Jays and I were having this debate last week.
Say we were to grab another first round pick.
Would you package our two later firsts if it allowed you to trade up from say 21 and 28 to 12 or 13?
Jays was in favour of drafting quantity. My argument was because this is such a forward-heavy first round, you should try to load up on the high end talent if possible.
With the possibility of a Rantanen, Barzal or Zacha sliding out of the Top Ten, or even tempting prospects like Meier and Konecny hanging around that neighbourhood, there might be a lot more value in having say the 4th and 12th picks than the 4th, 21st and 28th.
I wouldn't.
In fact, if I were you guys, assuming you got another first round pick from someone, I would look to trade down in a similar trade that you guys made with Anaheim in 2009. 22nd pick for the 30th & 42nd.
Imo, in the Leafs situation of virtually no prospect depth and no second round pick this year, 5th + 25th + 30th + 42nd > 5th + 12th
There's going to be a lot of good players left early in the second.
I wouldn't.
In fact, if I were you guys, assuming you got another first round pick from someone, I would look to trade down in a similar trade that you guys made with Anaheim in 2009. 22nd pick for the 30th & 42nd.
Imo, in the Leafs situation of virtually no prospect depth and no second round pick this year, 5th + 25th + 30th + 42nd > 5th + 12th
There's going to be a lot of good players left early in the second.
The odds of pulling a quality NHL'er out of the top 15 >>>>
I also have to challenge the idea of the Leafs having "virtually no prospect depth". We have 3 centres with legitimate middle 6 or better upside (Nylander, Verhaege, Gauthier), 4 wingers (Leipsic, Leivo, Brown, Johnson), and a small pile of defenders (Percy, Finn, Valiev, Loov, Granberg)
It's lacking in sexy prospects outside of Nylander, but that's a fair bit of prospect depth.
I honestly don't see much there.
Outside of Nylander, which one of those guys are surefire NHLers regardless of their position in a lineup?
A lot of maybes and projects that are a work in progress.
By middle 6, you mean a 1st or 2nd line center?
Gauthier's a third line center on a basement dweller. I don't think he's anything more than a fourth line center on a good team. Offense almost seems like a foreign concept to him.
Leipsic, Leivo & Brown are interesting and have a chance to make it, but none of them are shoe-ins. Need work
And none of those d-men really excite me. Percy, Finn, Granberg all scream bottom pairing d-men if they make it. Valiev & Loov I don't know enough about.
Percy is a surefire NHL'er, probably makes this season if the blueline wasn't logjammed.
Gauthier about as sure a thing for a 3rd line C role as a floor as you're going to get as well.
Leipsic is also a pretty good bet for at least a 3rd line role.
All prospects are relatively volatile though, that's just the name of the game. How many current Habs prospects are surefire NHL'ers? Probably not as many as you would suggest.
Yet he manages to put up a PPG in the Q every year.
Percy is a bottom pairing calibre NHL defender now. Finn's ceiling will be determined by his skating, if it's just good enough to not be an impediment, he has more than enough puck skills and hockey sense to carve out a 2nd pairing role. Granberg is probably a 4-5, but developing those guys is important to. Every time you develop one of those in house, that's one less time you have to go shopping for Mike Komisarek. That's the whole point of the word "depth".
Percy actually just recently got back into the Marlies after being out for a while with a concussion. So, there's that, and also the fact that they appear to have decided to insulate all of their best prospects from the shit-show up in the NHL this year. That's why, in spite of his strong scoring numbers, Connor Brown's stayed in the AHL all year while the likes of Sam Carrick, Trevor Smith & Troy Bodie have been called up instead. Ditto with William Nylander and Brendan Leipsic.So that's why Granberg & Holzer are playing instead of him?
...
Like I mentioned earlier, if Percy's an NHL d-man now, why is Holzer playing in front of him? I can maybe see the reason for Granberg, even though I don't see much in him. Holzer's 27 and has never shown that he's good enough to play in the NHL.
Yeah, we're agreed there. I've got very little enthusiasm for Gauthier as a prospect. I think his upside is pretty much "a smaller Brian Boyle".Floor??? If everything, and I mean everything goes well, he's a third line center.
So that's why Granberg & Holzer are playing instead of him?
Floor??? If everything, and I mean everything goes well, he's a third line center.
Don't disagree, but he's a ways away.
The ones we have that were surefire are almost all in the NHL. Prior to this season, the prospects we had I'd consider surefire were Beaulieu, Jacob de la Rose, Charles Hudon & Nikita Scherbak. Beaulieu's not a prospect anymore, de la Rose isn't a prospect anymore (unless something shocking happens, he's never going back to the AHL), Hudon's going to make the NHL, but at what position/effectiveness I'm not sure. Scherbak is probably a year away from being a full-time NHLer. The rest are works in process.
Am I supposed to be impressed that one of the biggest players in the Q only puts up a PPG in the weakest of the three major junior leagues? He should be destroying that league, but he isn't. This is not even slightly concerning to you?
Like I mentioned earlier, if Percy's an NHL d-man now, why is Holzer playing in front of him? I can maybe see the reason for Granberg, even though I don't see much in him. Holzer's 27 and has never shown that he's good enough to play in the NHL.
So do you also consider the Habs to have no prospect depth?