• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Suggesting it'd take Schenn, Kadri, Grabovski and Kulemin to land Getzlaf is a bit ridiculous. That's severely underrating the value of the Leaf players in that deal, and pretty much ignoring all precedent when it comes to recent deals for young "franchise" players.

Schenn, one of Kadri or Colborne and ONE first round pick would be a massively valuable package that'd definitely make Murray stop and think, though I still think all his bluster about looking to trade pretty much everyone is just his way of trying to light a fire under his team. I still don't see how it makes any sense for that franchise moving forward to divest themselves of Getzlaf or Perry.
 
We all want him so bad that we're severely overrating him and underrating the guys we would need to trade for him.

I think it takes two prime prospects and a 1st, or one prime prospect, one or two roster players, and two picks.

Kadri, Schenn and a 1st is a ton to give up. Colborne, Kadri and two 1sts is insane.

The first offer could happen. If not, Schenn, Bozak, Frattin, 1st. Something along those lines. But we won't lose more than one of Kadri, Colborne, and Schenn in any deal for Leo Getz.
 
I just had the audacity to compare Sundin to Iginla on another message board....oh God!! the natives are riled up about that one.
 
I'd give up either Kadri or Schenn in a trade for Getzlaf, perhaps include Bozak as well. There's really no need for Bozak after we acquire Getzlaf anyways. Something like;

Schenn + Colborne + 2nd round draft pick for Getzlaf + 3rd

or

Kadri + Colborne + Bozak + 1st round draft pick for Getzlaf

I think Schenn is very valuable, much more so than Kadri. I'd hate to give up either. It seems we'd have no choice though. If we could throw in a combination of Bozak + Kulie + Grabo instead of those two, we'd be golden.
 
Its not all of our top prospects though. Its 2 of our top 5 prospects (Kadri, Schenn, Gardiner, Colborne, Reimer). And Aulie can step in for Schenn, and ****ing Getzlaf can step in for Kadri/Colborne.
 
The thing is, big 1st line centers are just SO RARE in this league if Getzlaf is even available, you will HAVE TO pay a steep price for him.

I'm not trading BOTH Kadri and Colborne, that's all I'm gonna say. Between the 2, I'd much rather keep Kadri.

If we can get Getzlaf for say, a packge with Schenn and Colborne as the major pieces, I'd do it in a second.
 
1 of our goalies: Reimer, Gus, Scrivens, Rynnas, Owuya

1 of our young defensemen: Schenn, Franson, Gardiner, Aulie, Blacker, Percy

1 of our young forwards: Colborne, Kadri, Frattin

1 of our vet forwards: Connolly, Grabovski, Bozak, MacArthur, Kulemin, Lombardi, Armstrong


That should do it.
 
1 of our goalies: Reimer, Gus, Scrivens, Rynnas, Owuya

1 of our young defensemen: Schenn, Franson, Gardiner, Aulie, Blacker, Percy

1 of our young forwards: Colborne, Kadri, Frattin

1 of our vet forwards: Connolly, Grabovski, Bozak, MacArthur, Kulemin, Lombardi, Armstrong


That should do it.

That's much better zeke. I think that would be enough or close to anyways.

I find it funny that people are putting such high values on Schenn and Colborne when Schenn as you put it has sucked badly this season and is a 5-6th dman on our roster right now. He's been very Komi like(even Komi looks better). Colborne is still going to have a tough time cracking the NHL lineup simply because he has quite a few things to work on(skating, body strength, defensive game). If i'm a Ducks GM and take a look at that offer i simply must think it's a joke because a) i am not helping my team right now at all b) i'm gambling with the future picks who may/may not turn into anything good..So i'm giving up my premier player for what? Future potential? It's not like we're talking here about a young Tyler Seguin so we know what we are receiving. The Ducks GM made it very clear he wants roster players who can play right away and here we are giving scrap pieces.
 
We have enough depth that there really shouldn't be a single player that would be a sticking point from our end...

With that said, I would hate to give up Kadri, but for Getzlaf you kinda have to. Schenn, Colborne, + is probably a good starting point. We have enough defensive depth that losing Luke wouldn't sting too too much, and Getz/Connolly/Kadri/Bozak make Colborne more expendable.
 
I don't disagree it'll take a lot to pry Getzlaf from Anaheim (heck, I said that myself) but that said, let's also keep things in perspective.

1. The Ducks are in the middle of a terrible season. Murray will not be dealing from a position of strength, but a position of a weakness.

2. Getzlaf, with 7G and 20 Points through the first half of the season, is also in a terrible slump. If he is on the Leafs, he'd be ranked 9th in scoring, behind Bozak, MacArthur and Connolly - all of which have played fewer games than Getzlaf due to injuries. And this is Getzlaf who has the luxury of playing with the likes of Selanne, Perry, Ryan. Obviously, Getzlaf's trade value at this point is no where close to say, last season.

3. The last time Burke traded for a slumping super-star in his mid-20's he paid a package that included Ian White as the best player in that deal.

4. The last time Burke traded with Murray he acquired Lupul and Gardiner for Beauchemin.

It would be silly to focus on Schenn's slump in the first month of this season (or, every season) and overlook the slump Getzlaf is currently in. It would be equally silly to assume Murray would get maximum value for Getzlaf when his team is one of the worst teams in the league.

I still don't think Murray would trade Getzlaf ... if I were him I'd trade Ryan before I trade Getzlaf, but if he does, I won't be surprised a package centered around Schenn + Colborne can get it done.
 
Back
Top