• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Mcguire was on the radio yesterday and stated that Tampa needs D (and a goalie) badly, but D first.. .and that they are looking to trade Malone for that help.

We all know that Burke has liked and shown interest in Malone before. So who knows.
 
The Bolts aren't going to get any defensive help by dangling Malone. Malone and that toxic contract of his have negative value.

I'd have to think hard about whether I'd even be willing to do a Malone/Komisarek swap.
 
Komi for Malone actually works now, with Komi not being horrific anymore.

Both make the same amount this year (5.5) with Komi being guaranteed 7 million over the next 2 years, and Malone being guaranteed 8 million over the next 3 years.

It adds some needed size upfront, with an easily movable contract as of next year (I imagine any team trying to keep up with the cap floor would dig paying 2.5 million while having him count for 4.5) should Burke decide to move him later.

Tampa is dying for blueliners, and Komi finally stopped being terrible. Hell, out of the Toronto spotlight, he may even get comfortable again.
 
I'd like Malone in Chicago....but i dont think i'd give them the obvious piece ( Hjalmarsson) that would make sense for them.

I would take him as a dump though, for like O'Donnell and a prospect.
 
I'd do Komi for Malone :)

Tampa isn't the only team that needs help on D ... Colorado is also looking for Dman, so is Anaheim.
 
Exactly ... so if we dangle any of Gunnarson, Schenn, or Franson out there we should do a WHOLE LOT better than Malone. Malone won't get you a youngish dman.

But Stevie Y, just for you, you can take Komi for Malone. :)
 
But why would we dangle Schenn, Gunn, or Franson if we can dangle our #8 defender and get a useful, big bodied forward on a very movable contract after this year?
 
Depends on what you want.

(Who's this forward anyways? You're talking about malone?)

Komi is still injured, so I don't think Stevie Y is gonna trade Malone for Komi. Even if he isn't, I highly doubt Komi is the best Stevie Y can do with Malone.

From our perspective, it depends on what route Burke is trying to take.

Malone, at best, is a band-aid.

If he's thinking long term, and he has the opportunity to get a young forward like Ryan, Stastny etc with 1 of Gunnarson, Franson or Schenn, that's a better long term move. Fact is with Gardiner already ready for top 3 minutes in the NHL, we can afford to move 1 of those guys.
 
You can't get Ryan for any of them, and you shouldn't give up Schenn for Stastny.


Nothing wrong with a good band aid to help get us into the playoffs this year, and worry about a perfect fit later.
 
When does Burke's christmas trade freeze kick in?

Something makes me think it was Dec 9 last year, but I could be wrong.
 
You can't get Ryan for any of them, and you shouldn't give up Schenn for Stastny.
We don't know if a package centered around Schenn can get us Ryan, and whether we should trade Schenn for Stastny is a separate discussion, but the point is Stastny and Ryan are building blocks for this team going forward. Malone, OTOH, is not.

Malone is the kindda player who is often available via UFA actually.


Nothing wrong with a good band aid to help get us into the playoffs this year, and worry about a perfect fit later.
Agreed, but again, comes down to what it costs us.

And it's not gonna be Komi for Malone ... heck, if any team would take Komi off our hands I'd trade him for a bag of pucks in a hurry ... it's not necessarily because Komi sucks, but just because we have plenty of depth on the blueline we have no use of Komi anymore, and we need to free up that cap space.

But trading for Malone would cost us SOMETHING useful.
 
He'd be a perfect fit, and we have more than enough assets to acquire him. He'd make this team lethal. The only question mark would be in goal.

He would make us a lot better, sure, and we even have some stuff to trade. but you're forgetting the most important part of the whole thing.

Ha? Not me, not on forumice. Don't be so obvious with the letter M with your next one (M) ate.

you already admitted it, didn't you kailyn?
 
We don't know if a package centered around Schenn can get us Ryan, and whether we should trade Schenn for Stastny is a separate discussion, but the point is Stastny and Ryan are building blocks for this team going forward. Malone, OTOH, is not.

The cost for Ryan would be significant, and we would have to outbid the league to do it. I'm not interested in outbidding every loony GM in the league for Bobby Ryan.

I never claimed Malone is a building block for this team. In fact, I as quite clear with what I thought he was. The flaw in your thinking imo, is that you're fixated on building blocks. If an opportunity to get better comes along, you take it, and worry about finding franchise building blocks later. Malone would be an opportunity to get better in an area where we need to. Net presence and along the boards.

Malone is the kindda player who is often available via UFA actually.

Sure, but in this case we can get Malone and have it be a cap neutral move by shipping Komi the other way


Agreed, but again, comes down to what it costs us.

Komi, maybe a mid round pick thrown in as icing.

And it's not gonna be Komi for Malone

I don't know why you'd say that. Malone has 3 years left on his deal to Komi's 2. They need a decent defensive defender right now a lot more than they need the 40-45 point Malone.

... heck, if any team would take Komi off our hands I'd trade him for a bag of pucks in a hurry ... it's not necessarily because Komi sucks, but just because we have plenty of depth on the blueline we have no use of Komi anymore, and we need to free up that cap space.

Thing is, you hit the nail on the head right here. Most teams lack defensive depth. As much as we've bitched about Komi, it looks like he's finally found a reasonable level of form, but even then, clearly has no place on the team. You'd be surprised what teams will do to add defensive depth. Mike Commodore was traded for, twice, at a similar cap level to Komisarek.

But trading for Malone would cost us SOMETHING useful.

Yeah, Komi & a 4th would be pretty useful to Tampa these days. Have you seen how bad their blueline looks?
 
Nobody wants Komi! Nobody. He played 10-12 good games before he got hurt, so what. It doesn't erase the last two years. And he is hurt to boot. We are stuck with him this year.

And with Franzon playing well, Schenn back on track, he has nowhere to play when he gets back.

Hopefully after this year with Finger off the books, Burke will just bury him.
 
Back
Top