• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

FI Leafs Top Prospect Project

MindzEye

Wayward Ditch Pig
It's August....we're bored. We should start a series of prospect polls and put together our FI Leafs board consensus top 20 Leafs prospects list.

If there's enough interest, I'll start putting together the polls.
 
This would be intriguing particularly if we had some well informed posters making their respective cases for why they feel certain prospects deserved to be slotted where.....

Would still be interesting if everyone just votes.....but we'll likely just end up with a list that's a hodgepodge of other lists out there kind of amalgamated together.

If we had well informed arguments though backed with evidence (scouting reports, stats, stats comparisons vis a vis previous players who put up similar seasons at similar ages, etc etc)....by the likes of hockeylover, Jays, Irish, Mindz, leafman101, zeke, etc etc....with some healthy debate back and forth, informing the voting process.

Then we'd have something really worthwhile imo.
 
I'd definitely be interested to hear everyone's thoughts. I'm pretty desperate at this point for some hockey, and prospect porn usually does the trick.
 
This would be intriguing particularly if we had some well informed posters making their respective cases for why they feel certain prospects deserved to be slotted where.....

Would still be interesting if everyone just votes.....but we'll likely just end up with a list that's a hodgepodge of other lists out there kind of amalgamated together.

If we had well informed arguments though backed with evidence (scouting reports, stats, stats comparisons vis a vis previous players who put up similar seasons at similar ages, etc etc)....by the likes of hockeylover, Jays, Irish, Mindz, leafman101, zeke, etc etc....with some healthy debate back and forth, informing the voting process.

Then we'd have something really worthwhile imo.

That's kind of what I expected to see happen in the polls tbh, though I definitely see some merit in starting a thread with the voting options for that slot before we open the poll to allow for the arguments to sway voters one way or another.
 
The way they do the top prospect pole on HF actually works pretty well. But you need a separate poll for each of the rankings, say top 10. You start with #1 (Nylander v. Marner) then once that is decided move on to the next ranking, removing the names which have been previously voted for.
 
The way they do the top prospect pole on HF actually works pretty well. But you need a separate poll for each of the rankings, say top 10. You start with #1 (Nylander v. Marner) then once that is decided move on to the next ranking, removing the names which have been previously voted for.

That's a good method
 
The way they do the top prospect pole on HF actually works pretty well. But you need a separate poll for each of the rankings, say top 10. You start with #1 (Nylander v. Marner) then once that is decided move on to the next ranking, removing the names which have been previously voted for.

yeah, that was the idea here. I've seen the same method used in other places for prospect lists. I like where Montana was with it though (and I thought along the same lines previously as well) in that we should be having a discussion thread on that slot prior to even opening the voting poll. I haven't seen that done elsewhere, they just open up the voting poll and it's purely democratic, where I think it would be more effective if people on the fence were able to see coherent arguments for or against a prospect being slotted in a certain position, before they determine who they would vote for in whichever slot.
 
Yeah, doing what we could to make the electorate as educated as possible prior to them casting their votes......is the ideal democratic process, imo.




Think we'd come up with one hell of a top 20 list that way.
 
I like that. The debate so often comes down to rating a prospects potential vs the probability of them reaching it. Would be nice if we could decouple those two things in our rankings.
 
That would make interesting split discussion topics on any prospect as well. Separate discussions on prospect potential, Vs likelihood for attaining it....I think there could be some compelling arguments concerning boom/bust guys like Bracco & Timashov Vs safer prospects with significantly lesser upsides like Harrington & Percy.
 
6 people responding within 6 hours on a Monday afternoon is enough for me. I'll start the first discussion thread....it will probably be the easiest.
 
suggestion....

skip

1. marner
2. nylander

first, we all know they're the top two. second, it's just inviting the trolls.
 
I wanted to hear out anyone who had legit Willy arguments personally...or at least see if the consensus existed here.

I imagine that 1-2 will be easy and quick though. Probably put up the voting threads in a bit.
 
Back
Top