• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

The thing with Carter is, we can all perfectly understand and empathize with him on his trade to Columbus. He signed pretty much a life-time contract with a NTC that he thought was going to guarantee he'd be staying in one of the best hockey markets in the States...and then the team used a (well-known) loophole in the CBA to trade him to a backwater city (no offense, undead, if you're reading this) to play for one of the league's most ineptly-run, uncompetitive franchises. Most of us would still gladly trade places with him, but we can understand him being upset.

However, a normal, mature human being playing in the NHL wouldn't ignore all attempts at communication by his new team for weeks after the deal, and then very clearly dog it once the season starts as a reaction to being upset about a trade. That kind of pouty, petulant behaviour wouldn't even be tolerated from a 10 year-old kid, let alone a fully grown professional athlete being paid obscene amounts of money to play a game for a living.

a mature human being would also slow down on the partying when his coach basically said 'c'mon pal, we need you to set a better example'.

i'm not surprised to see this guy sulking.

whatever, the lazy idiot's a good fit on columbus next to fatty nash.
 
I'm more concerned with him being a bitch that doesn't show up in the playoffs.

He's also a bad teammate who ****ed Hartnell's wife. I don't want that one-dimensional cancer anywhere near the Leafs roster. Our dressing room seems to have an excellent vibe to it and I'm of the belief that such a positive equilibrium can be upset with the introduction of negative personalities like Carter.
 
She is stunning.

rittenhouse-hartnell-flyers-higres.jpg



edit: proof
 
Kessel and Phaneuf came with the dressing room cancer tag as well, and that's worked out just fine.


Phaneuf didn't get along with Regehr, Kessel was loved in the dressing room, there wasn't a single word about him being a problem until after they couldn't agree to a contract.

The Boston media did the same thing to Marc Savard when it looked like he was going to be traded....all of a sudden there was talk of him being a problem in the dressing room.
 
You're proving the point. There's all sorts of talk about how guys are in the dressing room in one city, and then they go to another city and they're fine.

If anything, I'd think Carter's alleged partying (hell, maybe it was one drink in the dressing room one time) made him more popular in there.

I just don't think that kind of bullshit needs to be taken into consideration, unless it's something serious, a la Avery, who everyone in there pretty much hates.
 
This is now 2 cities where Carter is a problem. That of course completely neglects the fact the guy ain't all that good to begin with.
 
You're proving the point. There's all sorts of talk about how guys are in the dressing room in one city, and then they go to another city and they're fine.

Only there was never "all sorts of talk" about Phaneuf & Kessel. There was literally no talk about Kessel until he wanted out, then the Bruins mediots threw him under the bus (despite anyone who means anything in their dressing room saying that he was well liked). As for Phaneuf, the beef with he and Regehr was well known, it was his only dressing room problem.

Carter wasn't run out of philly for one drink, he was run out of town for being a party boy (who happened to rail Hartnell's wife allegedly) who choked horrifically when the games got important. Then he showed a complete lack of professionalism in how he acted towards his new franchise (who clearly wanted him, and paid a large price to get him). He showed the type of "character" you expect from someone who is a problem in the dressing room.

If anything, I'd think Carter's alleged partying (hell, maybe it was one drink in the dressing room one time) made him more popular in there.

only it doesn't seem that he (or Mike Richards) were very popular there.

I just don't think that kind of bullshit needs to be taken into consideration, unless it's something serious, a la Avery, who everyone in there pretty much hates.

I typically agree, but this one checks off all of the boxes, especially if he nailed a team mates wife. He was a well known party boy, and showed a complete lack of character if how he treated his new franchise after the trade. There weren't a whole bunch of ex team mates jumping to his defence when the media was throwing him under the bus either...as there was when both Phaneuf & Kessel were being lambasted.


But as mentioned by someone else, most of this is besides the point. He's a 1 dimensional floater who has a lifetime contract (with NTC) and continually disappears in big games. He's just not the type of player you want to attach yourself to long term imo.
 
My buddy knew Jeff Carter kind of, but more so the group of friends he hung out with while he was still in London and the dude was a big time bar hopper. I would not be surprised if he was still like this or even worse when he got that big fat contract from philly.

Then again so was Corey Perry when he played for the knights and that never seem to affect him or his team (that I know of).
 
I really can't blame a 26 year old millionaire hockey player for partying. I can't blame a 26 year old anything for partying.

The on ice stuff is what I'm scared of. I would have gladly taken Mike Richards (not at the trade cost though).
 
i think you can definitely blame a 26 millionaire for partying when it's during the stretch drive and his coach asks him to stop... and his team's best player, who has a hart trophy, a cup ring, and been to the cup with 3 different teams asks him to stop.

the problem isn't that he likes drinking. the problem is that he pretty clearly doesn't understand the commitment it takes to win.
 
i think you can definitely blame a 26 millionaire for partying when it's during the stretch drive and his coach asks him to stop... and his team's best player, who has a hart trophy, a cup ring, and been to the cup with 3 different teams asks him to stop.

the problem isn't that he likes drinking. the problem is that he pretty clearly doesn't understand the commitment it takes to win.

Meh. Richards was also in that group and he led the Flyers to the cup final while scoring a point per game in the playoffs. Don't think its related to drinking. Just think Carter doesn't have the commitment to do what it takes to win period.
 
the Flyers haven't missed those two crazy overrated players, and neither of helped improve their new team, either.
 
Back
Top