• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

I don't recall that trade.

All they got was a promise?? How was that a valid deal with no true asset going the other way?

What could we get for a promise to not laugh at them next year when they finish last no matter who they pick?
 
Well, you need something going back the other way but that is just paperwork ... they can easily 'trade' a 7th rounder to the Oils for 3rd and 4th later to 'complete' that trade.

Since it's just 3rd and 4th, words is all you need.
 
I don't recall that trade.

All they got was a promise?? How was that a valid deal with no true asset going the other way?

What could we get for a promise to not laugh at them next year when they finish last no matter who they pick?
I'm pretty sure that all trades have to include an asset now, but that wasn't the rule at the time.

Remember all the trades for "future considerations", or "a player to be named later"?

I mean, teams still do make essentially deals for nothing, but the "nothing" instead takes the form of conditional late round draft picks, like our Ashton/Broll for a conditional 7th rounder trade with Tampa Bay prior to the deadline.
 
Conditional pick or future considerations at least implies a player going back.

Promise not to pick someone is hilarious.

Wonder if a pinky swear would've upped the value to a 1st rounder.
 
Effectively its a swap of picks, without swapping picks.

Florida just gave Atlanta two picks for nothing most likely.
 
Conditional pick or future considerations at least implies a player going back.

Promise not to pick someone is hilarious.

Wonder if a pinky swear would've upped the value to a 1st rounder.
But you are not talking about trading from 27th to 1st either ... you are talking about swapping consecutive picks.

NHL is very much a old boys' club, swapping consecutive picks with the delta being 2 very minor late picks, GMs feel comfortable going by just words.
 
Fair enough, but all Atlanta got was a 3rd rounder and a 4th rounder only ... that, to me, seems to agree with my point of view - it is the 'better than nothing' package.

If you turn one of those 3rd or 4th into a player, it will sure feel like something, no? Filpulla went 13 picks after that 82nd overall. Stempniak went shortly after the 2003 4th as well...and while he's no prize himself, he did land Alex Steen in trade.
 
Conditional pick or future considerations at least implies a player going back.

Promise not to pick someone is hilarious.

Wonder if a pinky swear would've upped the value to a 1st rounder.
In the official NHL record, I'm sure it was recorded as "future considerations".
 
If you turn one of those 3rd or 4th into a player, it will sure feel like something, no? Filpulla went 13 picks after that 82nd overall. Stempniak went shortly after the 2003 4th as well...and while he's no prize himself, he did land Alex Steen in trade.
That makes no sense.

I am saying when you flip consecutive picks you don't get much in return.

You're saying no, it has been done, and it got Atlanta 3rd and 4th rounders!

I said 3rd and 4th rounders = not much in return, exactly what I said, nevertheless it's better than nothing.

And you said "Oh but 3rd and 4th rounder can turn into a NHLer too!"

Bro, you're essentially agreeing with my very initial point - it gets you very little, but it's still better than nothing. :)
 
How are free 3rd and 4th rounders very little??

It's a shot at a player in the top 100.

All in exchange for flipping spots to take the guy you were going to take anyway.
 
How is 3rd and 4th rounder not very little???!

They are SOMETHING, but in the grand scheme of things, when 3rd rounder has all but 30% chance of turning into a NHLer, and 4th round pick has 20%. Combined, they have a combined chance of turning into half a NHLer LOL.

You can sure come up with examples of how Datsyuk was drafted in the 5th round or Kaberle was drafted into the 7th round, and yes, every pick is a lottery ticket, if you have 1 more ticket you have 1 more chance in drafting a NHL player. It doesn't change the fact in the grand scheme of NHL trades, the value of a 3rd rounder and 4th rounders are worth V-E-R-Y L-I-T-T-L-E.

It's better than nothing, but it's very little. I said that in my very first post.

If you can't even agree with that I give up.
 
If we could somehow pry Edmonton's 2nd Rounder away......

Let's keep in mind, I think Edmonton has two excellent 2nd rounders to play with.

First is their own, and second is Buffalo's 2nd from Montreal in the Petry trade (via the Gorges trade). Those could be 31st and 32nd overall.
 
How is 3rd and 4th rounder not very little???!

They are SOMETHING, but in the grand scheme of things, when 3rd rounder has all but 30% chance of turning into a NHLer, and 4th round pick has 20%. Combined, they have a combined chance of turning into half a NHLer LOL.

You can sure come up with examples of how Datsyuk was drafted in the 5th round or Kaberle was drafted into the 7th round, and yes, every pick is a lottery ticket, if you have 1 more ticket you have 1 more chance in drafting a NHL player. It doesn't change the fact in the grand scheme of NHL trades, the value of a 3rd rounder and 4th rounders are worth V-E-R-Y L-I-T-T-L-E.

It's better than nothing, but it's very little. I said that in my very first post.

If you can't even agree with that I give up.

Then give up.

Guys that we are very high on who are former 3rd rounders include Leipsic, Verhaeghe and Valiev.

A guy who we're even higher on in Brown is a former 6th rounder. Andreas Johnson in the SEL a 7th.

Don't act like these are worthless picks. They quite often pan out well, as a pick is only as good as your scouting anyway.
 
Edmonton with all those picks, we really should make a move for some of them.

Bozak and Phaneuf could help that team big time i would think.
 
Back
Top