• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

What is the difference between "trading as many assets as possible" and "deliberately sabotaging a season"? Its the same thing. When you trade all of your assets it is deliberately sabotaging the team.

100% the Buffalo Sabres plan was to finish as low as possible this year and go for McDavid. And that plan has been in the works for a couple years now.
 
Didn't Buffalo trade both their first and second string tender at the time?

That is the definition of deliberate tanking.
 
An interesting point, if the Penguins end up falling out of the playoffs: Ryan Rishaug of TSN has confirmed that the Penguins did not put any lottery protection on the first round pick they traded to the Oilers. So, Edmonton could end up having two tickets to the McDavid lottery.

Excellent...because the ****ing thought of Pittsburgh getting McDavid makes me puke.

I spent a bit of time with the adjusted numbers yesterday and you could argue that Pittsburgh has had the 2nd, 4th, ~10th, & 20th best forwards of all time on their team over the last 25 years. Embarrassment of riches....**** them.
 
Excellent...because the ****ing thought of Pittsburgh getting McDavid makes me puke.

I spent a bit of time with the adjusted numbers yesterday and you could argue that Pittsburgh has had the 2nd, 4th, ~10th, & 20th best forwards of all time on their team over the last 25 years. Embarrassment of riches....**** them.

And it's not like they had just Crosby or Lemieux... they had Lemieux + Jagr, and now Crosby + Malkin. So yes, **** them.
 
Excellent...because the ****ing thought of Pittsburgh getting McDavid makes me puke.

I spent a bit of time with the adjusted numbers yesterday and you could argue that Pittsburgh has had the 2nd, 4th, ~10th, & 20th best forwards of all time on their team over the last 25 years. Embarrassment of riches....**** them.
Yeah, the thought of Pittsburgh having any chance of ending up with McDavid was pretty vomit-inducing, considering they've had Malkin/Crosby for this generation, and had Lemieux/Jagr/Francis in the previous generation. That ****ing franchise has more than filled its quota of generational talents.
 
Since 1980, the Pittsburgh Penguins have received 27 of the top 250 offensive seasons of all time from Lemieux, Jagr, Crosby, Malkin, Francis, Kovalev, & Dr Recchi

The Leafs have had 1, from Doug Gilmour.
 
Since 1980, the Pittsburgh Penguins have received 27 of the top 250 offensive seasons of all time from Lemieux, Jagr, Crosby, Malkin, Francis, Kovalev, & Dr Recchi

The Leafs have had 1, from Doug Gilmour.
Reason #10,123 why it's about time we catch a goddamned break and win this draft lottery.
 
The fact the Pens is on the verge of missing the playoff WITH both Malkin and Crosby in their lineup has gotta be a little embarrassing for Rutherford imo ...

And Bylsma is probably laughing out loud somewhere if they do miss it.
 
Button's draft rankings should never be taken seriously. That Elliot Gould wannabe was a terrible scouting director. There's a reason why his personal rankings always deviate so radically from the established CSS and ISS ones.
 
ISS has Crouse ahead of Marner. I dont get that one

There are a few mocks that i've seen with Crouse in the top 5. Everyone raves about his "matured" game and how he is defensively responsible. Not even a PPG in his draft year is a bit of cause for concern i guess. Scouts see something in this guy and the 2 or 3 times i've watched him i was impressed. Just not impressed enough to take him ahead of Strome or Marner.

This board would go up in flames if we took Crouse over Strome or Marner.
 
That one is probably size-based. It's silly, but Crouse has a lot more individual skill and offensive talent than many on here seem to think. He's a really good two-way player and has David Backes upside.

I'd still rank them:

1. McDavid
2. Eichel
3. Strome
4. Hanifin
5. Marner
6. Provorov
7. Werenski

And then Crouse battling it out with a bunch of other names in the 8-12 range.
 
No, they will go with Hanifin I think. Too tempting to not take the potential franchise rearguard there, even though Oil Change has issues everywhere on the roster and are hardly in a position to overlook the centre if they believe he is BPA.
 
One can go on and on about a guy's "tools", "individual skill", etc. but I think it'll always concern me when the production isn't there. Why isn't the skill leading to points? Why are nearly all the CHL forwards in the top 50 of Central's list outproducing him? Another team can take a chance that the production will come. Not us and not at 4/5/6.
 
One can go on and on about a guy's "tools", "individual skill", etc. but I think it'll always concern me when the production isn't there. Why isn't the skill leading to points? Why are nearly all the CHL forwards in the top 50 of Central's list outproducing him? Another team can take a chance that the production will come. Not us and not at 4/5/6.
It scares the hell out of me when a scout's description of the player starts with "size", "grit", "poise", "leadership", "two-way play", etc. Those are all great qualities that I want players on this team to have, but unless the first thing that impresses you about a prospect is their high-end skill, I don't want the Leafs going anywhere near them with a pick anywhere in the first round. If you're Luke Schenn or Tyler Biggs and simply don't have the talent to be a good NHLer, it doesn't matter if you have the rest of that crap in spades.

Another thing that sets off alarm bells for me is the fact that Crouse, in both of his OHL seasons, has scored more goals than assists. Now, maybe that's a symptom of him not having a lot of talent around him, but more often than not, I'd say that it's a sign that you're a Clarkson-esque player that has a good shot, but lacks the skill or vision to generate offense on your own, or for the players around you.
 
.86 ppg should be enough for him to drop in the rankings. Those are not top 10 numbers let alone top 5
 
What is the difference between "trading as many assets as possible" and "deliberately sabotaging a season"? Its the same thing. When you trade all of your assets it is deliberately sabotaging the team.

100% the Buffalo Sabres plan was to finish as low as possible this year and go for McDavid. And that plan has been in the works for a couple years now.

So Jonas is really the GM of the Buffalo Sabres?
 
Back
Top