• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Lets be honest here. Phaneuf is playing very well now. But he is STILL not quite worth what he is paid. Close though.
 
If Phaneuf can get back to the 50ish point range, combined with his defensive/physical ability, he will be well worth his contract. A good point total, a healthy +/- along with all the minutes he logs will get him Norris consideration, and he's off to a good start in this regard.

I have no problem paying big for players who have the potential to be one of the very best at his position.
 
Plus I know it's a bit wishy-washy, but I really do think he's bringing some serious leadership now, which to a young team can make a real impact. There's value there above his numbers.
 
Even being able to chew up the minutes he does on a regular basis goes a long way towards justifying his contract, especially when you throw in the crushing open-ice hits that have been appearing with increased regularity. But if he keeps on putting up points like he has, and ends up in 50+ point territory, no one anywhere should have any cause for complaint about his salary.
 
IMO Phaneuf has been earning his contract ever since he started to score last January. The rest of his game was always up to par.
 
50 point Phaneuf with everything else he brings is worth 6.5 million. You throw in a useful 4th/5th defenceman with plus size and reach like Aulie into the mix on top of it, and you're looking at Brian Burke's best trade so far in Toronto. Poor Flames.
 
I always had this impression about Phaneuf that he was this chance taker, who put himself in bad defensive positions in order to generate offense or a big hit. But since he arrived in Toronto, it's actually the opposite. The guy is a stud defensively and physically, and he's actually been underwhelming to me offensively so far. I think he needs to take more chances offensively and not just rely on his big shot.
 
I always had this impression about Phaneuf that he was this chance taker, who put himself in bad defensive positions in order to generate offense or a big hit. But since he arrived in Toronto, it's actually the opposite. The guy is a stud defensively and physically, and he's actually been underwhelming to me offensively so far. I think he needs to take more chances offensively and not just rely on his big shot.
Yeah, there were a lot of Bryan McCabe comparisons floating around when he was first dealt here. But so far in Toronto, Phaneuf hasn't been a guy that'll throw himself wildly out of position to make a hit or an offensive play.
 
Yeah I wasn't sold on Phaneuf when we traded for him but he's definitely won me over. And I'll echo the sentiment that I would like to see him step up into the rush more and involve himself offensively.
 
In a recent interview Phaneuf talked about a big hit and a goal are the same thing, that if you get one in at the right time, it gives the whole team so much energy and momentum. He said big hit is a double-edge sword though,that if you line one up, but miss the body, then usually the goalie has to bail you out because itwill be an odd man rush or worse, a breakaway. So what he's tried is to find that fine line and not cost his team scoring chances.

In that sense, he's already more mature than McCabe as a Leaf
 
Phaneuf is a smart hockey player. He's very calm and plays in-control. This is rare, because there are a lot of hot heads in the NHL, especially guys who play a physical game. This side of his game is really underrated.
 
It's no coincidence that Phaneuf's reputation took it's first major hit in the first year that Kipper stopped being an elite goalie. Misdiagnosing team defensive struggles by blaming dmen instead of goalies has killed many a team.

And Phaneuf does sometimes show one weakness defensively - sometimes he gets caught standing up too straight and getting turnstiled a bit, leading to him looking glaringly bad - but that happens very rarely...and I can't even really remember the last time it happened, to be honest.

I still wonder what caused the ensuing down year offensively the season after that first year he started to get criticized, though (I don't consider last year a bad offensive season, just an injured one). Might have just been a young kid reacting badly to the first criticism of his career, either losing confidence or trying to do too much, or both.
 
Iginla only scored 69 points that year, and they had 2 guys with more than 37 points so the offensive struggles weren't just reserved for Phaneuf. I think it was just one of those years for Calgary, like New Jersey had last year. Big expectations with Jokinen and Bouwmeester coming in, that they couldn't live up to, and everyone kind of crumbled under the pressue.

Except for Kipper which is kind of ironic.
 
Phaneuf and Iginla had dinner Friday night. Remember when everyone in the media said they hated each other and that's a big reason Phaneuf was traded? Oops.

Someone start the Iginla to Toronto rumours.


Maple Leafs captain Dion Phaneuf wasn’t saying who picked up the bill, but he and a couple of old Calgary Flames teammates, including Jerome Iginla, headed out for Italian food on Friday night.

“It’s good to see everyone,” a relaxed Phaneuf told reporters after the Leafs’ morning skate on Saturday. “We had some laughs, but when the puck drops, it’s all business.

“I started my career there. I had a lot of fun, made a lot of real good friendships and I can’t say enough good things about the city or the organization. But having said that, I’m really happy where I am now and it’s been a really great move for me.”

The defenceman recorded 228 points in four-plus seasons with the Flames, including 20 goals in his rookie campaign.

As for who picked up the cheque?

“Ask him (Iginla),” Phaneuf said with a grin.

Battlin’ buddies

While Phaneuf and Iginla are obviously good friends, as the Leafs captain says “it’s all business” when the two hit the ice. Iginla has told media that he likes to “chirp” at Phaneuf when the pair are out on the ice. Phaneuf didn’t deny it any, when asked if he likes to chirp back.

“We battled whether it was practice or now in the real game,” Phaneuf said. “He’s a competitive guy, I’ve got lots of respect for Iggy, the way that he plays. He scores goals but he plays really hard.”
 
Back
Top