• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

True enough. When somebody is basing their opinions on completely irrational viewpoints (4th/5th overall > 3rd overall, GTA BPA > BPA), there really isn't much to be gained from continuing the discussion.

You guys just don't get it. Too eager to insult that you can't just stop for a second to even see what I'm actually saying.

Again, all things being equal - and they pretty much are between Hanifin, Strome, and Marner - I'll take the positional need and will enjoy the hometown birth origin.

If we're talking Hanifin or Crouse, I take Hanifin obviously.

But if the Leafs would take Hanifin at 3rd, I want 4th in the hopes the Oilers take him first.
 
You guys just don't get it. Too eager to insult that you can't just stop for a second to even see what I'm actually saying.

Again, all things being equal - and they pretty much are between Hanifin, Strome, and Marner - I'll take the positional need and will enjoy the hometown birth origin.

If we're talking Hanifin or Crouse, I take Hanifin obviously.

But if the Leafs would take Hanifin at 3rd, I want 4th in the hopes the Oilers take him first.
I haven't insulted you, or thrown any personal shots your way.

All I've said is that I think your point of view is completely irrational, which it is. And it's not that I don't understand what you're trying to say. You're just wrong. No matter how you want to argue it or spin it, the best player is the best player. It doesn't matter what position they play, or where they were born. And a 100% chance of having the opportunity to select the player you want is better than having a 50% chance, 25% chance or 0% chance. Full stop.

You disagree and cannot be swayed, hence my additional comment that there isn't much to be gained from continuing this discussion.
 
I haven't insulted you, or thrown any personal shots your way.

All I've said is that I think your point of view is completely irrational, which it is. And it's not that I don't understand what you're trying to say. You're just wrong. No matter how you want to argue it or spin it, the best player is the best player. It doesn't matter what position they play, or where they were born. And a 100% chance of having the opportunity to select the player you want is better than having a 50% chance, 25% chance or 0% chance. Full stop.

You disagree and cannot be swayed, hence my additional comment that there isn't much to be gained from continuing this discussion.

Well, your "true enough" reply was to a guy who took a personal shot, so it felt like a pile on.

I still don't think you guys get it, but what can I do.

Last attempt. If I were GM of the Leafs, I would for sure want to get the highest pick possible. If it was 3rd, I'd try to flip picks with Edmonton and get value while assuring that they'd take Hanifin, or otherwise take Strome/Marner with it. If it was 4th, I'd take Strome/Marner.

But I'm not GM of the Leafs, and I don't want them using the pick on Hanifin, which they might if they landed at 3rd. There is no discernible difference between Hanifin and Strome in terms of ceiling. None. And I just flat out believe that this team needs a #1C more than a dman, and even better, one with size and roots in TO.
 
Well, your "true enough" reply was to a guy who took a personal shot, so it felt like a pile on.

I still don't think you guys get it, but what can I do.

Last attempt. If I were GM of the Leafs, I would for sure want to get the highest pick possible. If it was 3rd, I'd try to flip picks with Edmonton and get value while assuring that they'd take Hanifin, or otherwise take Strome/Marner with it. If it was 4th, I'd take Strome/Marner.

But I'm not GM of the Leafs, and I don't want them using the pick on Hanifin, which they might if they landed at 3rd. There is no discernible difference between Hanifin and Strome in terms of ceiling. None. And I just flat out believe that this team needs a #1C more than a dman, and even better, one with size and roots in TO.
Okay, again. You don't need to keep trying to explain. I understand perfectly why you think your argument makes sense. I even at least get, if not agree, why you'd want the prototypical big #1 center ahead of anyone else. But no matter how you try and frame it, your reasons both for wanting Strome and for wanting us to pick 4th instead of 3rd are completely illogical.

You'll have better luck convincing people that it is in fact rational to believe that 2+2=5.
 
Last edited:
That's the spirit!

Now, let's just hope we win the lottery, and this entire Strome vs. Marner vs. Hanifin debate becomes moot.
 
That one is probably size-based. It's silly, but Crouse has a lot more individual skill and offensive talent than many on here seem to think. He's a really good two-way player and has David Backes upside.

I'd still rank them:

1. McDavid
2. Eichel
3. Strome
4. Hanifin
5. Marner
6. Provorov
7. Werenski

And then Crouse battling it out with a bunch of other names in the 8-12 range.
My top 8 are out

Ive gone

Mcd
Eichel
Strome
Marner
Hanifin
Werenski
Provorov
Rantanen

And coming out tomorrow zacha at 9

Crouse is being debated for top 10 right now... gonna take a bit of thought tomorrow between him and barzal.... but hes 10 or 11.
 
I'm guessing Hanifin has been dropped a bit because he and Boston College had a relatively disappointing season as far as winning trophies. But he's what 17 playing against 21 year olds, next will likely be his best.
 
Who do you think has a likelihood of making the NHL this year?

McDavid 100% the rest i'm not sure though Eichel probably will.

What about Hanifin? Strome? Marner?
 
Who do you think has a likelihood of making the NHL this year?

McDavid 100% the rest i'm not sure though Eichel probably will.

What about Hanifin? Strome? Marner?

All 3 likely could jump in to the NHL next season. Hanifin would have the hardest time of the 3 because of position, being an 18 yr old defender is hard as ****, though Hanifin has the size and skating to pull it off if his IQ is there.
 
I'm guessing Hanifin has been dropped a bit because he and Boston College had a relatively disappointing season as far as winning trophies. But he's what 17 playing against 21 year olds, next will likely be his best.

Has he spoke of his future yet? Is he committed to BC until he's done school
or will he make the jump early?
 
I'd personally be OK with any of Strome/Hanifin/Marner if we end up picking 5th and have to go BPA.

However, I'm very much worried that Marner will actually end up playing the wing in the NHL. That to me would be a wasted tank. #1D or C is what we need. Given that we have Morgan I'd be going with Strome here.

Strome, Hanifin, Marner is how I'd rank them.
 
Out of curiousity, what's the justification for having both Strome & Marner over Hanifin?


I put a detailed reason in my review on strome.

Basically I have 3-7 very close, and my philosophy is that when things are that close, take the forward as there are more elite defencemen found later in the draft who develop late, then there are forwards who develop late.

There are more PK Subban, Duncan Keith, Zdeno Chara, Shea Weber, Rob Blake, Nick Lidstrom, etc.... 2nd round and later Norris winners and contenders than there are 2nd round and later guys who win scoring titles, so all else equal in the top 5, go for the forward.

Note though that it has to be a toss-up between the players for this to apply.... I had Ekblad at #1 last year cause I didn't see it as a tossup, I saw him as clearly ahead.

http://lastwordonsports.com/2015/04/02/2015-nhl-draft-profile-3-dylan-strome/
 
Last edited:
I put a detailed reason in my review on strome.

Basically I have 3-7 very close, and my philosophy is that when things are that close, take the forward as there are more elite defencemen found later in the draft who develop late, then there are forwards who develop late.

There are more PK Subban, Duncan Keith, Zdeno Chara, Shea Weber, Rob Blake, Nick Lidstrom, etc.... 2nd round and later Norris winners and contenders than there are 2nd round and later guys who win scoring titles, so all else equal in the top 5, go for the forward.

http://lastwordonsports.com/2015/04/02/2015-nhl-draft-profile-3-dylan-strome/
What do you think the chances of Marner becoming a winger in the NHL are as opposed to a full time C?
 
Marner's a center. The only thing that would prevent him from playing center is size, but that hasn't prevented countless other players. The way he skates, sees the ice, and competes without the puck there is no reason to not project him as a center IMO.
 
As of now my top 10 would be:

1. McDavid
2. Eichel
3. Marner
4. Hanifin
5. Strome
6. Werenski
7. Provorov
8. Meier
9. Barazal
10. Konecny
 
Back
Top