For all intents and purposes, we're at 43 at the moment. That's counting Bernier, Kadri & Panik, who are all about to become RFA's, but the Leafs are reportedly looking to re-sign all three, so may as well count them towards the total.
EDIT: actually, I guess we're at 44. I didn't count Marincin in my total. He's an RFA too, but safe to assume the Leafs will sign him.
A note though: the Leafs did do exactly what you're suggesting last year with defenseman Cody Donaghey of the Quebec Remparts. He made it all the way through the 2014 draft, but the Leafs still had some interest and invited him to our prospects camp, which lead to us signing him to a three year entry-level contract.