• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

they aren't analogous. there's a level of nerves and a level of precision that is required to score goals.

case in point: watch bozak play. the guy gets all sorts of chance to score but can't finish. he hits posts, he puts it just wide, he ends up putting it right in the chest protector.
 
I wouldn't say no finish at all - he made a nifty in-tight lightning roof-job off the rush that just nicked off the crossbar. It was a pretty impressive shot, IMO.
I know which shot you're talking about. I think that was impressive and didn't see that in Frattin in previous games. As he continues to adjust to the NHL I think they will start going in for him.

I still don't see him more than a 15G scorer though, because he has almost no creativity and poor on-ice vision.
 
they aren't analogous. there's a level of nerves and a level of precision that is required to score goals.

case in point: watch bozak play. the guy gets all sorts of chance to score but can't finish. he hits posts, he puts it just wide, he ends up putting it right in the chest protector.

He's played 5 NHL games.
 
Frattin has a heavy, powerful shot but it takes him like 5 seconds to get it off. His release is way too slow for the NHL level. I'm not impressed with his game at all.
 
Fair enough, maybe I am.

Let's see what Wilson does with Kadri when he becomes available ok?

If he sends him down to the Marlies for 3-4 games just for conditioning, it's perfectly acceptable.

But just wait and see - he'll leave Kadri there until the next losing streak ... while Frattin, Orr are both on the Leafs' 23 man roster.

I agree that he'll probably send him down but also i don't think you'll see him back here any time soon. The reason is i don't think you'll see any big losing streaks (early on anyways)..This team, besides some questionable goaltending early on and few players who are adjusting on the back end, everything looks in place for a pretty good year. Personally i think Frattin has an all around better game. Kadri showed that he's got more skills but can't play in corners as well and defensively is pretty shitty. What they should do is trade this kid and one of our dman and try to get a number 1 center.
 
Yeah, its too early to pass judgment on Frattin yet, but he still has to prove he can score at this level. In not like you can say "well eventually he'll bury these chances" like you would with a proven goal scorer like Kessel.

Frattin hasn't shown the ability to produce at this level yet.
 
Yeah, its too early to pass judgment on Frattin yet, but he still has to prove he can score at this level. In not like you can say "well eventually he'll bury these chances" like you would with a proven goal scorer like Kessel.

Frattin hasn't shown the ability to produce at this level yet.

Agreed, it's only been 4 games, let's give it more time. We can just debate based on what we see for now. I honestly see a little bit of Kully in this guy..He has decent speed, hard shot and can muscle his way on the boards which is impressive because he isn't that big really. Just want to see him take more chances offensively and put a few goals to get him going. I was listening to him talk about what he's learning from Army and Lombo and he was saying how Army is really good at cycling the puck down low and Lombo uses his speed up the middle to create more room, so he's trying to do those things better as well.
 
The bottom line for me is that in his five NHL games, Frattin hasn't shown me enough that I believe he's forced us to send our top forward prospect---who really doesn't have anything more to learn/prove in the AHL---back down to the Marlies so that we can keep him in the lineup. I'd rather finally give Kadri his extended NHL shot, and give Frattin (who hasn't played a single game in the AHL yet) the chance to work out how to bury his chances in professional hockey with the Marlies.
 
The bottom line for me is that in his five NHL games, Frattin hasn't shown me enough that I believe he's forced us to send our top forward prospect---who really doesn't have anything more to learn/prove in the AHL---back down to the Marlies so that we can keep him in the lineup. I'd rather finally give Kadri his extended NHL shot, and give Frattin (who hasn't played a single game in the AHL yet) the chance to work out how to bury his chances in professional hockey with the Marlies.
Well said, there's nothing I can add.

I mean, Gardiner's flat out stolen a spot from Aulie / Franson because he had a VERY, VERY spectacular training camp.

Frattin, OTOH, has not played at a level in ANY 1 game, either in training camp or in the first 4 games to move him ahead of Kadri.
 
The bottom line for me is that in his five NHL games, Frattin hasn't shown me enough that I believe he's forced us to send our top forward prospect---who really doesn't have anything more to learn/prove in the AHL---back down to the Marlies so that we can keep him in the lineup. I'd rather finally give Kadri his extended NHL shot, and give Frattin (who hasn't played a single game in the AHL yet) the chance to work out how to bury his chances in professional hockey with the Marlies.

I can't believe we Leaf fans have already been conned into believing that we have to pick and choose between two of our best prospects, and have to pit them against each other.

Frattin and Kadri should both be on the team now, and for a long time to come. And maybe Colborne too.
 
It really does come down to that though when healthy. The Leafs have a lot of forwards. Kessel, Connolly, Lupul, Grabo, Mac, Kulemin, Lombardi, Bozak, Armstrong, Steckel, Brown, Kadri/Frattin.

Of course you could bench a guy like Lombardi, Bozak, Army, Steckel or Brown in favour of Frattin, but I'm not sure that you want to at this point. Maybe he is more effective than Brown if he can score, but without capitalizing on those chances not really.

The Leafs really do have great depth up front right now.
 
This situation is Kris Versteeg all over. Remember how Burke said it was because he didn't see a good fit on the top 6 role for him? Why not? The guy is a 20-25 goal scorer. I don't believe that for a second. He wasn't liked because he played very much like Kadri (tried to do a lot by himself, turned pucks over very often and didn't come back fast enough and work in the defensive zone)...Even Phil had those moments where he was benched because of similar shit, the thing is Kessel can put 40-50 goals and he's actually gotten better in other aspects of his game..Kadri just doesn't have enough tools..People say his vision is better than his finishing..I'd rather see Kadri go on breakaways and see those slick moves cause he can really deke. To me, when i watch him play, i get excited once in awhile when i see that act of brilliance, while at most other times i have to worry about him making a stupid decision where he goes 1 on 1 with opposing player and turns it over or because of a dumb pass...He only seems to make good passes if there's a lot of room out there (pp situation).

I will say this too, i don't care who this team plays as long as we win games..To me that's the most important thing..I'm sick and tired of losing seasons. If you love Kadri that much that's great and i hope the kid can come back and play...but if we start losing and it's mostly because of us having these players who don't think the game very well, it will be on you. I don't agree with everything Wilson does but for most part he has the winning lineup right now and i don't care for all the whining from Kadri, Franson, Komisarek or whoever else. Now for those who agree that 1 player can mean the difference between winning and losing (case in point someone mentioned Komisarek), this should be no different.
 
it'll be interesting to see what happens when Connolly sits.

Dupes really should be sat out, but more interesting is which one of Bozak, Lombo, Army, or Frattin drops down to the 4th line in his place.
 
Thing is though Dupuis has been pretty good. Wilson has been relying on him and Steckel on the PK heavily these last few games. Does the coach really take that guy out of the lineup at this point?

I have a tough time seeing a coach benching one of his most trusted PKers, especially with the history of that unit here.
 
makes me want to look at our PK numbers....


Steckel: 3:34
Dupuis: 2:39

Lombardi: 2:16
Brown: 1:55

Armstrong: 1:04
Bozak: 0:27

Grabovski: 0:29
Kulemin: 0:26

I wouldn't mind seeing a big boost in Bozak's PK time (and hte Bozak-Army pairing in general), especially when Connolly comes back to take ES time away from him.

I wouldn't mind seeing the grabo-kuly pair get more time as well.

He hasn't been used there yet but Frattin might be an option to fill Dupes' PK slot, as would Kessel.
 
This is gonna be a pretty tough call for Wilson when Connolly and Kadri becomes available, and that's gonna be some time next week.

Kadri maybe he can still buy himself (and Burke) some time by sending him to the Marlies for a conditioning stint. He WILL have to put the prized offseason signing back into the lineup whenever he becomes ready.

Fact is, sure you can move Bozak down to the 3rd line for Connolly, but nobody on the bottom 6 has played bad enough to deserve a seat in the pressbox. Steckel and Dupuis are both doing their job, Brown can scrap, and that right there is a bit of job security. Frattin's played well enough to consider a promotion from the 3rd line, so he stays obviously. Armstrong has struggled, but you know from history he is a good and smart veteran that you just don't leave off the roster if he's healthy.

So Lombardi might be cloest to the chopping block ... and that only solves 1 problem when Connolly comes back. Kadri would be much tougher to accommodate ... do you move Dupuis into the pressbox when he's been a good role player and a good PKer?
 
Back
Top