• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Its not about Nash vs Kessel as much as it would be Nash and Kessel. I'm not going to argue over which player is better as we clearly have our own biases and determinants. The fact remains that neither player has played with someone of this skill level.

Having Kessel - Nash - Carter - Lupul as our core forwards would leave us in pretty good shape should we be able to find a goalie that can make a save.
 
It has nothing to do with what "people" want. It's holding Burke accountable to his own standards.

can you describe Burke's vision for me, by the way?

He had to completely strip a club with an empty cupboard down and fill it back up again. In three years he's added Kessel, Lupul, Phaneuf, Gardiner and Colborne for some picks and a lot of nothing. He's stocked the prospect pool. He has built the youngest team in the NHL and they are currently in a playoff spot 2/3 of the way into the season.

There is no earth where Brian Burke isn't satisfying his standards.

His vision was to add talent, and build a team that is fast and skilled enough to beat a skilled team in the playoffs, big and tough enough to beat a big team, and good enough on the special teams to beat a team with good special teams. Is he done? Has he reached his perfect team? Of course not. But anyone expecting that process to be finished 3 years in is insane.

The Leafs haven't been on this good of an upward trend though since Quinn's early days.
 
What's the highest point total a Rick Nash linemate has ever produced?

Columbus Blue Jackets Points Leaders

2002-03: Ray Whitney (76 points) - not a Nash line-mate.
Rick Nash (39 points)
Tyler Wright (30 points) - Nash line-mate.
Grant Marshall (28 points) - Nash line-mate.

2003-04: Rick Nash (57 points)
David Vyborny (53 points) - Nash line-mate.
Todd Marchant (34 points) - Nash line-mate.

2005-06: David Vyborny (65 points) - Nash line-mate.
Rick Nash (54 points)
Nikolai Zherdev (54 points) - not a Nash line-mate.

2006-07: David Vyborny (64 points) - Nash line-mate
Rick Nash (57 points)
Sergei Fedorov (42 points) - Nash line-mate.

2007-08: Rick Nash (69 points)
Nikolai Zherdev (61 points) - Nash line-mate.
Sergei Fedorov (28 points) - Nash line-mate.

2008-09: Rick Nash (79 points)
R.J. Umberger (56 points) - Nash line-mate.
Jakub Voracek (38 points) - Nash line-mate.

2009-10: Rick Nash (67 points)
Antoine Vermette (65 points) - Nash line-mate.
Jakub Voracek (50 points) - Nash line-mate.

2010-11: Rick Nash (66 points)
R.J Umberger (57 points) - Nash line-mate.
Jakub Voracek (46 points) - Nash line-mate.
 
I think it's pretty obvious Burke's vision on day 1, and his current vision are completely different.....he's clearly changed things up on the fly.
 
Columbus Blue Jackets Points Leaders

2002-03: Ray Whitney (76 points) - not a Nash line-mate.

2003-04: Rick Nash (57 points)
David Vyborny (53 points) - Nash line-mate.

2005-06: David Vyborny (65 points) - Nash line-mate.
Rick Nash (54 points)
Nikolai Zherdev (54 points) - not a Nash line-mate.

2006-07: David Vyborny (64 points) - Nash line-mate
Rick Nash (57 points)
Sergei Fedorov (42 points) - Nash line-mate.

2007-08: Rick Nash (69 points)
Nikolai Zherdev (61 points) - Nash line-mate.
Sergei Fedorov (28 points) - Nash line-mate.

2008-09: Rick Nash (79 points)
R.J. Umberger (56 points) - Nash line-mate.
Jakub Voracek (38 points) - Nash line-mate.

2009-10: Rick Nash (67 points)
Antoine Vermette (65 points) - Nash line-mate.
Jakub Voracek (50 points) - Nash line-mate.

2010-11: Rick Nash (66 points)
R.J Umberger (57 points) - Nash line-mate.
Jakub Voracek (46 points) - Nash line-mate.


Jesus. H. Christ.


That poor bastard.
 
Burke isn't trying to build a 2011-12 playoff team. He is trying to build a cup contender. Anyone who thinks the criteria for judging Burke's job is making the playoffs this year is missing the point.
 
I think it's pretty obvious Burke's vision on day 1, and his current vision are completely different.....he's clearly changed things up on the fly.

I don't think so. His plan changed in that he went from a top 6/bottom 6 to a top 9/bottom 3, but that is just adapting to the game. That isn't changing the plan. He doesn't have the big, tough team that he wanted, but thats because he has been working with what he has. IMO he still wants that kind of team. Its why he drafted a guy like Biggs and traded for Colborne. He's not done with this team.
 
He had to completely strip a club with an empty cupboard down and fill it back up again. In three years he's added Kessel, Lupul, Phaneuf, Gardiner and Colborne for some picks and a lot of nothing. He's stocked the prospect pool. He has built the youngest team in the NHL and they are currently in a playoff spot 2/3 of the way into the season.

There is no earth where Brian Burke isn't satisfying his standards.

His vision was to add talent, and build a team that is fast and skilled enough to beat a skilled team in the playoffs, big and tough enough to beat a big team, and good enough on the special teams to beat a team with good special teams. Is he done? Has he reached his perfect team? Of course not. But anyone expecting that process to be finished 3 years in is insane.

The Leafs haven't been on this good of an upward trend though since Quinn's early days.

Perfect team?? Burke has said that the team as it stands now needs only "tweaks". How accurate do you believe that statement to be?

Burke has said he wants a team that is big, tough and truculent. What do you think of the team's toughness?

Burke has said that it is his policy to build from the net out. How good would you say the goaltenders we have are?

It looks to me like the Earth we're on right now is one where Burke is falling far short of his standards on building a good team.

He better have a hell of a trade deadline, this team is fading fast.
 
Blame linemates all you want but I think Nash is very overrated and some team is going to pay a ridiculous premium on an average player. Kovalchuk had shitty linemates in Atlanta (he didn't always have Heatley or Hossa) and still racked up the goals and points. Sure he's tailed off but the fat remains, Nash is overrated.
 
Well its just semantics, but I really don't see that minor of an adjustment throwing off a guys whole vision.

His vision has always been to build from the net out, and add talent and "trucculence." He brought in the best goalie coach in the world, and signed every talented free agent goalie he could. Obviously this hasn't turned up the answer yet. Then he completely stocked the D. Phaneuf, Liles, Gardiner, Franson, Aulie, Komi were all brought in. Guys with trucculence. Guys with skill. Then up front he added guys like Kessel, Lupul, Mac, Bozak, Connolly. A bunch of highly skilled guys. And he got his pick and shovel men in Brown and Steckel.

IMO he is clearly following his plan. He's just not as far along as some people were expecting he would be by now, whether that is fair or not is another question.
 
Leafs are going to have to make some sort of a move. There are 5 teams within 6 points of them and 3 have a games in hand. One of those is Washington and they are only 1 point back. If the Leafs don't start stringing wins together they will get passed by sooner rather than later. I never expected your goalie situation to fall apart like that. Might have to go out and acquire a goalie.
 
Perfect team?? Burke has said that the team as it stands now needs only "tweaks". How accurate do you believe that statement to be?

Burke has said he wants a team that is big, tough and truculent. What do you think of the team's toughness?

Burke has said that it is his policy to build from the net out. How good would you say the goaltenders we have are?

It looks to me like the Earth we're on right now is one where Burke is falling far short of his standards on building a good team.

He better have a hell of a trade deadline, this team is fading fast.

You just have unrealistic expectations. That he would build the cup contender within 3 years. Thats nuts. This is the youngest team in the NHL. Yeah they need to add more. They also need time for the rookies to stop making rookie mistakes.

But to think that they aren't on the right track? An older team that was bottom of the barrel in the NHL, goes to a playoff team that is the youngest team in the NHL and you think the guy at the helm isn't doing his job? Geez.
 
Burke isn't trying to build a 2011-12 playoff team. He is trying to build a cup contender. Anyone who thinks the criteria for judging Burke's job is making the playoffs this year is missing the point.

Missing the playoffs in EVERY year since he was hired
 
Blame linemates all you want but I think Nash is very overrated and some team is going to pay a ridiculous premium on an average player. Kovalchuk had shitty linemates in Atlanta (he didn't always have Heatley or Hossa) and still racked up the goals and points. Sure he's tailed off but the fat remains, Nash is overrated.

Kovalchuk played with Savard, Heatley, Hossa, Kozlov.......those are some pretty damn good linemates.

Especially when compared to the likes of Vermette, Vyborny, Umberger, etc.
 
Missing the playoffs in EVERY year since he was hired

He had to rebuild. Sure he wanted to make the playoffs. But that wasn't the primary objective. If it was he'd have been trading away all the young guys for vets. But thats not the vision. He's trying to build a team that can win a cup.
 
Funny, I thought he has said (many times) that his goal is to make the playoffs, which would be falling short of his standards.
 
Sure. But he also said many times "I could have traded Luke Schenn to make the playoffs, but I don't want to jsut make the playoffs to get my butt kicked in the first round."

"His standards" were never just make the playoffs. They were always to build a team that can win a cup.

If his standards were just to make the playoffs do you really think he would have traded away Versteeg, Kaberle and Beach last year? That was never the primary goal.
 
Back
Top