• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

Same as saying can they ignore Strome's size?

you can't ignore his size but there are so many other attributes to consider before you start placing emphasis on size

You can't let that be a deciding factor unless you consider both guys interchangeable

At the moment based on numbers and all scouting reports I would lean towards Marner if it came down to both being available
 
IMO in todays NHL skating is more important than size.

The real question is can you ignore Strome's skating when picking between the two.
 
I watched Strome, I see Jason Allison. Allison had a ton of talent, but no zip. Can that work in today's NHL. Lets ask Joe Thornton.
 
can't say I disagree, though Allison is a bit of an exaggeration.

then again, Allison was friggin awesome prior to injuries.
 
Is Strome's skating THAT bad though?? I don't think so. I don't think he has superb skating, but I think his skating is average, at worst.

You can't draft just size, but at the same time I don't think Strome is just size.
 
You can't be a terrible skater and be ranked top 5.

And all of these factors are important - scoring, size, skating. I'm happy with either of the kids.
 
Allison excelled in a completely different game. The game is so much faster now.

Strome isn't a terrible skater, but he isn't a good skater. More importantly he isn't an elite skater which Marner is. And IMO that outweighs the size advantage.

That is what we are talking about here, comparing those two. Its not a "one is awesome and one stinks" kind of thing.
 
The thing is, much is made of Marner's size, but he's no shrimp.

Given his scoring and skating, he's emerged as my choice too right now.
 
Marner is not THAT small either. He's listed as 5'11 on most sites, which yes, does make him an under-sized NHLer, but it's not like he's Martin St.Louis size.

And he's also 18, if he grows another inch he's 6'0, and at 6' his size isn't that much of a factor anymore.
 
I'd be happy with either.

First, no Strome's skating is nowhere near as bad as some have tried to portray it. You have a kid who was drafted to the OHL at 6'0" whose grown to 6'3" and it adjusting to a longer stride. His edges and balance are very good. He's not slow. He's got that Sundin stride where it doesn't look like he's doing a lot but he's actually moving well.

Second, Marner's height isn't the problem. While I think the 5'11" is a generous listing, it's his build. This is a slight kid. most sites list him sub-170. His skating, hands and Hockey IQ are all first class. He could fill out, the same way Strome's stride could continue to get more efficient.
 
Sundin was a 6'5 230lb gorilla on skates.

I've watched Strome maybe 3 times now, and have come back unimpressed with his skating. The rest of his game is excellent. He slows the game down to his speed and dominates. Not sure if that slow speed will transfer over, but he really needs to work on his skating. I believe he can do it. But if he can't we are looking at a guy that will have trouble creating space for himself.
 
Spezza might be a good comparison, but everything i've read has said how advanced Strome's defensive game is for his age.

A defensively responsible Jason Spezza is probably a heart candidate in his prime.
 
I have to go with Marner. Go with the talent model. IMO. I like Strome actually. But I see Allison. Lots of Allison. Brilliant mind, stick but the legs don't want to cooperate. If he turns out to be as good as Thornton, I eat a dish of Schenn Shrimp.
 
Hurts me that we have to have this debate with two potential superstars available, after this horrific year. Can't even tank right :banghead:
 
The top 5 looks good to me. Any of McDavid, Eichel, Hanifin, Strome, or Marner and i am a happy enough camper with the garbage we put up with.

But we know the second any of them are drafted by the Leafs they go from potential superstar to overrated with questionable work ethic in the media.
 
Back
Top