• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

and luke schenn's playing at a 25 point pace as a 21 year old, which is pretty solid for a physical defensive defenseman at that age.

i see them as similar players with similar upsides and similar limitations.


I see them as similarly valued players, one because he's already close to his ultimate ceiling, and the other because he's still progressing towards his (which imo, is ultimately higher)

The list of power forwards that produce at or around a 50 pt pace as 22 year olds and are incredibly valuable players for the entirety of their careers, is significantly longer (imo) that the list of defensive defenseman that are 25 point dmen at 21, and evolve into much more than that.

Nothing in Schenn's past leads me to believe his offensive upside is that of someone who will produce much higher than he is now.....JVR's, does.
 
At the risk of sounding like teeds, I just can't possibly see how Schenn can ever overcome his horrific FIRST STEP and ever become a true big-minute shutdown defenseman.
 
I see them as similarly valued players, one because he's already close to his ultimate ceiling, and the other because he's still progressing towards his (which imo, is ultimately higher)

The list of power forwards that produce at or around a 50 pt pace as 22 year olds and are incredibly valuable players for the entirety of their careers, is significantly longer (imo) that the list of defensive defenseman that are 25 point dmen at 21, and evolve into much more than that.

Nothing in Schenn's past leads me to believe his offensive upside is that of someone who will produce much higher than he is now.....JVR's, does.

Pretty much. JVR might stagnate offensively and not be much more of an impact player from this point further (and a big 25-25-50 forward is still quite valuable provided they're signed to a reasonable contract), but even if he doesn't improve he still possesses quite a bit of value. Schenn on the other hand was one of the most polished players in the 2008 draft, physically very mature, and this gave him an advantage in terms of being able to play in the NHL immediately, but it may be that he has less room for additional development as a consequence of his early polish.

Van Riemsdyk came into the league as an incredibly raw player with only a handful of NCAA campaigns at a middling division I program under his belt. Of course, the odds that van Riemsdyk doesn't improve at all are quite minimal IMO. His career trajectory three seasons in matches up quite favourably with other power forwards like Graves, Leclair, and Bertuzzi. Most of them had a season or two where they produced at around a 50 point pace and then took massive steps forward into being franchise producers shortly thereafter.
 
speaking of Tavares, if we are going to give up all of our assets for a top line Center, it should be someone like Tavares instead of Getzlaf
 
I see them as similarly valued players, one because he's already close to his ultimate ceiling, and the other because he's still progressing towards his (which imo, is ultimately higher)

The list of power forwards that produce at or around a 50 pt pace as 22 year olds and are incredibly valuable players for the entirety of their careers, is significantly longer (imo) that the list of defensive defenseman that are 25 point dmen at 21, and evolve into much more than that.

Nothing in Schenn's past leads me to believe his offensive upside is that of someone who will produce much higher than he is now.....JVR's, does.

i think it's debateable as to how high jvr's ceiling is.

the late-breakout power forward stories (a la leclaire and bertuzzi) are becoming increasingly rare... getzlaf, perry, etc. were all good in their early 20s. most of the late breakout guys have only become 50-60 point guys.... clowe, malone, etc. and those guys are only debatably better than what i think schenn's likely destined to become (and even that is arguable... plus, i still hold out some hope that schenn can develop into an adam foote type of shut down defender, which is much more valuable than a clowe or malone).
 
speaking of Tavares, if we are going to give up all of our assets for a top line Center, it should be someone like Tavares instead of Getzlaf

Why?

Both are young players but Getzlaf is the type of physical monster that Tavares could only dream of becoming. And he has a record of winning and championship experience that JT lacks.
 
Larry Murphy wasn't prone to "defensive lapses" any more than a lot of high-minute defensemen would be on a teams as awful as the 95/96 and 96/97 Leafs. And as much as it is a suspect stat, it's pretty impressive that Murphy managed to be only a -2 in his full season with us in 95/96, and a +1 in his 69 games with us in 96/97, when the rest of the defensemen the Leafs dressed during that same period were a combined -101.
 
Much like Schenn, Murphy also had NO FIRST STEP, thus when he got burnt, he got burnt BADLY.
 
Schenn's absolute best case projection would be Scott Stevens ... but he doesn't really have Steven's offensive talent. If he develops into Adam Foote, that would be very good for us already.

Schenn and Stevens are nothing alike- Stevens had decent mobility and a penchant for ripping people's heads off when they crossed the blueline. Schenn lacks mobility, and while he is a solid and frequent hitter, he doesn't throw open ice bombs like Stevens did, nor does he hit to hurt. I'll put this in a simpler context- Schenn hits to take people out of the play, Stevens hit people to take them out of the game.

Schenn is far more similiar to an Adam Foote type player.
 
i think it's debateable as to how high jvr's ceiling is.

the late-breakout power forward stories (a la leclaire and bertuzzi) are becoming increasingly rare... getzlaf, perry, etc. were all good in their early 20s. most of the late breakout guys have only become 50-60 point guys.... clowe, malone, etc. and those guys are only debatably better than what i think schenn's likely destined to become (and even that is arguable... plus, i still hold out some hope that schenn can develop into an adam foote type of shut down defender, which is much more valuable than a clowe or malone).

I'd need more names than just Perry-Getzlaf, when history has shown that in most instances it takes longer for power forwards to develop.......hell, even Perry, only put up 54 points his age 22 season, while JVR's currently playing at a 48 point pace. (and I'd never dream of saying JVR has the kind of upside Perry does, simply that he didn't "break out" until he was 23)

Guys like Malone and Clowe, weren't NHL regulars until they were a year older than JVR is now (although admittedly, they both did have strong opening campaigns)


That said, I'd gladly trade Schenn for a 22 year old version of either of them....
 
Much like Schenn, Murphy also had NO FIRST STEP, thus when he got burnt, he got burnt BADLY.

murphy got turned at the bluelines sometimes.

the first step thing can be overcome with guile, physicality and most importantly smarts.

svehla had no first step but it barely seemed to burn him.

chara doesn't have much of a first step but he doesn't get beat.

even phaneuf takes a few strides before he gets going.

schenn has had some troubles thsi year.. he had them early last year, but came around by the end of the year/

not sure why he keeps regresing in that regard; for him though it just has to be a matter of anticipating the move to the outside and closing the space by cutting hte man off along the wall before he can burst by.
 
Why?

Both are young players but Getzlaf is the type of physical monster that Tavares could only dream of becoming. And he has a record of winning and championship experience that JT lacks.

If you have to ask, then it's not worth explaining. JT is younger (fits in more with age of team) and is going to be better than Getz, if not already.
 
Schenn and Stevens are nothing alike- Stevens had decent mobility and a penchant for ripping people's heads off when they crossed the blueline. Schenn lacks mobility, and while he is a solid and frequent hitter, he doesn't throw open ice bombs like Stevens did, nor does he hit to hurt. I'll put this in a simpler context- Schenn hits to take people out of the play, Stevens hit people to take them out of the game.

Schenn is far more similiar to an Adam Foote type player.

You can't say that Schenn lacks mobility and then compare him to one of the most mobile defencemen in the league during his heyday in Foote. He made three Olympic teams largely on his skating ability (his career high in points was only 31), which has a lot more importance on international-sized surfaces.
 
Why?

Both are young players but Getzlaf is the type of physical monster that Tavares could only dream of becoming. And he has a record of winning and championship experience that JT lacks.
Yes, but JT is also the more skilled and better offensive player of the 2. Quite a lot more skilled, in fact.

But who's fooling who here? NYI is NOT trading JT. Zero chance.
 
If you have to ask, then it's not worth explaining. JT is younger (fits in more with age of team) and is going to be better than Getz, if not already.

And Getzlaf isn't exactly an old man out there.

At 26 years old he would fit in with the average age of the team just fine and would be re-united with fellow 2003 first round pick and 2004 and 2005 Team Canada WJC teammate Dion Phaneuf.

Yes, but JT is also the more skilled and better offensive player of the 2. Quite a lot more skilled, in fact.

But who's fooling who here? NYI is NOT trading JT. Zero chance.

You're comparing apples and oranges to begin with. There is absolutely no question that Tavares is the superior natural goal-scorer between the pair. He could even challenge for Rocket Richards at some point in the near future. But Getzlaf is also one of the league's most elite play-makers and until JT establishes himself as a reliable 80-90 point guy like Getzlaf has produced prior to this season, it's somewhat disingenuous to claim that he's the superior overall offensive player. They each have divergent strengths.
 
You can't say that Schenn lacks mobility and then compare him to one of the most mobile defencemen in the league during his heyday in Foote. He made three Olympic teams largely on his skating ability (his career high in points was only 31), which has a lot more importance on international-sized surfaces.
Yeah why do people assume Foote is slow? He was offensively challenged but he was by no means a slow skater.

You can't be an effective shut-down defenseman, even in the clutch & grab days of the NHL, if you're lead-footed.
 
You confused Larry Murphy with Larry Robinson didn't you?

msun basically explained it so no i am not confused. I was in mid teens at the time i guess.

I was saying mostly that if Luke can be a bit smarter with the type of passes he makes and all, he can become the assist guy similar to Murphy (and yeah their skating is so similar).
 
Back
Top