• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Yeah, Thomas is great, but he is 40 and retired and counting $5 mill against the cap to not play. I'm not giving that guy more years to count against the cap to not play.
 
Until he magically went back to his regular self in the playoffs.

Just a fluke I guess.

And he still posted a 920 SV% reg season.

Luongo is so overrated on this board, it's getting ridiculous.

he really isn't.

most people see him for what he is.. a guy who has consistently been a top five goaltender since before the lockout.

you can call it overrated if you'd like, but the stat you love pointing to only proves the point.
 
Luongo is adequately rated. Not one person said Lunogo was better than 2 years ago, .930+ Tim Thomas.

This year there is no denying they were equals though.
 
Thomas has been the best (or at least a top 2 goalie) over the last couple years, and not just in the reg season, but in the playoffs as well.

He's better than Luongo right now.

he's 38 years old and has decided to hamstring his team by not playing this season, knowing full well that his contract still counts against the cap.

i don't care if he is better -- and his second half performance, frankly, makes that a very suspect argument -- the guy is an enormous risk because of his apparent willingness to not honour his contract and play.

not to mention the fact that he's 38 years old and was awful in the second half this season.
 
Until he magically went back to his regular self in the playoffs.

Just a fluke I guess.

And he still posted a 920 SV% reg season.

Luongo is so overrated on this board, it's getting ridiculous.

Luongo is actually perfectly rated on this board. It's off the forum he's hilarious underrated by virtually everyone.
 
Thomas has been the best (or at least a top 2 goalie) over the last couple years, and not just in the reg season, but in the playoffs as well.

He's better than Luongo right now.

So...what you're saying is that you've abandoned attempting to argue that a small sample size is meaningful.

Good idea.

and yes...Thomas was great until the 2nd half of this season, where he was terrible. At his age, the line between "slump" and "decline" is thin.
 
Just a quick note...

Remember the utter collapse we witnessed in Toronto last year? The collapse that goaltending was a big part of?

Post All Star Break SV%

Reimer - .902
Thomas - .903

We call this a "red flag"
 
he really isn't.

most people see him for what he is.. a guy who has consistently been a top five goaltender since before the lockout.

you can call it overrated if you'd like, but the stat you love pointing to only proves the point.


This.
 
So...what you're saying is that you've abandoned attempting to argue that a small sample size is meaningful.

Good idea.

and yes...Thomas was great until the 2nd half of this season, where he was terrible. At his age, the line between "slump" and "decline" is thin.

You don't need to argue with a small sample size regarding Thomas.

He posted one of the best seasons ever by a goalie two years ago.

He posted 920+ in both the reg season and playoffs this past season.

He's better than Luongo based on the above.
 
Back
Top