• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

By the way, Burke sure knows suppressed NHL level talent huh? He has been trying to pry Sam Gagner out of Edmonton for quite some time now according to my guys, but has not been able to do his usual holdup, LOL.

Sam Gagner pulled a Sittler PLUS last night. Scored eight points in one NHL hockey game. Think his stock just soared???
 
We saw Svehla at a much later age than Schenn. Schenn was rushed, so we may see him improve a lot still. The thing about Schenn is he is raw as an organic egg at sunrise still. I wish he had merely been given the customary two or three years of lower league development.

Schenn did a good job of playing against a great player the other night(Malkin). I would have let this guy plied his trade at the lower levels to develop the confidence to carry the puck and do all the little things that guys like Liles and Gardiner do, with no apparent effort. Its all about tons and tons of practise, at the appropriate level.

I am teaching tons of kids for free right now, and my favourite drill is letting one kid have the puck and letting three other kids get in his OR HER way, but NOT taking the puck. Allowing tons and tons of puck carrying.

What does teeder want? Puck carrying, puck carrying, puck carrying. And the NHL is the hardest place in the world to learn that. THAT is why I don't shit all over Schenn any more.

I generally agree now that it was shortsighted to play Schenn in the NHL right out of his post draft season. You do see the raw tools for a decent offensive defender in him (~35+ points), that are coming along fairly slowly.

With that said though....he really did earn himself a role on the team as an 18 year old, and it's hard to deny a player the opportunity to play in the NHL if they're good enough to do it, just because you think they might develop differently if you force them to play in a league they're too good to play in just so they dominate it.
 
I think we do tend to forget how young Schenn is sometimes ... he plays a lot more mature than his age. Obviously, he can still develop, but as compared to how pleased I was with him in his rookie then his sophomore season, I think his development has regressed.

But he's still a very young player in this league, and even younger among defensemen.
 
I think we do tend to forget how young Schenn is sometimes ... he plays a lot more mature than his age. Obviously, he can still develop, but as compared to how pleased I was with him in his rookie then his sophomore season, I think his development has regressed.

But he's still a very young player in this league, and even younger among defensemen.
Yeah, to us Schenn is just another veteran now. But it really puts things into perspective when you realize he's the same age as Joe Colborne and Jake Gardiner, and yet he's halfway through his fourth full season in the NHL.
 
I think Schenn may be struggling competing for ice time with some many other dmen. He's never really had to do that before.
 
I generally don't buy into the notion that a player would get better playing in the AHL than the NHL.

I don't think Schenn would be Doughty-esque now if he had played a year on the Marlies.
 
The problem is that Schenn would have had to play a minimum of one additional year in Kelowna (no under 20 year-old North Americans allowed in the AHL) and THEN a year with the Marlies if the Leafs brass wanted him to get the requisite pre-NHL professional experience.
 
depends onthe player, but nobody is saying he should have been in the ahl... jsut that another year or two in junior might have benefited him.

there might be some truth to it... just look at tyler myers, who was a good step behind schenn offensively when they played together in 07-08... but in 08-09 myers had a chance to get big pp minutes and a lot of time on the puck, which schenn didn't get in the nhl, and took a big leap forward. some of that i'm sure is his skating, but some of it is also experience.

schenn never had a real shot to develop his offensive game, from his shot, to time spent on the puck.

maybe it would have benefited him, maybe it woudln't have -- we'll never know... but there is some evidence to suggest htat it would have.
 
The problem is that Schenn would have had to play a minimum of one additional year in Kelowna (no under 20 year-old North Americans allowed in the AHL) and THEN a year with the Marlies if the Leafs brass wanted him to get the requisite pre-NHL professional experience.

requisite?

huh?

i dno't think anybody is saying the ahl would have been a necessary stepping stone.. just that another year or two in junior might have helped schenn gain some confidence with the puck.

when you watch him stickhandle, he shows some real promising signs, especially on his side of the ice. but at times he's jsut clueless from the offensive blueline in.
 
Good point Jays.

The year in Kelowna would be a complete waste of time.

I generally think players are better off learning the game in the AHL until they are really ready, but in Schenn's case I think it was the right call to have him in the NHL at 18.
 
I think it's dangerous to assume that the same policy benefits every young defenceman when they all have different strengths and weaknesses. A guy like Josh Gorges (another Kelowna product) played his nineteen year-old season with the Rockets and it hasn't turned him into a prolific NHL producer by any stretch.

And he was a considerably better offensive defenceman in junior (seasons of 41, 59 and 42 points) than Schenn ever was pre-NHL.
 
requisite?

huh?

i dno't think anybody is saying the ahl would have been a necessary stepping stone.. just that another year or two in junior might have helped schenn gain some confidence with the puck.

when you watch him stickhandle, he shows some real promising signs, especially on his side of the ice. but at times he's jsut clueless from the offensive blueline in.

What don't you get?

If you're a North American product you don't get to play in the AHL before age 20. If the team wanted him to get one pro season in the AHL before he came to the NHL he would need to play an extra year in the WHL.
 
who said anything about needing a pro season under his belt?

pretty sure the only argument that was made was that he might have benefited from a year of being able to dominate junior... just like his teammate tyler myers, who spent the extra year rounding out his offensive game
 
Vitas Gerulaitis once said the worst mistake he made was playing in practise all the time with better players, Borg, Mcenroe and Connors. He never played with anyone who he was better than, in practise. So his game was more counterpunch. And that hit me him saying that.

Its important to play with better competition sure. But as any boxing manager will tell you, its pretty important to gain confidence and fill people in like a buttertart as well.
 
depends onthe player, but nobody is saying he should have been in the ahl... jsut that another year or two in junior might have benefited him.

there might be some truth to it... just look at tyler myers, who was a good step behind schenn offensively when they played together in 07-08... but in 08-09 myers had a chance to get big pp minutes and a lot of time on the puck, which schenn didn't get in the nhl, and took a big leap forward. some of that i'm sure is his skating, but some of it is also experience.

schenn never had a real shot to develop his offensive game, from his shot, to time spent on the puck.

maybe it would have benefited him, maybe it woudln't have -- we'll never know... but there is some evidence to suggest htat it would have.

I was drooling over Myers back then, but I'd take Schenn over him right now.

I don't know what kind of adrenaline was pumping in Myers' veins back then, but he's sure out of whatever is was now.
 
Back
Top