• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Didn't Burke say he wouldn't GIVE OUT those cap circumventing contracts?

I can see him taking on one though if it improves his team.
 
do you think new MLSE ownership would say to Burke.... "Get Luongo". I know he said he has autonomy, but you gotta think the new owners would want to go into next year with something big to promote.
 
Burke has gone on record that he will not take on contracts that circumvent the cap. Luongo's contract does just that for the next 10 years. So unless Burke is a liar........

I would like YOU to demonstrate how Luongo would make the Leafs a Stanley Cup champion as you cited in you Rangers example......

THAT would be facinating, and fanciful at best.

Who said anything about making them a Stanley Cup champion?

At the very list acquiring him would eliminate the most pressing need at the most important position for the Leafs moving forward. He would provide a legitimate stepping stone to eventual greatness.

You're talking about potentially acquiring a consistently elite to minimum very good to borderline elite goaltender with a history of workhorse consistency and high-end performance. A player who has been a champion multiple times as the man between the pipes for the world's most dominant national team and someone that can be relied upon to play key minutes. For all the discussion about him "choking" supposedly in the Finals last year I don't know of two many goaltenders historically who ended up contributing two 1-0 shutouts in the same Finals series and ended up on the losing side.
 
Are you suggesting that The current Leafs are as good as either the Rangers or the other example Dallas were? Both those examples are rediculous. The Leafs are a lottery team. Adding Luongo will not make them a Stanley Cup winning team.

And, if Luongo is media feeling pressure in BC, he will get killed in Tornoto by the media.

If he is going anywhere it is Florida. He has family there and his NTC gives him the right to call shots.

Vancouver is a traditional goaltender's wasteland. Toronto by comparison has a well-known, long-standing reputation for venerating goaltenders and taking seasons to turn on them. Are you seriously comparing the two?

I also suggest that you read back through the rest of the thread because all that you have brought up has already been address beforehand. The fact of the matter is that adding a goaltender of Roberto Luongo's calibre makes the Toronto Maple Leafs better in the immediate present, mid-term, and potentially even long-term.
 
Who said anything about making them a Stanley Cup champion?

At the very list acquiring him would eliminate the most pressing need at the most important position for the Leafs moving forward. He would provide a legitimate stepping stone to eventual greatness.

You're talking about potentially acquiring a consistently elite to minimum very good to borderline elite goaltender with a history of workhorse consistency and high-end performance. A player who has been a champion multiple times as the man between the pipes for the world's most dominant national team and someone that can be relied upon to play key minutes. For all the discussion about him "choking" supposedly in the Finals last year I don't know of two many goaltenders historically who ended up contributing two 1-0 shutouts in the same Finals series and ended up on the losing side.

YOU DID..

Mike Richter couldn't win with the President Trophy winning Rangers, there is no way he could win in the same city two years later.
 
And good grief, why are people even discussing Florida as a potential destination for any long-term goaltenders? They have the best goaltending prospect in the world. This guy:

markstrom.jpg


jacob_markstrom_fla.jpg


scaled.php
 
I have to laugh when people suggest GM-a wont deal with GM-b because they dont like it each. Its a business, and if a good business deal is presented they will make one.
 
Vancouver is a traditional goaltender's wasteland. Toronto by comparison has a well-known, long-standing reputation for venerating goaltenders and taking seasons to turn on them. Are you seriously comparing the two?

I also suggest that you read back through the rest of the thread because all that you have brought up has already been address beforehand. The fact of the matter is that adding a goaltender of Roberto Luongo's calibre makes the Toronto Maple Leafs better in the immediate present, mid-term, and potentially even long-term.

Better yes. But playoff fodder with Luongo in net. For example, the 4 games in the final that he LOST against Boston last year. You might remember Boston as the team that Burke help turn into a Stanley Cup champion as his own team continued to miss the playoffs. You know, the team that beat the crap out of Toronto 6 times this past year.
 
Better yes. But playoff fodder with Luongo in net. For example, the 4 games in the final that he LOST against Boston last year. You might remember Boston as the team that Burke help turn into a Stanley Cup champion as his own team continued to miss the playoffs. You know, the team that beat the crap out of Toronto 6 times this past year.

You have no reasonable means of ascertaining whether this is true or not. Your whole argument amounts to a hopeless, unhelpful "why bother improving, we'll never win" defeatist attitude.

Acquiring an elite goaltender would, without question, be a major component of making the Toronto Maple Leafs Hockey Club a Stanley Cup champion. They have an opportunity to acquire the perfect one at substantially reduced cost due to circumstances beyond that player's control. If they do not take advantage of that chance it could be years before another opportunity arises, if then.
 
You have no reasonable means of ascertaining whether this is true or not. Your whole argument amounts to a hopeless, unhelpful "why bother improving, we'll never win" defeatist attitude.

I will make it easier for you to understand. What I am saying is...the solution is an upgrade in goaltending...yes.
Is Luongo that solution....no.
 
Has no one mentioned yet that Burke never had a problem trading for a cap-circumventing contract, just signing a player to one.

In his view, if the NHL accepts a contract, it doesn't circumvent. Even though if he signed a player to one and the NHL accepted it, that'd be a no-no.

Makes no sense, but I've heard him offer that justification before.
 
Yes and? My point remains the same. Just because a goaltender hasn't won with a specific team before does not preclude them from winning later. Tim Thomas played four NCAA seasons, six AHL/ECHL/IHL seasons, 2 Finnish league seasons, and 1 Swedish league season before he even became an NHL regular. He still has a championship ring, even after being a part of the 2010 Bruins that blew a 3-0 Eastern Semi-Finals series lead.
 
Better yes. But playoff fodder with Luongo in net. For example, the 4 games in the final that he LOST against Boston last year. You might remember Boston as the team that Burke help turn into a Stanley Cup champion as his own team continued to miss the playoffs. You know, the team that beat the crap out of Toronto 6 times this past year.

He did?
 
Has no one mentioned yet that Burke never had a problem trading for a cap-circumventing contract, just signing a player to one.

In his view, if the NHL accepts a contract, it doesn't circumvent. Even though if he signed a player to one and the NHL accepted it, that'd be a no-no.

Makes no sense, but I've heard him offer that justification before.

Scroll up. It's been mentioned several times. You are correct though, he has mentioned that seemingly hypocritical stance in the past.
 
Back
Top