mbow30
Spudmeister Supreme
I think the key of what you mentioned there is the fact most of us are casual observers...so sometimes we think a player would be of more value to us even though other teams have seen pros and cons and obviously don't think there's enough there. How many times we thought a player coming to the Leafs would make a significant impact and it just didn't happen?
it has nothign to do with being able to rate what a player brings to the table. just that we're more apt to remember the game against vancouver where eager took 10 minutes in penalties -- because we all watched it -- than the 60 regular season games he played this year that we didn't watch, and which he didn't take 10 minutes in penalties in.
as for expectations.. i don't know. most of the guys they have signed or brought aboard over the past several seasons have done just about what i expected of them.
if anything i was pleasantly surprised by a couple (mac in particular).