• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

No deal for those guys.

It's the "B" assets that will go in any deal - Kadri, Aulie, etc., not Colborne, Gardiner.
First of all, no way you get Nash for strictly "B" players. In fact, I'd say Nash will fetch more than Gardiner + Colborne + 1st.

2. interesting you call Kadri a "B" prospect but Colborne an "A" ... but I won't go there.
 
No it wouldn't.

And that is a steep price to pay, but I'd probably make that trade.

No way would i give Gardiner for any player(and i like Nash very much)...This kid is going to be great and i don't think dmen like Jake come around so often. Right now his only weakness is that of any young player that comes into the league and that's his mental game is off at times...He can defend very well, vision, skating, skill and so on is all there.
 
Fair enough. It's been precisely thirteen years since the Leafs had a young rookie puck-moving defenceman as talented as Gardiner burst onto the scene. I'll let you guess who that was...
 
The price for Nash will be unbelievably high for whoever trades for him. Columbus is in no rush to trade him, nor are they desperate to make the playoffs, this season is done for them, so they are more then willing to hold out for the highest offer. Teams like the leafs aren't in the drivers seat here, they are desperate to make the playoffs and badly need a guy like Nash, basically Columbus has the upper hand here.
 
I'd say 1 - as much as I like Gardiner, I don't see him as an untouchable. As per Eakins, Gardiner may not be an offensive defenseman in the NHL. He will be a very effective defenseman who can move puck up ice quickly and with confidence, he can log a lot of minutes, but not sure he'll be a consistent 40-50 points dman in the NHL.

Second of all, I think you're under-estimating the value of a consistent 30+G power forward who's only 28, and I don't even like Nash all that much.
 
The price for Nash will be unbelievably high for whoever trades for him. Columbus is in no rush to trade him, nor are they desperate to make the playoffs, this season is done for them, so they are more then willing to hold out for the highest offer. Teams like the leafs aren't in the drivers seat here, they are desperate to make the playoffs and badly need a guy like Nash, basically Columbus has the upper hand here.

They said the same thing about Kovalchuk.
 
Fair enough. It's been precisely thirteen years since the Leafs had a young rookie puck-moving defenceman as talented as Gardiner burst onto the scene. I'll let you guess who that was...

Yeah the kid has almost no flaws right now...Ron was saying last night how he was our best dman (hard to argue since Dion and even Liles have looked kinda shaky). I don't know why i thought Kabs was with us for longer (i was thinking more like 16-17 years) but yeah another great one..It'll be nice if Jake becomes even better than Kaberle(and he has the tools).
 
They had to trade Kovalchuk. Plus he's got some serious character issues, and if I remember correctly was an expiring contract.

The BJ's don't have to trade Nash. They are going to want to get at least one young player who looks like a potential stud ... that's why Bernier and Gardiner make sense. If they feel that way about either Schenn or Kadri, we might have a chance, but the deal Corky suggested is along the lines of what it will take.
 
The BJ's don't have to trade Nash. They are going to want to get at least one young player who looks like a potential stud ... that's why Bernier and Gardiner make sense. If they feel that way about either Schenn or Kadri, we might have a chance, but the deal Corky suggested is along the lines of what it will take.

The Flyers didn't have to trade Carter or Richards either.

Every single year there are big names up for grabs and people always consistently over-estimate what it will take to acquire them. Every. Single. Year.


Stop falling for the blatantly obvious hype, people.
 
They said the same thing about Kovalchuk.

Big difference- Kovalchuck was a pending UFA that offseason, New Jersey wasn't going to overpay for the guy when he could be have been had for free several short months later. Nash has a fair number of years left on his contract, and Columbus isn't making the playoffs, again they are in NO rush to trade the guy, they can afford to wait it out and drive up the trading value for Nash.
 
Back
Top