• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

You know I think Shanahan actually might have been putting in the tank in the off season by not going wild and just bringing in some nice low time pieces like Winnik and Santorelli. I think he was shocked, I really do, with how well the Leafs were playing at the time they were high up in the standing.

I think every GM whose team is bottom rung, has to have his eyes on the prize in this years draft. Some say even the second round will offer up some real gems.

I would fully expect and hope that Nonis(eek) trades some guys to at least get the second rounder replaced and much much more

If MLSE braintrust don't trade Phaneuf or Franson or both, then I have to tell you, I am going to be scratching my head for years. And if they can get rid of a guy I think is a great player but just cannot be counted on, Lupul, so much the better. Sad as that is too say.

I think losing Phaneuf and Franson however could really smoke the defence for years. We would be losing an enormous amount of experience and talent. If another McDavid were available next year, phew, we might have a shot at it if we let our two best Dmen go.

Trading Kessel? I suspect he might not care all that much himself, but again, what a talent to trade. Sure would hope the package is a good one.
 
Bob Mackenzie's mid-term top 60:

http://www.tsn.ca/mcdavid-the-unanimous-no-1-in-tsn-s-mid-season-ranking-1.193058

THE TOP 60

PLAYER TEAM POS HT WT GP G PTS
1. Connor McDavid Erie (OHL) C 6'1 187 25 23 66
2. Jack Eichel Boston U (NCAA) C 6'2 196 22 13 36
3. Noah Hanifin Boston C (NCAA) D 6'2 205 24 3 14
4. Dylan Strome Erie (OHL) C 6'3 187 45 30 85
5. Mitch Marner London (OHL) RW 5'11 164 45 35 93
6. Lawson Crouse Kingston (OHL) LW 6'3 212 32 16 23
7. Pavel Zacha Sarnia (OHL) C 6'3 210 26 11 23
8. Zach Werenski Michigan (NCAA) D 6'2 214 20 5 18
9. Mikko Rantanen TPS (Finland) RW 6'4 209 40 4 15
10. Mathew Barzal Seattle (WHL) C 6'0 177 20 7 18
11. Oliver Kylington AIK (Sweden1) D 6'0 174 16 4 7
12. Ivan Provorov Brandon (WHL) D 6'0 200 43 11 44
13. Kyle Connor Youngstown (USHL) C 6'1 182 31 14 39
14. Paul Bittner Portland (WHL) LW 6'4 202 45 21 39
15. Travis Konecny Ottawa (OHL) RW 5'10 171 43 20 42
16. Jakub Zboril Saint John (QMJHL) D 6'2 185 33 8 22
17. Brandon Carlo Tri-City (WHL) D 6'5 185 43 3 20
18. Colin White USA U-18 (USHL) C 6'0 183 7 0 5
19. Nick Merkley Kelowna (WHL) C 5'10 187 48 16 69
20. Timo Meier Halifax (QMJHL) RW 6'0 209 40 28 60
21. Evgeny Svechnikov Cape Breton (QMJHL) RW 6'3 205 38 19 49
22. Jordan Greenway USA U-18 (USHL) LW 6'5 223 9 2 8
23. Erik Cernak Kosice (SVK) D 6'3 203 34 5 8
24. Filip Chlapik Charl'town (QMJHL) C 6'1 190 44 23 52
25. Jeremy Roy Sherbrooke (QMJHL) D 6'0 182 40 5 39
26. Brock Boeser Waterloo (USHL) RW 6'1 192 32 23 40
27. Thomas Chabot Saint John (QMJHL) D 6'2 179 45 8 27
28. Jake Debrusk Swift Current (WHL) LW 6'0 177 49 28 49
29. Jeremy Bracco USA U-18 (USHL) RW 5'9 172 11 7 15
30. Nicolas Roy Chicoutimi (QMJHL) C 6'4 202 45 11 29
31. Jansen Harkins Prince George (WHL) C 6'1 180 49 17 58
32. Daniel Sprong Charl'town (QMJHL) RW 6'0 185 48 22 54
33. Jacob Larsson Frolunda (SWE) D 6'2 181 9 0 3
34. Nicolas Meloche B-Comeau (QMJHL) D 6'2 200 44 10 34
35. Adam Musil Red Deer (WHL) C 6'3 208 42 11 28
36. Mackenzie Blackwood Barrie (OHL) G 6'4 215 32 2.86 .913
37. Matthew Spencer Peterborough (OHL) D 6'2 200 42 5 24
38. Roope Hintz Ilves (FIN) LW 6'2 183 29 4 14
39. Christian Fischer USA U-18 (USHL) C 6'1 212 35 16 32
40. Nikita Korostelev Sarnia (OHL) RW 6'1 196 34 16 36
41. Filip Ahl HV71 Jr. (SWE JR) LW 6'4 214 23 12 30
42. Thomas Novak Waterloo (USHL) C 6'0 180 31 8 32
43. Joel Eriksson Ek Farjestad (SWE) C 6'2 183 21 2 3
44. Ryan Pilon Brandon (WHL) D 6'2 212 45 9 39
45. Jonas Siegenthaler ZSC (SUI) D 6'2 214 33 0 3
46. Daniel Vladar HC Kladno (CZE2) G 6'5 185 8 1.97 .933
47. Jakob F-Karlsson Omaha (USHL) C 6'1 192 35 10 39
48. Jens Looke Brynas (SWE) RW 6'0 187 34 2 6
49. Blake Speers S.S. Marie (OHL) RW 5'11 185 41 18 48
50. Samuel Montembeault B-Boisbriand (QMJHL) G 6'3 166 37 2.70 .891
51. Denis Guryanov Togliatti (RUS2) RW 6'2 183 22 15 25
52. Dennis Yan Shawinigan (QMJHL) LW 6'1 188 38 21 43
53. Alex Dergachyov S. Petersburg (RUS2) C 6'4 201 24 8 22
54. Noah Juulsen Everett (WHL) D 6'1 180 46 5 34
55. Guillaume Brisebois A-Bathurst (QMJHL) D 6'2 173 46 3 21
56. Ryan Gropp Seattle (WHL) LW 6'2 183 43 18 36
57. Matej Tomek Topeka (NAHL) G 6'3 181 24 1.59 .935
58. Anthony Beauvillier Shawinigan (QMJHL) C 5'10 181 47 33 72
59. Mitchell Stephens Saginaw (OHL) C 5'11 182 41 16 31
60. Graham Knott Niagara (OHL) LW 6'3 180 45 18 29
 
Obviously, you want to draft the best talent available, but what if we were looking at drafting that C, and outside of McDavid, I am assuming Strome is the first choice... but what about this Pavel Zacha... he has the size, but not the numbers of Strome... but he looks like he may be around where we pick.

What's your take on this big kid?
 
Obviously, you want to draft the best talent available, but what if we were looking at drafting that C, and outside of McDavid, I am assuming Strome is the first choice... but what about this Pavel Zacha... he has the size, but not the numbers of Strome... but he looks like he may be around where we pick.

What's your take on this big kid?

Statistically he hasn't been encouraging, but he's really young for this draft (turns 18 just 2 months before the draft). He has all the intangible stuff you want out of a big 1st line centre, but we haven't seen the offensive chops yet. He's one of those picks that an amateur scout really earns his money on. He could be anything from Radek Faksa II to Anze Kopitar II
 
If we end in a spot where we have to choose between Strome or Marner who do you lean towards?
 
If we end in a spot where we have to choose between Strome or Marner who do you lean towards?
Both of them have things to be concerned about. With Strome, it's his skating. With Marner, it's that we'd be adding yet another under-sized offense-first forward to the organization.

If I had a choice, I'd probably have to go with Strome.
 
If we end in a spot where we have to choose between Strome or Marner who do you lean towards?

Strome. I'm not that concerned about his skating. I see a kid who is, right now, who's at or ahead of where Ryan Johansen was at the same age.

I think, if this was any other draft year, Strome's a #1 pick.
 
Some of the top draft eligible CHL forwards by PPG...

McDavid 2.57
Marner 2.07
Strome 1.92
Meier 1.47
Merkley 1.37
Svechnikov 1.26
Chlapik 1.20
Barzal 1.05
Konecny 1.04
Bittner 0.91
Zacha 0.88
Crouse 0.80
 
So, here's a quick analysis of zeke's point.

McDavid goes out November 11th against Mississauga, comes back for the game Nov. 9

In that time?

14 points in 9 games without McDavid in November (8 goals, 6 assists)
13 points in 10 games without McDavid in December (4 goals, 9 assists)
5 points in 3 games without McDavid in January (3 goals, 2 assists)

That's 32 points in 22 games, a 1.45ppg pace.
He has 60 points in 26 games with McDavid in the lineup a 2.3ppg pace.

With McDavid, 36% of his points are goals.
Without McDavid, 47 % of his points are goals.

He is a good player with Connor, no doubt. But he's also a really good player without him.
 
So, here's a quick analysis of zeke's point.

McDavid goes out November 11th against Mississauga, comes back for the game Nov. 9

In that time?

14 points in 9 games without McDavid in November (8 goals, 6 assists)
13 points in 10 games without McDavid in December (4 goals, 9 assists)
5 points in 3 games without McDavid in January (3 goals, 2 assists)

That's 32 points in 22 games, a 1.45ppg pace.
He has 60 points in 26 games with McDavid in the lineup a 2.3ppg pace.

With McDavid, 36% of his points are goals.
Without McDavid, 47 % of his points are goals.

He is a good player with Connor, no doubt. But he's also a really good player without him.

1.45 is a whole lot different than 1.92, though. that's more kadri production (1.39) than tavares production (1.85).
 
I'd gladly take a Kadri with Strome's size. Strome is a year younger than Kadri in his draft year too.

Clearly there is a McDavid effect there. IMO he's not a Tavares, MacKinnon level of talent, but I haven't seen enough of him yet.
 
1.45 is a whole lot different than 1.92, though. that's more kadri production (1.39) than tavares production (1.85).

Yeah, but you can't totally remove McDavid without factoring in the great players who played with the other guys who went #1 (Tavares-MacLean/Kadri), (Hall - Ellis), (McKinnon - Drouin), (Yakupov-Galchenyuk)
 
so who do you take then instead?

I'd probably take strome.

but this draft is really all about mcdavid.

marner's stats are kind of hard to ignore though. 2+ ppg is a pretty rare feat for a 17yr old.

to be honest you're in just as good a position at 5/6/7 as at 3/4 I think.
 
Back
Top