T
teeds
Guest
Well you have been very good with most of your calls. Kulemin being one of the best.
Well you have been very good with most of your calls. Kulemin being one of the best.
The scary thing about being right in this world is you are attacked for it.
The scary thing about being right in this world is you are attacked for it.
Wtf is this "kulemin call" noise you keep spouting? Half of the board has been pegging him as a 25+ goal scorer, top 6 forward since we had nothing but russian league youtube videos to go on. The way you carry on, one would be excused for believing that he was an obscvure 7th rounder from siberia that you scouted personally instead of the 2nd round pick with a russina league mvp title under his belt before he had ever played a minute of NHL hockey.
That's not really fair though.
Like any prospect, you can only judge them based on their performances in the leagues they compete in. And Kulemin was one of the top players in the Russian league at a young age. That doesn't guarentee success at the NHL level, but it's a very good sign for the future. Especially when you have a coach who's very familiar with him comparing him to Malkin.
Whether he becomes a good player or not remains to be seen, but those goals he scored are crazy good. The Russian league is not the NHL, but it's still a very good league, and he embarrassed forwards and defenseman on most of those goals.
All those goals were scored in the 2nd half of the Russian season. To have that many highlight goals in such a short span is pretty incredible.
I disagree.
Kulemin has shown that he isn't a perimeter player. He's a guy that isn't afraid to go to the net. And he scores a lot of goals because of this. You dont have to be the most talented guy in the world in order to score if you willing to fight for position in scoring areas around the net. Ryan Smyth is a perfect example of this. I would be a lot more concerned if he was a Berezin type player who hung around the perimeter. But that isn't his style of play. He has a good mix of finesse and power which translates well to the NHL game.
In the old NHL, the case could be made that Stralman wouldn't be able to make the transition. But with his ability to skate, pass and handle the puck -- he's become an ideal 'new age' defenseman.
Will both be superstars? Probably not. But I'd be very surprised if Kulemin ddoesn't become at least a 2nd line player and Stralman a 2nd pairing dman.
He has a very good mix of physical ability and skill which makes him a very interesting prospect.
What? I totally disagree about him being anything like Berezin, other than maybe the speed. This is a really old scouting report but...
In fact, he seems like the ANTI-BEREZIN, doesn't it? In the WCs, he didn't get much of an offensive role but was used to kill penalties and a couple times as the only forward in a 5 on 3 situation.
Now since that scouting report he seems to have really developed his offensive game because I don't think anyone would say at this point that he's not imaginative. But that defensive awareness, hard work, feistiness... I'm guessing that doesn't all go away. The interesting part is that part saying that his skills should work well in the NHL, and this was before he ever broke out.
^ In reading the initial scouting reports, it certainly does sound a lot like Ponikarovsky. And actually, I could see how one would make that comparison with a lot of the video clips we've seen of him.
I don't really think that he'll have that much of a problem adjusting to the NHL personally. It seems like a lot of the young Russian fowards that come over need to adjust to the physical part of NA hockey, and need to work on their defensive responsibilities. That seems to be one of Kulemin's biggest strengths. He seems to have a great attitude and that makes gives me reason to be optimistic.
Glad to have him under contract. He is a talented young kid, it is hard not to get excited about his potential. Why oh why is he staying another year in Russia though? As Teeder said, get him over here and adjusted to the North American game.
Been a while since I've seen any threads about Kulemin. I'm pretty psyched to see him (hopefully) get some quality minutes with the Leafs next year. He reminds me a bit of a poor man's AO in that he has speed, can dangle, has a hard shot, and can dish out big hits (but is obviously not on the same elite level as AO).
Here are some newish vids on YouTube that I hadn't seen before:
I think he has a good shot at being one of the better 2nd round picks of not only his draft class but of the past couple of years. We'll soon see if he can put it all together at the NHL level.
I have really high hopes for this guy. Probably my favorite prospect in our system right now.
They are only highlights, but from what I have seen, I think under the right coach. He can turn into a good power forward for us.
The kid's got no holes in his game, and some great assets to boot.
Kulemin is pretty intriguing. Its actually pretty surprising that no one in Toronto is talking about him. He is probably the Leafs best prospect, well aside from Schenn now, and is now 22, having spend the last two seasons dominating in Russia. He also plays a brand of hockey that we seem to love over here.
You'd think you would hear more about him, especially with this "rebuild" going on.
He should be able to step in next year as a legit top 6 forward if that is where he fits in in the NHL. This isn't a 19 year old rookie like Tlusty. This guy should be pretty ready to contribute.
I agree Leafman.
He has a very good combination of size, speed and toughness. Plus, he's played in the 2nd best league in the world over the last two years where he was one of the top goal scorers.
Cant wait to see him.
Did I "spout" about anything, hothead?
Agreed, teeds was the one who brought it up, and he's brought it up a few times recently for some reason. You did jump in yourself with your "nobody likes anyone to be right" comment though. And there's no lynch mob. Just trying to resolve a long-standing debate with facts. I also looked up preston mizzi's claim that he made a "call" about Brett Lebda the other day, and as I noted, it turned out Mizzi was right. If I'd gone back, looked and found out you were right, I'd have posted that too.First of all, I didn't bring up the subject nor was I arguing anything while the entire lynchmob is rounding up for action.
Second, I'd be curious as to when my first comment on him was.
The posters I quoted? Nope. Here's a thread about Kulemin getting sent down from Kuly's first season here. The vast majority of the posters around here defend Kulemin, and make it clear they don't like the move:Third, it's one thing to like him on Youtube, and it's another to crap on him when he got here and call for sending him to the minors and claiming he was never going to be anything special - which many of those quoted posters did. I stuck by him and predicted he'd be exactly what he is today while almost all, if not all, the naysayers and bandwagonners were off the Kuly-train. Pull the quotes from that camp when people were calling for him to be sent down.
There, you made me finally argue it.
i disagree, he didn't look out of place at all in the nhl and deserved to stay up here to let his game develop in the national hockey league.
this is a disgrace of a rebuild, actually.
so now
-tlusty, kulemin and stralman, who were all expected to assume fairly substantial roles on the team this season, are playing for the marlies.
-colaiacovo and steen, once considered staples of the team's future, were shipped off at the quarter point for lee stempniak, a player who doesn't look like he will last long in toronto
-wellwood, who scored at nearly a point per game rate two seasons ago, was lost to the canucks on waivers
-justin pogge performed well in his lone nhl start, only to be redemoted so that the leafs can continue to trot out a pair of goaltenders who are not worthy of nhl playing time right now
hopefully the kulemin move is just a precursor to a 2-for-1 trade and that the leafs just needed to clear a spot on the roster. he shouldn't have been sente down.
for players coming out of junior i agree, but kulemin is 22 years old and has 3 full professional seasons in a pretty competitive league (probably the best aside from the nhl) under his belt.
and while he hasn't been a standout in the nhl, he hasn't looked entirely out of place.
i'm not sure what playing out the year with the marlies is going to accomplish for him. he has to learn how to maneuver against the best players, he has already proven that he can be a star amongst second rate talent.
I thought this was the whole point of rebuilding, allowing the kids to play full time and earn their stripes.
Oh well, once Poni/Antropov/Stajan are traded he'll be back up. Burke is going to start putting his stamp on the team fairly shortly I would imagine.
Tulsty, Kulemin, Stralman will hopefully all be back up soon. At least, I hope they are. If not then this is a crappy rebuild.
The kid had 7 goals!
Am i the only one here who thinks that 7 goals in half of a season for a rookie just experiencing NA hockey isnt that bad?? This move definitely doesn't make sense.
Maybe he will rip up the A and make them look like idiots...
First dumb move by Burke so yes he deserves flack for this.
I don't agree with this one at all unless it's a precursor to a move
I don't think he'll be playing out the year for the Marlies, the trade deadline is rapidly approaching.
I don't agree with sending him down, but it might be part of a bigger picture. As a stand alone move it sucks, but it might make sense later.