• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

2015 NHL Entry Draft

Just throwing it out there:

Brandon Carlo 6'5 196lb : 63gp 4g 21a 25p .39ppg
Shea Weber 6'4 205lb: 70gp 2g 16a 18p .25ppg

Can't always judge a defenseman on point production in the WHL. From all reports i've seen Brandon Carlo is said to be a great skater for his size. If management takes him i wouldn't be too sour. Not my first pick but looks like a guy with decent potential.
 
Not that i think he's the next Shea Weber. Shea Weber was taken in the 2nd round because it was hard to project how his skills would look in the NHL. Well they look pretty damn good right.
 
Just throwing it out there:

Brandon Carlo 6'5 196lb : 63gp 4g 21a 25p .39ppg
Shea Weber 6'4 205lb: 70gp 2g 16a 18p .25ppg

Can't always judge a defenseman on point production in the WHL. From all reports i've seen Brandon Carlo is said to be a great skater for his size. If management takes him i wouldn't be too sour. Not my first pick but looks like a guy with decent potential.

They're not at all comparable. Weber always had one of the best shots in the draft. Carlo doesn't possess the same type of skill-set that allowed Weber to blossom offensively.

You're essentially comparing a stay-at-home defender to an offensive stud.

Weber was also the sixth defenceman on an incredibly dominant Kelowna Rockets squad that would win the Memorial Cup the next year. They won 51 games in his draft year and he was stuck behind two twenty year-olds in Duncan Keith and Tomas Slovak (one of the best defenders in the Dub that season), a nineteen year-old all-star Josh Gorges, a future NHL'er in Mike Card, and Brett Palin (with whom he battled for ice-time all season).

Weber was taken entirely on a tools basis, not production.
 
Yeah, I can't see this group selecting Carlo in the first round. All they have talked about is wanting high skilled players, with the potential to be impact players and needing to hit a homerun with the 24th pick.

Carlo is more Coburn than Weber.
 
They're not at all comparable. Weber always had one of the best shots in the draft. Carlo doesn't possess the same type of skill-set that allowed Weber to blossom offensively.

You're essentially comparing a stay-at-home defender to an offensive stud.

Weber was also the sixth defenceman on an incredibly dominant Kelowna Rockets squad that would win the Memorial Cup the next year. They won 51 games in his draft year and he was stuck behind two twenty year-olds in Duncan Keith and Tomas Slovak (one of the best defenders in the Dub that season), a nineteen year-old all-star Josh Gorges, a future NHL'er in Mike Card, and Brett Palin (with whom he battled for ice-time all season).

Weber was taken entirely on a tools basis, not production.

Excellent points. Having not watched Brandon Carlo i can't comment on what "tools" he has or doesn't have but to be considered in the 1st round bubble you'd figure scouts see something in him. Weber being drafted in the 2nd round as a project is about equal to Brandon Carlo getting drafted in the bottom of the 1st as a project him self. The Coburn comparison Leafman101 said is probably more along the lines of where Carlo projects but really we won't know until a decade after the draft.

My point was i wouldn't be crushed if we picked Brandon Carlo as he has some good qualities going for him from the reports i've read. He just wouldn't be my first choice at 24.
 
heard Bobo on TSN say Hanifin really wants to be a Leaf.

One thing that is fairly surprising, considering that these kids were all 6 years old or so the last time the Leafs actually had a legitimately good hockey team, is just how many of them are either Leaf fans or really want to play where hockey means the most.
 
One thing that is fairly surprising, considering that these kids were all 6 years old or so the last time the Leafs actually had a legitimately good hockey team, is just how many of them are either Leaf fans or really want to play where hockey means the most.

Babcock is playing a huge role in that perception. Who wouldn't want to play for one of the best coaches in the world
 
For the longest time my preference has been Hanifin. And after reading so many of you have a hard on for Marner, I ended up being torn on the 2.

Look at what Hedman meant to the Lightning.
Look at what Keith meant to the Black Hawks.
Look at what Doughty meant to the Kings.
Look at what Chara meant to the Bruins.
Look at what Lindstrom meant to the Wings.
The last cup winning team that didnt have an absolute stud on the blue line was Pittsburgh. That ****ing team didn't need it. Crosby had 103 points that season and he was 2nd on the team.


We don't have anywhere near any of those guys in the organization. Not even close.
 
I'm not really sure you can say Pittsburgh didn't have a "stud" on D when they won the Cup. They had Gonchar, back when he was a 60+ point defenseman, and they had 21 year-old Kris Letang, who was healthy at the point of his career and just coming into his own. The point is well made though. I really want one of Strome or Marner, but won't be disappointed if we try to land a stud on D instead. Though I also hope that Morgan Rielly will be able to evolve into that kind of player as well.
 
To be fair, if you're looking for a Duncan Keith clone at 20-21 yrs old, Morgan Rielly is probably your best bet...right down to the freakish athleticism.
 
Hanifin would be a great pick. A 17 year old emerging as a #1 defensman in the NCAA is unheard of. 17 year olds don't even typically play in the NCAA.

Marner and Strome's production is also unheard of though. It'll be hard to **** this one up.
 
Hanifin would be a great pick. A 17 year old emerging as a #1 defensman in the NCAA is unheard of. 17 year olds don't even typically play in the NCAA.

Marner and Strome's production is also unheard of though. It'll be hard to **** this one up.

And the most amazing this about it is?

How long has it been that the Leafs have needed a center? Two days past forever, that's how long. And the guy who is 3rd on the list for that #4 for most Leafs fan, is that center we have been coveting. That shows you the talent level in this draft and what will be available at 4.

Glad it isn't Burke drafting, we'd probably take Crouse.
 
It moved.

Hope you are correct.

rielly.0.gif
 
Back
Top