• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Chara
Keith
Lidstrom
Phaneuf
Suter
Weber

I'd say those 6 are definite top-10 defensemen, then you have a whack of guys who arguably belong there but are maybe a bit more inconsistent or unproven - Boyle, Green, Letang, Karlsson, Doughty, Myers, Edler...maybe guys like Enstrom, Bouwmeester, Pietrangelo, Girardi.

Not Jay-Bo...

And i pout Letang in the big group for sure...ahead of Phaneuf.
 
I wouldn't call Keith overly physical, i mean he can be.....but not overly.

Mind you...the Keith's, Lidstrom's and Letang's don't need to be.
 
I dunno, 5 of 7 seasons on pace for ~50 or more points to start a career is pretty damn good. This will be Letang's second so I don't see the big deal with having him below Phaneuf.
 
Stop comparing Phaneuf to Weber.

Weber is a top-5 defenceman in this league. Phaneuf is Bryan McCabe.

stop comparing phaneuf to mccabe

phaneuf is a top-10 defenseman in this league. mccabe is 36 years old and all but retired.
 
McCabe was an awesome player in his own right during his prime with us.

But he was very prone to stupid defensive errors, and was anti-clutch when it came to those errors in the playoffs in particular. He also had a great ass-check, but aside from that wasn't the most physical guy we had; he wouldn't fight often (or at all?).

Phaneuf is a lot better in his own end, also a better skater and passer, and has a lot more offensive skill (much of it still somewhat dormant, imo).

Phaneuf's the better player in his prime for sure. But McCabe was great too.
 
Keith>Dion for sure.

Not Seabrook no...he is what he is...a very good number 2...andif we got Weber...the best number 3 in the show
I'd take Dion over Keith, personally. Keith doesn't really have the physical/intimidation angle to his game that Phaneuf has. It's also sort of looking like his 14-goal, 69-point was an outlier, and that about 7 goals/45 points is pretty much his regular offensive ceiling, which means Phaneuf gets the edge on him offensively as well. Though I do also recognize the weakness of that position, with Phaneuf coming off 30 point/66game and 32 point/82 game seasons prior to this one. We'll see how they both do over the next few years.
 
As for Phaneuf vs. McCabe, I guess I'm not inclined to see comparisons to Bryan McCabe as an insult like some. Like most Maple Leaf players, and Maple Leaf defensemen in particular, McCabe was criminally underrated during his time here. He was physical, enthusiastic and had a four-out-of-five-year stretch for us where he was one of the most dominant offensive defensemen in the league. But he's not really a great comparison for Phaneuf. McCabe was a late bloomer, who struggled early in his career while bouncing between three different horrible teams before finding a home and his groove in Toronto. Phaneuf on the other hand, was a dominant NHL defenseman from the moment he stepped onto the ice as a 20 year-old.

In terms of their physical games, McCabe wasn't great at picking his spots and was only really a threat to players along the boards when they were coming into the Leaf zone. Phaneuf on the other hand is a threat all over the ice, he's one of the best open-ice hitters to come along on defense in the past 20 years and he's much smarter about not throwing himself wildly out of position to make a hit like McCabe was sometimes known to do. Their offensive games (at McCabe's peak, anyways) are where they're most similar, I guess. Both guys have booming point shots that get them more than their share of goals, and result in some assists for them as well. I'd say Phaneuf's a superior puck-mover and distributor, however---McCabe had to lean very heavily on Tomas Kaberle for that portion of his game. In the defensive zone, both are prone to the occasional mistake, but Phaneuf is a much smarter player in his own zone, isn't prone to chucking grenades like McCabe was and is a lot calmer with the puck.
 
Burke on bad trades:

“The good news is, if you make enough good trades, people forget about the horses— trades that you’ve made. People ask me, ‘what’s the worst trade you’ve made?’ And I would have to think hard about that, but I could tell you a couple real bad ones.”

He paused for a beat.

“A second-round pick in Vancouver for Vadim Sharifijanov.”

Burke paused again.

“That’s right. Everyone’s going, ‘who?’ Exactly. That’s pretty good evidence. I just told you it’s a bad trade. Now, it’s a bad trade. We overrated this player, we overpaid for him, but we fixed it. Right away, we said, ‘OK, we’re wrong.’ We got rid of the guy, put someone in the lineup who could help us more. We never recovered from that particular mistake, but we didn’t dwell on it and say, ‘maybe he’ll turn into a player.”

Burke took a breath.

“We traded Donald Brashear for Jan Hlavac and a pick. Jan Hlavac. Exactly. Now, Jan Hlavac is a great kid; actually played a couple hundred NHL games, but didn’t work out in Vancouver. But we flipped Jan Hlavac for Marek Malik, who played six years for us and was Ed Jovanovski’s defence partner. A 6-foot-6 defenceman taken in the ’93 draft, one round after Chris Pronger … so we fixed the mistake.”
Burke on the relationship between NHL GMs:

“We traded — I want to say in 2005 — Sandis Ozolinsh to the New York Rangers at the deadline for, I think, a third-round pick. And he was battling alcohol issues. He’d been sober with us, stayed sober with the Rangers and then, the night after they were eliminated in the playoffs, he was arrested on a DUI in Westchester County. Glen Sather, was the GM in New York, called me. He said, ‘I thought you said this kid was sober.’ I said, ‘Well, he was here, he was in counseling.’ And then, it turns out the kid’s got microfractures in his knee, and he needs surgery. Well, we didn’t know about the microfractures, but Slats sends me a bill for $65,000 for the surgery from this doctor in Vail. I sent it back to him. I said, ‘I’m not paying this. I didn’t know he was hurt.’”

Burke skipped ahead to 2009, when the Leafs acquired defenceman Erik Reitz from the Sather and the Rangers.

“We knew he was injured, but Slats said, ‘he’s in a walking cast, he’s fine.’ And so, he gets off the plane and he’s got a fractured tibia and he’s about 24 pounds overweight because he hasn’t been able to skate. We owed him about $50,000 in salary for the rest of the year. So I called Slats, I said, ‘walking cast my ass, this guy’s a cripple and he’s fat.’”

The crowd laughed.

“Slats said, ‘put him on a plane.’ He was going to take him back, to honour his word. I said, ‘you know what? You’re going to find out that there is some honour in the game. You think I owe you $60,000 from earlier, you’re going to collect it now. We’re going to keep the kid. And Erik Reitz is actually a good kid. It wasn’t his fault. So there is some honour in the game — but I still took [Sather] for $20,000 on the differential.”

http://sports.nationalpost.com/2012/01/26/leafs-gm-brian-burke-on-the-perils-of-nhl-trading/
 
Back
Top