• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

Im pretty intrigued by Zacha. His numbers don;t scream elite at the moment but he may get a pass due to this being his transition year and the small sample size.

6'3 210lbs centres who use their size to beat defenders may be hard to turn down in the in the 8-10 range
 
I'm over drafting players because they are big. Size shouldn't be the primary factor in a pick. There are other guys who are better players there IMO.
 
Zacha's sort of irrelevant to us anyways. Our second first rounder will likely be out of his range, and trading down to get him wouldn't make any sense. It's just as well. I'd be a little concerned that he's the next Radek Faksa: A mediocre offensive player that people get over-excited about, simply because he's big and plays center.
 
Marner's a center. The only thing that would prevent him from playing center is size, but that hasn't prevented countless other players. The way he skates, sees the ice, and competes without the puck there is no reason to not project him as a center IMO.
And yet hes played the vast majority of the last two years of junior hockey on the wing. His time at centre has been limited.
 
Zacha's sort of irrelevant to us anyways. Our second first rounder will likely be out of his range, and trading down to get him wouldn't make any sense. It's just as well. I'd be a little concerned that he's the next Radek Faksa: A mediocre offensive player that people get over-excited about, simply because he's big and plays center.

That's a perfect comparable actually. Big Czech centre with underwhelming offensive totals that people get excited about because he's "toolsy." Zero hockey IQ. Pass.
 
And yet hes played the vast majority of the last two years of junior hockey on the wing. His time at centre has been limited.

He has played center, and excelled though.

Why do you think he can't play center, other than size? He has the skating. He has the vision. He has the IQ. He moves the puck well. He is strong without the puck. And he does all those things at an elite level too. He has all the qualities needed to play center.\, and when he has played center he's been great.
 
Last edited:
He has played center, and excelled though.

Why do you think he can't play center, other than size? He has the skating. He has the vision. He has the IQ. He moves the puck well. He is strong without the puck. And he does all those things at an elite level too. He has all the qualities needed to play center.\, and when he has played center he's been great.

How about because Dale Hunter, a guy whose forgotten more about hockey than you and I will ever know, plays him as a winger 80 percent of the time?
 
Mitch Marner, Christian Dvorak and Max Domi are London's #1 line, yes?

Which one of them plays center?
 
Thats not a reason why he can't play center.

What about the fact that Dale Hunter, a guy whose forgotton more about hockey than you and I will ever know, has played him a center 20% of the time? Or the fact that he moved him to center for the playoffs.

Hunter has played him everywhere. Center, wing, defense on the PP. IMO that versatility should be a positive, not spun as a negative.
 
Marner's definitely a winger. I don't know why anyone who drafts him would consider him a centre. He just isn't used as one and he has more of the Patrick Kane play-making winger style.
 
Why though? No one says why they think Marner is a winger that is not capable of playing center, other than he has played wing when he wasn't playing center.

He has all the skill set necessary to play down the middle. He has the commitment to playing without the puck necessary. He has played center. Seems silly to write that possibility off at 17 for no apparent reason.
 
Last edited:
Thats not a reason why he can't play center.

What about the fact that Dale Hunter, a guy whose forgotton more about hockey than you and I will ever know, has played him a center 20% of the time? Or the fact that he moved him to center for the playoffs.

Hunter has played him everywhere. Center, wing, defense on the PP. IMO that versatility should be a positive, not spun as a negative.

Marner lined up both on centre and wing in round 1.

Plenty of scouts have trouble seeing him as a centre in the NHL and it's not entirely a size prejudice.
 
Marner lined up both on centre and wing in round 1.

Exactly. A guy who has forgotten more about hockey than either of us will ever know played him at center in the most important games of the season. Dale Hunter evidently thinks he can play center.

Plenty of scouts have trouble seeing him as a centre in the NHL and it's not entirely a size prejudice.

Its all size. I've still yet to hear another reason. He has the skating, he has the IQ, he has the puck moving ability, he plays a strong two way game. He's played center. Size is the only thing that would prevent it. He needs to put on 20-30 pounds to realistically compete at center in the NHL. But who cares, countless of little guys have done it. Dastyuk. Crosby, Zetterberg, Grioux, Johnson, Granlund the list goes on and on.
 
The thing with Crosby is that he's a physical freak. He has legs the size of tree trunks and an insanely powerful core, with a low centre of gravity. Marner, for all of his all-world skill, just strikes me as too fragile to withstand playing down the middle long-term.

But hell, maybe he's got a great attitude and demonstrates the commitment to getting stronger. I don't know. I'd just prefer Strome over him if we go with a future centre for the reason that he's already got the size and skill dimension.
 
Exactly. A guy who has forgotten more about hockey than either of us will ever know played him at center in the most important games of the season. Dale Hunter evidently thinks he can play center.



Its all size. I've still yet to hear another reason. He has the skating, he has the IQ, he has the puck moving ability, he plays a strong two way game. He's played center. Size is the only thing that would prevent it. He needs to put on 20-30 pounds to realistically compete at center in the NHL. But who cares, countless of little guys have done it. Dastyuk. Crosby, Zetterberg, Grioux, Johnson, Granlund the list goes on and on.

You want another reason? I'll give you one.

All those guys you've mentioned, except Sid, play the game with their brain (not that Sid doesn't). Marner plays it with his feet. That's not knocking his hockey IQ, watch the kid play. Like Paul Kariya or Pat Kane, he likes to up the pace of a game and make guys play at his speed. That's partly why he's able to survive at his size. In order to hit him, you have to catch him first.

Dats,Zetts, Giroux and Granlund all beat guys by finding openings, reading the play, etc. They play like typical centres. They succeed just as, if not more, often by slowing the play down.

Crosby is the exception, Sid tries to make guys play with him. However, as we've seen with Team Canada, that style of play is an absolute bitch to find wingers for. It's also harder in the NHL to play that style because the clear skating advantage you enjoyed in the OHL, you don't enjoy at the NHL level. If you're a generational talent and - as Jays pointed out, a bit of a physical freak - you can do it.

But Marner would need to gain 40 pounds of muscle to play at Sid's size.
 
Yeah I just disagree with that assessment. Marner's hockey IQ is among his best assets. But really its the play without the puck that determines whether a guy can play center or not. Not how he produces offense. Centers produce offense in all kinds of different ways. And there are lots of them that create time and space with their feet. The play without the puck is determinative of whether a guy can compete at that position or not.

Kariya played like a center with the puck. He just didn't play like one without it. Same with Kane, although he is a bit more of a perimeter player. Thats why guys like Kessel and JVR couldn't hack it when we tried them up the middle.

Marner, on the other hand, is consistently praised for his effort without the puck. He's a 3 zone player.
 
Last edited:
Yeah I just disagree with that assessment. Marner's hockey IQ is among his best assets.

Not saying it isn't. I'm saying that's not how he prefers to play the game. Watch Mitch Marner play, he does it at one speed and that speed is as fast as he can possibly skate and hold on to the puck.

Not a knock on him, but also not a way most great centres in the game play - including the smaller guys. It's the style of play, moreso than even his size, that has a lot of scouts believing he's a winger. A lot of scouts who watch him play see Paul Kariya, not Claude Giroux. And, given that Kariya is a likely a HOFer, that's in no way an insult.

Matt Barzal is pretty well the same size, no scouts are doubting whether he's a centre at the next level.
 
Merkley's a pretty fragile guy as well (5'10, 180). Same thing. He's a prototypical centre who is projected to be one once he turns pro.
 
Back
Top