• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Carlyle has shown that he is a three line man... and that third line gets plenty of ice time. I want it to be a checking line, but I would love it to be one that can still pop in some goals. Steckel on that line kills all offense. Bozak could keep that going, but I would like some big wingers for him.

Another reason why Anaheim completely lost it for him at a certain point. They might rebound next year, but he drove them into the ground. We shoulda kept Wilson till we got a goalie. At least he was entertaining.
 
Another reason why Anaheim completely lost it for him at a certain point. They might rebound next year, but he drove them into the ground. We shoulda kept Wilson till we got a goalie. At least he was entertaining.

Carlyle does have a "drill sargent" mentality when it comes to coaching and while that lessens his shelf life, it also produces winning results as well. Carlyle brings much needed structure to this leafs team, he has a defense first mentality and lets face it with at best average goaltending we badly need this type of system if the leafs are not just to make the playoffs but make some noise as well. Wilson likes to play a "run and gun" style which has lost its' expiry date a long time ago, if you watch the teams in the playoffs you will see the common dominator is a team first system(s) with emphasis on strong goaltending and defense. I'm not saying Wilson didn't have his strengths as a coach (ie being able to balance his lines equally, and having a knack for knowing who is playing well and who isn't) it's just his style is no longer effective in todays' NHL.
 
Its all cyclical. Detroit won pretty, as Federer is doing in tennis. But once in a while you get thug cycles where teams win ugly. We had Boston, this year we have New York, which is so ugly, it is making New Jersey appear to be the Detroit of this years playoffs, along with Washington.

If we had New Yorks team AND success, would I be cheering for it? Yes. But is it goddamn fawkin ugly? Yes it is. I mean they obstruct and bludgeon like no one I have seen in years.

And Carlyle? With the right components. Would be guilty of the same. But how he is going to do it with Colbornes, Bozaks, Kessels and such? Your guess.
 
And Carlyle? With the right components. Would be guilty of the same. But how he is going to do it with Colbornes, Bozaks, Kessels and such? Your guess.

- Every team needs skilled players to win, even the Rangers have guys like Richards/Gaborik (similar style player to Kessel IMO), but you also need guys who are willing to put in the effort and selfless enough to put their ego at the door. Colborne IMO is a hit or miss type player, the jury is still out on him, and Bozak a decision will have to be made on him. What the leafs really need to play Carlyle type of hockey is big rugged wingers who aren't allergic to playing physical and who are also strong along the boards so they can play the chip/chase gamer as well as work the cycle. Right now we have skill (Kessel, Lupul, Phaneuf, Grabo, Gardiner, Kulemin) but we lack the guys with heart/size/physicality and these players are going to have to be acquired via free agency (guys like Moen, Prust etc), through trade (ie Jordan Staal or even Rick Nash) as well as through the draft.
 
Carlyle is not a good fit with this team. Don't see it. Unless Burke has a trading partner for 88% of the team.
 
Carlyle is not a good fit with this team. Don't see it. Unless Burke has a trading partner for 88% of the team.

And who would u see as the perfect fit then? It's clear as day run n gun style isn't working and it hasn't been effective in over 7 years, guys like Wilson/Boudreau (just an example) would be miserable misfits here. This is a team badly lacking structure and Carlyle brings that in spades, as well as a defense first system which we haven't seen since the Pat Burns days in the early 90's.

I agree there are going to have to be players that need to go for this to work, guys like Lambo and Connoly just won't excel in a work your tail off defensively structured system, and of course there are going to be "Burke" players brought in during the offseaon. I strongly believe the leafs teams since 07' have been built to suit Ron Wilson's uptempo high risk/reward system, even Burke admitted to not being on the same page as his good buddy, now that he has Caryle he is going to bring in players suited for a structured team first orientented style of play.

Also it's not fair to judge Carlyle based on a dozen games, he came took over during argubaly the leafs worst possible slumps, there was no way for him to come in, mold this team to his liking and get said team into playoffs. The 12-15 games he was behind the bench was merely an evaluation to see which players have what iti takes to stick and which players need to be show the door, I'm sure him and Burke have been communciating back and forth about this, now Burke knows what he has to do to right the ship.

This season will be a fair chance to judge Carlyle because he'll have "his team" in place, if the end result is as bad or close to it as last year then by all means call him out, but right now he deserved a chance to work with this team.
 
Carlyle is not a good fit with this team. Don't see it. Unless Burke has a trading partner for 88% of the team.

carlyle isn't a trap coach, and that he relies on his top three lines is a GOOD thing, not a bad thing.

the concern i have is that i'm not sure he has the right demeanour for this team's make up.
 
carlyle isn't a trap coach, and that he relies on his top three lines is a GOOD thing, not a bad thing.

the concern i have is that i'm not sure he has the right demeanour for this team's make up.

He's a demanding coach who will expect the most out of his players, I don't see anything wrong with it and if the players have an issue with it then they need to be shown the door.
 
Bowman was a demanding coach too and every one of his players hated his guts ... some even after he led them to win the cup.
 
Please don't put Scotty Bowman in the same category as swimmy(Randy Carlyle) a weird, bizarre guy who has ALREADY lost this team, and who has already threatened to quit himself in the short time he has been here. Unbeknownst to all here. What kind of a weirdo would walk from a lucrative multiyear contract?
 
Would absolutely love to get McClement to take over the third-line centre role. He's got good size and was one of the best defensive centres in the league in St. Louis. Hell, he was a beast in that regard in junior too.

Precisely.

There isn't a better fit out there on the market for our third line center role.....he'll be cheap, and is the perfect shutdown guy for a Carlyle third line.
 
The Toronto Maple Leafs may make a strong push to land Columbus Blue Jackets star Rick Nash, and they may be able to put in a stronger offer than at the past trade deadline. The Toronto Star's Damien Cox writes, "The playoff run of the AHL Marlies suggests this is a team that may indeed have more young assets than they have been given credit for, assets they hope might help land Nash."

While some may think the Leafs are eyeing free agent Zach Parise, Cox writes that GM Brian Burke prefers Nash: "The Leafs prefer Nash's size, particularly with the more lenient way in which NHL rules have been administered down the stretch and in the post-season."

Among the strongest suitors for Nash will likely be the San Jose Sharks, who has a disappointing exit in the first round of the playoffs, so the Leafs will have to outbid them.


Nash makes sense on a number of levels.
 
Burke is just going to blow up this franchise even more doing that. I have one strong suggestion for him. Get a fawking goaltender. Nash, please, what does this team with no goaltender need Nash for?
 
Back
Top