• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

What happened to Kylington for him to drop completely out of the first?

Ive seen him range from top 10 to bottom 20 in most rankings

I think it's a failure to meet expectations. He came into the season with a lot of hype. There were scouts who compared him and Noah Hanifin favourably.

But he had a largely underwhelming year on big stages. His numbers in the SHL and Allsvenskan aren't bad but aren't head turning. His U-18 tournament was bad. He was probably the third best defenseman on his own team.

There's ceiling there still but I think scouts are seeing more flaws in his games than they did last year.
 
Crouse is a "safe pick" you know what you'll get, but I don't see too much upside compared to his peers. But he's big and Canadian, and probably filled with intangibles.

Is he actually safe though? I notice all the guys they say are safe don't actually have the production to justify being picked where they are, you're just hoping it comes... because tools. That seems actually seems pretty risky.

I mean, I guess he's safe in that you're probably getting an NHLer in some capacity but that kinda sucks for top 5.
 
He's big and fast. His ranking is purely a result of the "eye test."

He looks more like the next Benoit Pouliot than the next Ryan Smyth or Scott Hartnell.
 
I don't mind picking up the Semin contract, because in reality, we most likely won't be signing a lot of high profile UFA's in the next 3 yrs as we're rebuilding - BUT it's one thing to take on that contract, it's another to take on that AND not get properly compensated for it.

2 of Kessel, Kadri and Semin contract I can stomach for getting the 5th overall pick, but not all 3.

I mean, sure I love everything I hear about Haninfin / Strome / Marner - but there's no guarantee they'll not turn out to be another Kessel / Phaneuf / Kadri either. Prospects are prospects and even though there's a chance they may pan out to be franchise players, there's also a chance they don't, and we should give up accordingly in a trade because of that.

Wow my value on Kessel is waaay different. I wouldn't trade Kessel straight up for the number 5, I'd want something else thrown in. If I read it right it looks like you would be willing to add in Kadri?
I'm trying to think of another 30 Goal scorer who (aside from the past gongshow of a season) was in the top 10 in scoring multiple years in a row that would go for such a low of a return.
 
Wow my value on Kessel is waaay different. I wouldn't trade Kessel straight up for the number 5, I'd want something else thrown in. If I read it right it looks like you would be willing to add in Kadri?
I'm trying to think of another 30 Goal scorer who (aside from the past gongshow of a season) was in the top 10 in scoring multiple years in a row that would go for such a low of a return.
First of all, the 5th overall this year isn't the same as 5th from just any other year. Many would argue top 5 pick is as good as 1st overall in most other years, and thus the 5th overall this year does have higher value in itself.

Then, one can also argue Jumbo Joe, at the time of the trade from BOS, has achieved more than Kessel, and was traded for less. BOS went on to win a cup after Jumbo Joe was gone - and not really with the pieces that came back from the trade either. You can argue the fact Thornton was gone, and the change in the team chemistry, were necessary to rebuild the Bruins into a championship team. SJ, OTOH, never got close to the cup with Thornton in their lineup.

And Kessel is a proven NHL sniper who, unfortunately, is also coming off a piss poor season and is signed on to a long and heavy contract. Of course Kessel has good value still, but you consider all the circumstances, if you decided he's not in the long-term plan of the Leafs moving forward, then I'd have no problem trading him for 5th overall straight up.
 
First of all, the 5th overall this year isn't the same as 5th from just any other year. Many would argue top 5 pick is as good as 1st overall in most other years, and thus the 5th overall this year does have higher value in itself.

Then, one can also argue Jumbo Joe, at the time of the trade from BOS, has achieved more than Kessel, and was traded for less. BOS went on to win a cup after Jumbo Joe was gone - and not really with the pieces that came back from the trade either. You can argue the fact Thornton was gone, and the change in the team chemistry, were necessary to rebuild the Bruins into a championship team. SJ, OTOH, never got close to the cup with Thornton in their lineup.

And Kessel is a proven NHL sniper who, unfortunately, is also coming off a piss poor season and is signed on to a long and heavy contract. Of course Kessel has good value still, but you consider all the circumstances, if you decided he's not in the long-term plan of the Leafs moving forward, then I'd have no problem trading him for 5th overall straight up.
How about using someone who fits that description today, who you'd trade the 5th pick for? Kane, Stamkos, Malkin, Ovechkin, Crosby, Perry, Benn, Nash, Pavelski, Seguin - which of these guys would you trade for the 5th? (no I'm not saying that Kessel is as good as Crosby, but the top 10 is pretty elite, especially with goal scorers - which Thornton is not).
 
I am more concerned with improving the team rather than some perceived notion of value.

The question really is, how important would that #5 pick be to the future of the team versus what we have to give up for it?

If you think the guy you are getting at #5 is a key, building block piece for this team, then the fact that you aren't getting "fair value" isn't all that important. IMO its fine to overpay for a piece like that, otherwise pieces like that aren't moved.

So the question of would you move any of those guys for the 5th pick, varies more depending on the team and their situation, than the value of what they have to give up. Dallas has no reason to move Benn or Seguin. But maybe Toronto or San Jose has more to gain by moving a player of that ccalibre given where their team is currently.
 
I am more concerned with improving the team rather than some perceived notion of value.

The question really is, how important would that #5 pick be to the future of the team versus what we have to give up for it?

If you think the guy you are getting at #5 is a key, building block piece for this team, then the fact that you aren't getting "fair value" isn't all that important. IMO its fine to overpay for a piece like that, otherwise pieces like that aren't moved.

So the question of would you move any of those guys for the 5th pick, varies more depending on the team and their situation, than the value of what they have to give up. Dallas has no reason to move Benn or Seguin. But maybe Toronto or San Jose has more to gain by moving a player of that ccalibre given where their team is currently.

Getting fair value is pretty damn important
 
What is fair value though? Isn't getting an elite skilled 18 year old more important than getting fair value? Are you going to get a more impactful piece than that for Phil Kessel?

IMO getting the best asset that will have the biggest impact on the team moving forward is the most important thing. IMO that is actually damn good value. Whether that meets the idea of fair value is kind of irrelevant. I'd rather not get fair value, and get the best asset. Fair value is just subjective and made up anyway.
 
Last edited:
What is fair value though? Isn't getting an elite skilled 18 year old more important than getting fair value? Are you going to get a more impactful piece than that for Phil Kessel?
More than the 5th - who is by no means guaranteed to be as good or close to Kessel

Are you going to get a more impactful piece than that for Phil Kessel?
Yes, or you know, you don't have to trade him
 
Yes, or you know, you don't have to trade him

Well that to me is not maximizing value, which is way worse that not getting some made up concept of fair value.

IMO, an 18 year old blue chip talent is more valuable to this team, at this point in time, than a 28 year old, flawed, blue chip talent. And I don't think you would get a better deal than that. And I really don't think you would get that kind of return 2-3 years from now because this is a special draft class. Seems fair to me.
 
Keep him in hope of being ready to contend in 3-4 years when goal scorers are notoriously known for being on the downswing of their careers at his age?

You have to think of the long term implications here
 
What is a better fit for this rebuilding team? One of Strome, Marner or Hanifin or Kessel.

If you think the answer is the former then what about that isn't fair value? IMO if we were offered a 1st overall pick straight up for Kessel in most years, that would be seen as fair value.
 
Exactly. There is always a risk to trading a proven commodity for a prospect but the probability of 3 of those guys becoming impact players is pretty high.
 
Problem i have with dealing Kessel is that we will undoubtedly be doing a quality for quantity trade. Any draft pick we get him may have potential to be good but the likelihood of that pick achieving Kessel level success is small. Bringing up the fact that Boston won the cup after dealing away Thornton shouldn't be an endorsement to move Kessel. That was a garbage trade then and an even worse trade in hindsight. Maybe if the Bruins made a better trade they'd have won more than just the 1 cup.

I think there are bigger problems on this roster than Kessel. Just because public opinion is that this is a great draft to be drafting multiple players doesn't mean we should be throwing away elite talent for the mystery box. Kessel has been on the Leafs for 6 full seasons and to this day we still have not found him a quality center to play with. Poor coaching, poor defensive play and getting poor results isn't really surprising.

I think there are a lot of positives in keeping Phil Kessel on the roster. Though i wouldn't be surprised if management felt it was time to move on.

As or this draft, between Strome and Marner and Hanifin i am not sure who i would want. Strome has the potential to become that mythical unicorn big center we haven't had since Sundin. His skating is a pretty big concern for me. I'm no scout so for me to say that he was skating similar to Nik Antropov i know something isn't right. Marner on the other hand is pretty small but offers a completely different skillset in the mold of a Patrick Kane. Is he a center or a winger? In the grand scheme of things i guess it doesn't matter but having good center depth is essential in building a quality roster. Hanifin i have only watched 2 games in the NCAA and he wasn't very visible. As a 17 year old defenseman in the NCAA i think thats a pretty good thing. I saw he skated really well for a guy his size and made some nice outlet passes to get out of the zone.

I kind of want Strome because i think if he hits his ceiling i really like the role he would be able to fill. Thats not how real life works so i have no idea who to pick. Hard to argue against choosing Hanifin if he is available. Marner is wouldn't be surprised to see be the best player of the 3.

Tough choice.
 
We likely aren't getting a Strome, Marner or Hanifin for Kessel though. I very much doubt Carolina does that. Would we if the roles were reversed?

Kessel is a guy a contender or near contender should be going after. Maybe Carolina feels they can compete with Kessel. Though with that defensive depth and goalie situation i don't see how they can be so confident.
 
I think the very easy indicator of this trade is - ask 30 GMs will they trade 5th overall pick for Phil Kessel this summer, and I believe 29 of them will say no.

Including Francis.
 
What happened to Kylington for him to drop completely out of the first?

Ive seen him range from top 10 to bottom 20 in most rankings
Shit since january.... but could be a steal since rumours are hes been playing with a wrist that needs surgery
 
Back
Top