So how long before FSU, Clemson and others bolt from the ACC for greener $$$ pastures?
Well, that depends ... because it's about legal agreements and not bluster on sports talk shows. FSU's people have been particularly full of themselves lately on that front, making a lot of statements they know full well are nonsense after meetings this July aimed at breaking the agreement ended in frustration. The grant of rights contract that binds the ACC schools to the conference and the current TV and other collective rights deals runs until 2036, and it has proven thus far to be legally bullet proof.
Caveat ... there comes a point when breaking the grant of rights agreement becomes a manageable write-down and not the onerous penalty it is in 2023. By taking these three programs into their existing media contract structure, the ACC wins small on the revenue front for 2-3 years while basically ensuring they'll lose big in the long run. In other words, this expansion probably guarantees that the ACC will dissolve or restructure when the current grant of rights deal runs out. From my understanding from talking to some State people, it's a two-stage bet.
Stage 1 ... that the collapse of the TV rights market means that the current B1G and SEC contracts are unsustainable in the future (and maybe in the present). In other words, with patience, the financial scales will level out because the collapse of cable carriage rights fees means there's simply not enough money in the system anymore to sustain the present, much less grow the future. There's good bloody reason that Disney is playing hardball with Spectrum on their carriage fees and it has nothing to do with corporate greed. It has to do with the current numbers basically guaranteeing the ESPN loses money and Disney being no longer willing to subsidize the sports right fees out of their own pockets. ESPN has been bleeding cash for several years and sooner or later somebody was always going to apply the brakes. That time looks increasingly like now.
Stage 2 ... that the CFA, which really runs college football, will break away from the NCAA and make its own way before 2037 (or whenever the ACC grant of rights collapses as a disincentive). Honestly, this may be even more inevitable than the first bet. And the first bet is close to a sure thing ... depending on the degree of revenue reduction. Everybody outside of college administration sees that none of this conference weirdness works for anybody other than the football programs. It's only a matter of time before the increased costs associated with these mega-conferences to the non-revenue sports start to actually impact the bottom line for the revenue sports. It's already happening to basketball, which has become a shadow of its former self in a VERY short period of time. When it starts to hit football, I don't think it'll take even 2 seasons for the CFA to say screw it and start to flex their position. You probably end up with a semi-pro layer that pays the athletes and plays big money championship level football administered directly by the CFA or some other agency cooked up for purpose, running parallel to a more traditional student athlete based model administered by the NCAA. Then the CFA would be free to reset common sense and carve their super-conference up into regional divisions like any pro sport.
So yeah, the ACC made a short term cash grab because they're betting that the short term is all that matters ... because everything is going to blow up one way or another before the downside kicks in. It's cynical and self-serving, but honestly ... they're probably right.