• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

Then I pray for a 3rd for 4th swap so they can take Hanifin and give us a 2nd in consideration for it.

The thing is we don't know which team (Buffalo, Arizona, Toronto, Edmonton) gets Mcdavid and Eichel, that impacts things. If somehow Buffalo and Arizona get the top 2, I'd think Edmonton would take Hanifin but then again its the Oilers so....
 
If Edm really wants Hafinin and we're picking 3rd do you think we could swap picks with them in exchange for something?
 
Yes.

Not a whole lot, but at least an extra pick or two somewhere between the 2nd & 4th rounds.
swapping picks between consecutive picks will not get you much ... there's no "kadri moment" here, so if the guy they want is also the guy we plan to pick, we won't trade them. IF the guy they want is NOT the guy we wanna pick, then they'll be able to get him ANYWAYS. It's just for that little security and why should they pay extra for him?
 
Was bored and putting off studying so... FYI.

CHL players in the Central Scouting top 50 that are 1.2 PPG+ as a 17 year old...
Player, PPG (Rank)
McDavid 2.55 (1st)
Marner 2.00 (5th)
Strome 1.90 (6th)
Meier 1.48 (12th)
Svechnikov 1.42 (21st)
Beauvillier 1.40 (49th)
Barzal 1.30 (9th)
Strong 1.29 (20th)
Merkley 1.25 (13th)

Between PPG and 1.2...
Speers 1.18 (44th)
Chlapik 1.17 (17th)
Trenin 1.16 (50th)
Konecny 1.13 (26th)
Harkins 1.13 (18th)
DeBrusk 1.13 (24th)
Yan 1.08 (35th)
Bittner 1.08 (19th)

CHL Under PPG in Top 50 of CSS
Korostelev 0.96 (41st)
Zacha 0.92 (8th)
Crouse 0.91 (4th)
Gagne 0.88 (48th)
Gawdin 0.75 (37th)
Roy 0.74 (25th)
Marsh 0.73 (42nd)
Wagner 0.64 (43rd)
Musil 00.59 (32nd)
 
Last edited:
What is up with Beauvillier ?

Don't know a thing about him myself but this is what draftsite.com says:

Slippery undersized left winger from the Q who compact stride give him short areas rocket bursts in the attack zone. Plays with intensity and sneaks into the open spot to receive passes. Not the best shortest player on the puck when he carries for long periods.
—Bill Placzek—


(He's 5'10, 172lbs)
 
swapping picks between consecutive picks will not get you much ... there's no "kadri moment" here, so if the guy they want is also the guy we plan to pick, we won't trade them. IF the guy they want is NOT the guy we wanna pick, then they'll be able to get him ANYWAYS. It's just for that little security and why should they pay extra for him?

I don't know about that. Moving up from 7 to 5 to get Luke Schenn cost us a pretty penny. If the 4 slot really wants Hanifin, they'll pay to move up and get him.
 
I don't know about that. Moving up from 7 to 5 to get Luke Schenn cost us a pretty penny. If the 4 slot really wants Hanifin, they'll pay to move up and get him.
It's a little different to move from 7 to 5, than from 4 to 3.

I mean, they pretty much know we're not picking Hanifin (otherwise why would we trade 3rd to them for 4th? We'd just pick Hanifin and there's no trade) so even if they do NOTHING they'd end up with Hanifin in all likelihood. They know we're not gonna pick Hanifin just because EDM doesn't trade with us.

Now, the only reason they'd pay SOMETHING to us is fear of us trading down from 3rd to say, 5th, and then the team who trades with us grab Hanifin. But by doing that, we'll get the leftover of Strome and Marner that EDM doesn't take. They know the likelihood of that is also not really high ... plus, knowing TOR, they know for sure we won't trade lower than 5th and end up with NEITHER of Strome / Marner. This means this trade possibility is limited to 1 team (5th) only.

If we trade down from 3rd (let's say we have the 3rd) to 5th we'll get SOMETHING. 3rd to 4th I think we'll get very little, if anything.
 
It's a little different to move from 7 to 5, than from 4 to 3.

I mean, they pretty much know we're not picking Hanifin (otherwise why would we trade 3rd to them for 4th? We'd just pick Hanifin and there's no trade) so even if they do NOTHING they'd end up with Hanifin in all likelihood. They know we're not gonna pick Hanifin just because EDM doesn't trade with us.

Now, the only reason they'd pay SOMETHING to us is fear of us trading down from 3rd to say, 5th, and then the team who trades with us grab Hanifin. But by doing that, we'll get the leftover of Strome and Marner that EDM doesn't take. They know the likelihood of that is also not really high ... plus, knowing TOR, they know for sure we won't trade lower than 5th and end up with NEITHER of Strome / Marner. This means this trade possibility is limited to 1 team (5th) only.

If we trade down from 3rd (let's say we have the 3rd) to 5th we'll get SOMETHING. 3rd to 4th I think we'll get very little, if anything.


http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sports/hockey/draft02/trades.htm
o. 2 (Atlanta/Florida): Florida trades third-round pick (No. 82 overall, later traded) and 2003 fourth-round pick to Atlanta for Thrashers' promise not to draft Jay Bouwmeester at No. 2 overall on June 22, 2002.

You're looking at this too formulaically. It comes down to whether or not the 4 spot (assuming we're 3rd) wants Hanifin or not, and how much more they value Hanifin over Strome, Marner, etc. If they put a lot of value on Hanifin, it doesn't matter who they think we want (and we'd be bloody fools to tell them that we didn't want the consensus #3 pick). They inquire, you tell them that you're not sure who, that you like all 3 but are leaning Hanifin (the consensus pick at this point), but that you're open to moving down if they really want Hanifin. If they want to get "their guy", they'll have to pay to make sure that they do. Or you do them an even bigger solid by doing a deal similar to the one I quoted and simply make a promise to not draft their guy, for a cost. This would also save them some cap dollars on that player's ELC by taking Hanifin 4th instead of 3rd. We get the 1C we want, and a few other ~3rd round picks. Win-win.
 
Fair enough, but all Atlanta got was a 3rd rounder and a 4th rounder only ... that, to me, seems to agree with my point of view - it is the 'better than nothing' package.
 
Well, yeah you aren't going to get Eberle, or next years 1st, to move down a spot.

But if you end up with the player you were going to pick anyway, any extra early picks are a good bonus.
 
Back
Top