• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Losing Liles sucks, but this kind of thing is just part of hockey. Time to see if Franson and/or Gardiner can step up and fill the hole while Liles is out, and if Keith Aulie can keep playing like he deserves to stick at the NHL level.
 
Concussions are almost impossible evaluate in terms of how long a player may have to sit out. The symptoms can appear suddenly after several days of a positive prognosis; similarly, a player can be back on the ice within a few days of having negative symptoms and experiencing fatigue or dizziness.

Everyone reacts differently based on the severity of the concussion and their own personal physiology. I would hope that Liles takes it easy though. He is one of the Leafs most important players and given our defensive depth this season I would prefer that he not rush things and stays out as long as necessary to recover.
 
Poor Liles. I don't like this one bit. Against faster teams our d will be chasing around in our zone even more.

no d-man on the team did more chasing around in his own end than liles.

they sure will miss him on the pp, though. he's their only d-man who can consistently carry the puck out.

should give gardiner some time on the top unit, though (at least, i hope so).
 
Franson's been great since he started getting some reasonable ice-time as the season has progressed. I'm definitely looking forward to seeing how he can respond to increased responsibility. Offensively, he might be the most efficient defender on the team.
 
remember, Liles already missed a game, and it was far from a disaster - granted, it was only the Isles.

here's how the D was used in that game:

Even Strength

Gunnar 21:17
Schenn 21:00

Phaneuf 18:57
Aulie 17:28

Gardiner 18:08
Franson 13:33


PP

Phaneuf 1:12
Gardiner 0:33
Franson: 0:21

SH

Phaneuf 2:24
Gunnar 1:58
Aulie 1:37
Schenn 0:23
 
no d-man on the team did more chasing around in his own end than liles.

they sure will miss him on the pp, though. he's their only d-man who can consistently carry the puck out.

should give gardiner some time on the top unit, though (at least, i hope so).

heh. You are usually right and in this case partially. Look at the reason for that. He's usually paired with Franson who cannot skate and do shit on the defensive end. Liles tries to do work for 2 guys out there. I'm with LoF on Franson. He has the great shot but to me he looks really bad defensively(the whole chasing around is HIS fault).
 
remember, Liles already missed a game, and it was far from a disaster - granted, it was only the Isles.

here's how the D was used in that game:

Even Strength

Gunnar 21:17
Schenn 21:00

Phaneuf 18:57
Aulie 17:28

Gardiner 18:08
Franson 13:33


PP

Phaneuf 1:12
Gardiner 0:33
Franson: 0:21

SH

Phaneuf 2:24
Gunnar 1:58
Aulie 1:37
Schenn 0:23

I don't think we're dead or anything, but Liles is a really important piece for us.

I don't think it's a coincidence that our PP is among the best in the league this year with him back there.
 
He strikes me as being totally out of shape or something. He's too slow, both with his legs and his brain.

I don't know what anyone would find impressive about him.
 
heh. You are usually right and in this case partially. Look at the reason for that. He's usually paired with Franson who cannot skate and do shit on the defensive end. Liles tries to do work for 2 guys out there. I'm with LoF on Franson. He has the great shot but to me he looks really bad defensively(the whole chasing around is HIS fault).


no, it isn't franson's fault, because it has been this way all year, whether liles has played with komisarek, gardiner or (for brief stretches) schenn.
 
no, it isn't franson's fault, because it has been this way all year, whether liles has played with komisarek, gardiner or (for brief stretches) schenn.

His play recently has been better but i still see same mistakes. He has gone from like -7 to + 1 right now...Liles is a + player while getting over 21 minutes of ice time. As for pointing out that he played with Schenn and Komi it doesn't really help your point since those guys do similar shit in terms of chasing around with their weak speed...and again Schenn only recently got his game going.
 
Franson has been really good lately IMO.

Liles is a big loss though. Its obviously much easier to handle with the emergence of Gardiner though. It also helps that they have Connolly to QB the top PP unit. Its also nice that Keith Aulie is your 7th dman. Would be much worse if a guy like Komi, Finger, Exelby or Lebda was stepping into the lineup. They should be fine, but hopefully he isn't out for too long.
 
you're right, the fact that liles has been prone to running around in his own end with every partner he has played for this year is not evidence of his problems, but all of his partner's problems defensively.

sorry, but that's ridiculous.

liles is a good defenseman.. he's strong one on one.. he's a good shot blocker.. he is very adept at getting to loose pucks and skating them out of the zone. he's also terrific on the pp.

but he clearly has coverage problems defensively, as most defensemen of ihs size/skillset do.
 
you're right, the fact that liles has been prone to running around in his own end with every partner he has played for this year is not evidence of his problems, but all of his partner's problems defensively.

sorry, but that's ridiculous.

liles is a good defenseman.. he's strong one on one.. he's a good shot blocker.. he is very adept at getting to loose pucks and skating them out of the zone. he's also terrific on the pp.

but he clearly has coverage problems defensively, as most defensemen of ihs size/skillset do.

msun, it's not ridiculous at all. The reason for it being that most people on here think that Schenn had a really bad start (even you did, admit it). Komisarek is aggressive and strong but we also know that often he makes those mental errors that gets us stuck in our own end. Put the fact our forwards haven't been helping very much in terms of getting to the point in time and clearing pucks out(our problem very often), it leads to tired players chasing around. This whole thing you have with him chasing guys around can be blamed on so many people and i really don't think he deserves the most blame.
 
yeah, it is definitely ridiculous to say that a player who has had the same problem no matter who he has been paired with doesn't have that problem, and that the problem should be attributed to all of those partners (of varied size and skillsets).
 
Back
Top