really spend any time worrying about whether we have our Toews or Keith to go along with our Kane if we decide to go with Marner. Maybe Rielly, or a defenseman we pick up later in this draft is our Keith. And maybe we walk out of the 2016 draft with Auston Matthews or Logan Brown, and they end up being our "Toews". Just pick the best player and worry about the rest later.


Makes sense.


That's a good point. Our tank isn't over yet though it's much harder to see a Babcock team finishing bottom 3-4. We'll see.
 
So here's the core point I am making:

1- A Winger who has a potential to be a 'super' star top line player
2- A Centre who has a potential to be a star top line player

Both very good players, I'd take the latter because I think positions matters here. I don't want to be stuck with a Patrick Kane without a JT in the few years (or a Phill Kessel with a Bozak in our case). I can find good wingers elsewhere, #1Cs are just very elusive.

Patrick Kane's a pretty elusive too though. its not like those guys grow on trees. And its not like he is any less important to Chicago's cups than the other guys. You cannot find Patrick Kane's elsewhere any easier than you can find a Jonathan Toews. All of them are big time, key players. Chicago could have picked Turris over Kane because he was a center. But what good would that have done. Not comparing Strome to Turris, its just generally about focusing on position first. Focus on talent first. Take the best hockey player.

And IMO Marner is a center anyway.
 
Last edited:
I think I lean Marner just because drafting d-men early and high can be such a crap shoot. It's like IW said, more elite D are drafted in the later rounds than elite Fs. And Marner also put up silly good numbers this year.
 
I get the C vs W part. I do think C is more valuable.

But I also think if Marner turns out to be that 'super elite' winger, he can make a good #1 C out of other C's in our system / on our team ... say, Kadri will greatly benefit from a super elite Marner on his wing.

I look at the skill level of Marner over Strome, and I have no question I'm picking Marner over Strome.
 
That's a good point. Our tank isn't over yet though it's much harder to see a Babcock team finishing bottom 3-4. We'll see.
I don't expect us to finish bottom-5 either, but I expect us to finish around the bottom-10. As much as that is a wild guess at this point.

From there though, the top-3 picks in the draft will all be up for grabs in the lottery.
 
Back
Top