• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

We have them among us as well. Been going back and forth with a blogger on twitter trying to justify Crouse being a top 5 talent and arguing CS rankings trump everyone else.
 
We have them among us as well. Been going back and forth with a blogger on twitter trying to justify Crouse being a top 5 talent and arguing CS rankings trump everyone else.
Just tell the blogger to google "appeal to authority fallacy", do some reading and then STFU.
 
Picking Crouse would really fly right in the face of everything they've been saying lately though about using statistics to catch when your eyes are being lying SOBs. I'd be really surprised if they took him based on what Dubas has been talking about.

Carolina fans seem to reallly like Crouse so I hope they get exactly what they want.
Either just win the McDavid lottery, or, at least stay at 5th and pick Strome / Marner and make Crouse a completely moot point.
 
I'll have to see if I can find that Hunter interview posted online, and give it a listen. If they just specifically asked for his opinion about Crouse, it makes sense that he'd give positive comments. I mean, what else is he going to say? It's not like he's going to tell everyone that they don't have any interest in him.
 
Your reasoning is based on some seriously flawed assumptions. But I've given up trying to talk sense into you - continue to advocate for the team you support having a WORSE DRAFT PICK.

Don't try to less than smoothly step up to the mic to talk shit for no reason.

As I said, I know exactly where we're at and what the implications are. 1 and 4 are the only acceptable slots for our first rounder for me.
 
Don't try to less than smoothly step up to the mic to talk shit for no reason.

As I said, I know exactly where we're at and what the implications are. 1 and 4 are the only acceptable slots for our first rounder for me.

I wasn't trying to talk 'shit'. But if I was, your asinine stance on our draft position provides ample reason.
 
We have them among us as well. Been going back and forth with a blogger on twitter trying to justify Crouse being a top 5 talent and arguing CS rankings trump everyone else.

So funny.

In the last 10 drafts, there have been 27 CHL forwards taken with Top 5 picks.

All 27 had better draft year production than Crouse. 70+% of them had 1.4 ppg or better at only 17 years old.

Not really sure what scouts are seeing with their eyetest that makes it okay to rank him Top 5.
 
I wasn't trying to talk 'shit'. But if I was, your asinine stance on our draft position provides ample reason.

You start off by commenting on wasn't I the guy who wanted to be in 4th, as though it was inconsistent with what I was saying.

When it became apparent that it was not, then you turned it into an opportunity to start talking shit about that subject again.

There's nothing asinine about wanting every single star to align so that we can get a 6"3 OHL scoring champ center from Toronto.

If finishing 3rd means they take a college dman, and ending up with 6th means getting ****ed with a guy like Crouse, then I want 4th, with 5th as the consolation prize. I could give a shit about the 2% improvement in odds of landing 1st overall by finishing in 3rd.
 
He's just appreciating the irony that you idiotically wanted the team to win so they wouldn't pick 3rd without even considering the unintended consequences of winning.

You can get Strome at 3. Can't at 6. Maybe not even 5th.

Winning didn't help your cause, just like everyone told you it wouldn't.
 
You start off by commenting on wasn't I the guy who wanted to be in 4th, as though it was inconsistent with what I was saying.

When it became apparent that it was not, then you turned it into an opportunity to start talking shit about that subject again.

There's nothing asinine about wanting every single star to align so that we can get a 6"3 OHL scoring champ center from Toronto.

If finishing 3rd means they take a college dman, and ending up with 6th means getting ****ed with a guy like Crouse, then I want 4th, with 5th as the consolation prize. I could give a shit about the 2% improvement in odds of landing 1st overall by finishing in 3rd.

The third overall pick gives us a greater likelihood and ability to draft Strome than 4th overall.

I can't believe we're still having this discussion.
 
He's just appreciating the irony that you idiotically wanted the team to win so they wouldn't pick 3rd without even considering the unintended consequences of winning.

You can get Strome at 3. Can't at 6. Maybe not even 5th.

Winning didn't help your cause, just like everyone told you it wouldn't.

Moron - I wanted them to win just enough to stay where they are, not go down and not move up.

Lest you think otherwise, it's not actually in my ability to cause them to do one or the other. I simply have a preference, just like anyone.

And if Hanifin goes at 3rd, I don't want the Leafs taking the so-called BPA who is a college dman over just as easily the true BPA who is a hometown hulking elite first line center. I want that possibility removed from reality. If it turns out Edmonton takes Strome over Hanifin, so be it. All I can do then is hope we take Marner over Hanifin.
 
Draft strategy should be to take BEST PLAYER AVAILABLE.

By the time any of the prospects are ready for prime time our organizational needs will have changed.
 
BPA is subjective. And for a potentially marginal, perceived, and maybe non-existent edge that one player may have over another in projections, supposed BPA ignores completely team need.

However much "better" a dman at 3 (who plays in a difficult to gauge league) may be than a center at 4, I'll absorb in order to get a hometown first line center.
 
Stop arguing with this dummy. Anyone who would take a lesser player because they were born in the GTA is not worth the pages of discussion.
 
For many scouts, the difference between Strome and Hanifin is negligible. One team is getting a first line franchise centre. The other team is getting a cornerstone defenceman.

I'm relatively confident we'd be able to grab Strome at 4.
 
I don't care what the position is i want the best player available. I want the best player in the minds of Mark Hunter/Kyle Dubas/Brendan Shanahan.

I read somewhere that Hanifin is now 6'4. Can't find the link though so don't hold me to it. Not that it matters but a guy that is 6'4 that can skate like Hanifin(i've watched 3 games so i'm no expert) has a place on my team. I think the Toronto media and media believing fans would be dissappointed initially with the selection but i think after game action i think that tune would change.
 
Stop arguing with this dummy. Anyone who would take a lesser player because they were born in the GTA is not worth the pages of discussion.
True enough. When somebody is basing their opinions on completely irrational viewpoints (4th/5th overall > 3rd overall, GTA BPA > BPA), there really isn't much to be gained from continuing the discussion.
 
Moron - I wanted them to win just enough to stay where they are, not go down and not move up.

Lest you think otherwise, it's not actually in my ability to cause them to do one or the other. I simply have a preference, just like anyone.

And if Hanifin goes at 3rd, I don't want the Leafs taking the so-called BPA who is a college dman over just as easily the true BPA who is a hometown hulking elite first line center. I want that possibility removed from reality. If it turns out Edmonton takes Strome over Hanifin, so be it. All I can do then is hope we take Marner over Hanifin.

Yeah, exactly. Your "hope" is dumb, and changes by the day. They could have drafted Strome at 3, probably 4, maybe 5, but definitely not 6.

If your hope was to guarantee Strome, hoping they would win and get a worse pick is just the wrong strategy, as everyone has told you time and time again. Complete nonsense.

The more they won, the more the odds of getting a chance to draft Strome decreased.
 
Last edited:
Stop arguing with this dummy. Anyone who would take a lesser player because they were born in the GTA is not worth the pages of discussion.

The point is, he's not a lesser player, at least not in any way that anyone could prove.

They play different positions and both project to be elite. I'll take the GTA born 6"3 center.
 
Yeah, exactly. Your "hope" is dumb, and changes by the day. They could have drafted Strome at 3, probably 4, maybe 5, but definitely not 6.

If your hope was to guarantee Strome, hoping they would win and get a worse pick is just the wrong strategy, as everyone has told you time and time again. Complete nonsense.

The more they won, the more the odds of getting a chance to draft Strome decreased.

Seeing as to reading comprehension is not people's thing here, I'll say it again. I wanted them to win enough to stay in 4th. No more, no less.
 
Back
Top