The thing about Gillis is that he just doesn't want to look bad, but he literally is stuck between a rock and a hard place, and he has to. He though sees what Carolina did and wants Burke to give up fair value for Luongo.
Pitt knew they had to deal with Carolina, and Rutherford the idiot, gave up a decent package as a favour to Shero, he probably could have low balled, but I am sure Staal had let it be known that he would go to Carolina next year regardless of where he was traded to. Gilis wants Burke to pull a rutherford, and Burke won't