• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

Less of a fan than I am when it comes to Marner or Strome. There's actually a part of me that prefers Werenski and Provorov. I think Hanifin ends up in ARZ and both the player and franchise will be better off.

I get this feeling that Arizona ends up last and gets McDavid.

They're incredibly bad, and like us, have given up. Buffalo actually shows some scrappiness, and I think it will cost them.
 
I don't get all the hoopla over these other guys. We'll simply draft McDavid after winning the lotto. :sarcasm
 
I was looking up statistics for previously drafted players. I was looking for players comparable to Marner and Strome.

One that really got me was:

Mitchell Marner 5'11 175lb 62gp 124pts 2.0ppg
Sam Gagner 5'11 185lb 53gp 118pts 2.23ppg

Gagner when drafted came in and put up 49 points in his rookie season. That was his best year point production wise. What happened to this guy? Injuries? Concussions?

Not saying it'll happen but if we draft Gagner part 2 i'll cry.
 
Sam Gagner may have had a similar point total to Marner, but he was also third on his team in scoring in his draft season, behind Sergei Kostitsyn and some guy named Patrick Kane. And I'm assuming that those two guys also happened to be Gagner's wingers.

Mitch Marner, on the other hand, is leading the OHL in scoring, and has 17 more points than his nearest teammate.
 
Yeah Gagner played with a guy who scored 70 points in the NHL the next year, became one of the best players in the NHL, and was old enough to play in the NHL, just a late birthday. That is more similar to Strome's situation than Marner's. But either way I wouldn't worry about it. Gagner is like the only exception that didn't become a top line NHLer for players that put up those kind of numbers in their 17 year old seasons.
 
I still think I'd prefer Strome, but if Leafs got Marner instead I would not be disappointed at all.
 
Marner has some quality linemates as far as the OHL is concerned. Kane developing into one of the best players in the world doesn't take away the fact that Gagner produced excellent numbers.

Didn't Gagner get hurt? Maybe thats why he didn't develop into much after a good rookie season. That and being an Oiler.
 
Marner has some quality linemates as far as the OHL is concerned. Kane developing into one of the best players in the world doesn't take away the fact that Gagner produced excellent numbers.

Didn't Gagner get hurt? Maybe thats why he didn't develop into much after a good rookie season. That and being an Oiler.
He does. But do you honestly not see the big difference between being by far the best player on your line, and the third-best player on a line by a considerable margin?

Marner and Gagner just aren't a good comparison.
 
If we do draft Marner i hope he doesn't follow a Gagner-like development.

Hypothetical:

At the moment lets say that Shanahan and Co are ready to move on from Kessel in the offseason. Now say we win the McDavid sweepstakes. Does that change their tune on trading Kessel? Kessel on McDavid's wing does sound appealing from an offensive standpoint.

McDavid would likely make Kessel a 40-40 player again. As opposed to Bozak dragging the line down.
 
Corey Pronman wrote an article today about how 3/4 should take Strome and Marner before Hanifin. (I personally dont see the Oilers passing on Hanifin if they sit 3rd)

What direction do the Leafs go in if we pick 4th and Hanifin and one of Strome/Marner are on the board.
 
I think Mirtle tweeted that if the leafs go 1-8-1 in the last 10 games, they would have a 24% chance at third overall.

I think that is a tough call there then. Like Artnes said. Defenseman sometimes drop a few spots because they take more time to mature and develop into top pairing D. If we do get the third, or if we stay at five and Hanafin is there along with one of Strome or Marner is he truly the BPA??

I also heard today that the leafs have not drafted a first line centre since Daryl Sittler.... Sundin, Gilmour et al were all acquired through trades.

I know it goes against what many here say in that you draft on talent not on need. But the the talent between a Strome/Marner that much less than Hanafin?
Look at how far Seth Jones dropped.
 
If Strome's gone, I'd take Marner....I haven't seen too much separating Hanifin from Werenski, but I'll need to see him in the Frozen Faceoff tournament.
 
At this point, I think EDM or ARZ take Hanifin 3rd. I'd take Strome there.

And I agree with Metal, I don't see much separating him from Werenski......or Provorov for that matter.
 
I think Strome is better for "team-building" while Hanifin is good addition to a team looking to get to the next level, like Edmonton. He's a defenceman the Oilers sorely lack.
 
Hanifin-Nurse-Klefbom-Schultz would be a really nice top 4. Would definitely compliment the Hall-RNH-Eberle-Yak-LD group up front and turn Edmonton into a legitimate threat.
 
I think Strome is better for "team-building" while Hanifin is good addition to a team looking to get to the next level, like Edmonton. He's a defenceman the Oilers sorely lack.

Is this due to him being the prototypical big centre we have been crying for since Sundin?

I think he would be an great addition and would compliment Nylander on the future top line but I continue to read about Marner and its hard to overlook the creativity and agility he has.

One constant remark I continue to see is he has the ability to make defencemen look stupid with his patience and speed.

Its close but I am still leaning towards wanting Marner but will stoked if we picked Strome as well.
 
I'll be very surprised if Hanifin doesn't go 3rd. McDavid 1st, Eichel 2nd and Hanifin 3rd is almost a foregone conclusion. Which means if we don't win the lottery, the most likely scenario for us is we walk away with Strome or Marner.

(but I won't complain 1 bit if we end up with Hanifin at 4th ... Hanifin - Rielly will be a deadly top unit for years to come)

As for Marner vs. Strome, isn't Marner a winger? Some sites list him as a winger and some as a center. I think all things being equal, centers > wingers.
 
Marner is being projected as a winger, but he plays as a C. The same way a lot of people project Nylander as a W, but he seems to have all the skills you want out of a C. Smallish centres tend to have to prove themselves to people that they can stick as C's in the NHL when bigger C's tend to not have to.

Kadri was being projected by a lot of people as a W for a fairly long while too and we see how silly a projection that turned out to be.
 
While that's true on Kadri, I dunno if a lot of people project Kadri to be a W ... it was just Wilson as far as I can remember :)

I guess my question is - Kadri and Nylander are natural C's, and they played C through their junior careers. Is Marner the same?
 
Back
Top