• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

i agree its not easy getting a no.1 C, but if you're gonna blow your wad on acquiring someone, i don't think doing it on ANOTHER scoring winger is the way to go. you guys already blew a wad on a no.1 scoring winger and how is that working out for you?

That's working out great for us, Kessel is a ****ing beast

dumping another no.1 pick (do you even HAVE one this year?), another couple of good prospects, and a good roster player for another no.1 winger seems to me to be a dumb move.

Yes, we have a 1st round pick this year (and we had 2 last year).

The point to all of this is, you don't stop acquiring talent just because it's not the immediate hole you have to fill. Especially when it's a player who is likely to be around for the next 7+ years. Again, we could quite easily go out and get a player like Stastny this summer after a Nash trade. Making the one move doesn't negate the possibility of the other.
 
The point to all of this is, you don't stop acquiring talent just because it's not the immediate hole you have to fill. Especially when it's a player who is likely to be around for the next 7+ years.

This.


How people can't grasp this concept, is beyond me.
 
I don't disagree with this, i disagree withhow elite a talent Nash is.

The argument has gone on at length about it, but I think the best way to sum him up is that he's a legit top 5-10 goal scoring winger with some effort based holes in his game.

There's really nothing that he can't do well out there. It can be argued that he's lazy, it can also be argued that playing in Columbus is slowly sapping his will to live. He should definitely be judged, and valued on his track record. He's clearly incredibly talented and incredibly enigmatic. You can't sell the ****ing farm based on the talent, nor should you entirely turn up your nose at the idea due to him being an enigma.
 
The argument has gone on at length about it, but I think the best way to sum him up is that he's a legit top 5-10 goal scoring winger with some effort based holes in his game.

There's really nothing that he can't do well out there. It can be argued that he's lazy, it can also be argued that playing in Columbus is slowly sapping his will to live. He should definitely be judged, and valued on his track record. He's clearly incredibly talented and incredibly enigmatic. You can't sell the ****ing farm based on the talent, nor should you entirely turn up your nose at the idea due to him being an enigma.

This is fair...but i also question the fit in toronto with no real center for him....unless you split up lupul and kessel.
 
what a bunch of hockey hipsters... it has somehow become the cool thing to bash nash and say how overrated he is... its getting ridiculous now as if he somehow isn't even a very good player anymore. but yeah lets just pass and wait for the summer and sign a number one centre then. that strategy has worked out great for us so far...

you assemble as much high end talent as you can and you sort out positional needs later
 
You can slot Nash into Lupul's spot or you can slot him in MacA's spot. You could also play him with Lupul and have Kessel play with Kulemin.
 
The argument has gone on at length about it, but I think the best way to sum him up is that he's a legit top 5-10 goal scoring winger with some effort based holes in his game.

There's really nothing that he can't do well out there. It can be argued that he's lazy, it can also be argued that playing in Columbus is slowly sapping his will to live. He should definitely be judged, and valued on his track record. He's clearly incredibly talented and incredibly enigmatic. You can't sell the ****ing farm based on the talent, nor should you entirely turn up your nose at the idea due to him being an enigma.

This about sums it up.
 
I was not overly impressed with Kessel last year, but haven't said anything bad about him this year, because obviously he's been playing great all season long. He is a speedy sniper with a lot of talent but there are certain things he can't do that Nash can. We also have to keep in mind that Lupul, while playing ****ing great this year, has a long history of injuries and underachievement. What if Lupul's play drops next year, or he suffers a significant injury?

I'd feel a whole lot better going into next season with these 2 guys and Nash, rather than just these 2 guys.
 
what a bunch of hockey hipsters... it has somehow become the cool thing to bash nash and say how overrated he is... its getting ridiculous now as if he somehow isn't even a very good player anymore. but yeah lets just pass and wait for the summer and sign a number one centre then. that strategy has worked out great for us so far...

you assemble as much high end talent as you can and you sort out positional needs later

Well, we'd only be hockey hipsters if we claimed to dislike Nash before it was cool. But honestly, what exactly is wrong with not wanting to surrender a massively valuable trade package in exchange for a career 65 point player that's poor defensively and makes $7.8M per season? If you want to believe that in spite of that, Nash would be worth the money and the trade assets, or that after 9 years in the NHL he'll blossom into a PPG+ player in Toronto, that's fine. I just happen to disagree.
 
Lets say Nash is Lunchables Mini Pizza...I want the lunchables because according to others they're awesome. But I'm not going to go and buy the cheesy bread from the school cafeteria to trade it for the lunchables. I'll trade what I've got, but not an exorbitant amount. Let some other kid waste money and assets.
 
Well, we'd only be hockey hipsters if we claimed to dislike Nash before it was cool. But honestly, what exactly is wrong with not wanting to surrender a massively valuable trade package in exchange for a career 65 point player that's poor defensively and makes $7.8M per season? If you want to believe that in spite of that, Nash would be worth the money and the trade assets, or that after 9 years in the NHL he'll blossom into a PPG+ player in Toronto, that's fine. I just happen to disagree.
My thoughts as well.
 
Lets say Nash is Lunchables Mini Pizza...I want the lunchables because according to others they're awesome. But I'm not going to go and buy the cheesy bread from the school cafeteria to trade it for the lunchables. I'll trade what I've got, but not an exorbitant amount. Let some other kid waste money and assets.

Somehow i understood that...and appreciated it

Lunchables is in theory awesome...then you eat it...and realize its garbage.

Just like Dunkaroos.
 
This is fair...but i also question the fit in toronto with no real center for him....unless you split up lupul and kessel.

We don't have a lack of centres at all though. Just a lack of #1 centres. Nash would have either Connolly or Grabovski to play with...which is as good or better than anything he's ever had in Columbus.
 
You can slot Nash into Lupul's spot or you can slot him in MacA's spot. You could also play him with Lupul and have Kessel play with Kulemin.


I think the point would be to keep Kessel & Nash on seperate lines. Especially considering the fact that Lupul & Kessel work so well together. Then Nash slots into Kulemin's position on the Grabovski line to start (assuming Kulemin isn't part of the deal), and Kulemin goes down to the 3rd line with Connolly and whoever.
 
Agreed, but in absence of one of those, getting our hands on an excellent puck possession winger would be a step in the right direction of balancing our forward lines better.

It's not like we're choosing Nash over Getzlaf or Staal....we'd be choosing Nash over...nobody. Stastny is simply the best centreman likely available right now and he doesn't exactly fit the mold you're describing either. Though adding Nash wouldn't preclude us from getting Stastny this summer either. Colorado simply can't be happy paying him to score 50-55 points the last 2 years. We can better financially afford to bank on a Phaneuf like ressurection.

well, adding a $7.8mn forward might preclude you from adding the $6.6mn stastny...

in a acpped environment you have to be more calculated and imo nash isn't the guy to make your move on. this team has too many moves to make to get to where they need to be to be adding that sort of piece.
 
This.


How people can't grasp this concept, is beyond me.

i don't think anybody isn't grasping this.

the problem is that the move really limits what else they'll be able to do to improve, and how much nash would improve this team is very open to debate.

fact is, with their current goaltending and bozak centering their first line they would still have the same two big problems they have right now.

trading 4 pieces for nash and having him tie up 12-13% of the cap makes it a lot more difficult to address those needs.
 
Nick Kypreos
#SNtrade. Going into Sunday nite, its sounding like #Rangers have backed out on the Nash sweepstakes. #Bluejackets demands remain too rich.
 
Ok, We know Nash is available but what about Dustin Brown? He is the same age and MUCH cheaper contract. I would be willing to throw assets to L.A for Brown. What do you think would get it down?

Something like Kulumen/Mac, a 1st, 2nd/dec prospect?
 
Back
Top