It's not a question of filling or not filling those roles, it's a question of which roles you prioritize as a GM.
Do you really think there's anyone here who wouldn't want to see the Leafs have a perfect third line of grit, toughness, defensive ability, and a decent amount of offensive ability as well? A bottom pair of big bruising defensemen who are rock solid defensively and can move the puck a bit? of course we all do. That would be awesome.
that was never the question.
the question is how you allocate your limited resources in the most effective way. the question is one of identifying which talents you have to pay big money for, and which talents are more easily replaceable. the question is which roles you feel are most crucial and necessary to prioritize.
If guys like Armstrong and Komisarek for example had played the way Burke envisioned(and in no way am I arguing with you on those signings, I hated them from the getgo as you know) then the importance of what they were supposed to bring to the table would be much more apparent. Not sure if you watched the Leafs lose a billion battles along the boards on all 3 zones this past season, but I sure did.
The roles of inflicting punishment on the opposition and stopping them from scoring are important ones. In a game, in a season, in a playoff run. We're very weak in those areas and even 2 or 3 truly successful fits there would have made a good difference. But instead of getting useful parts strong in toughness leadership and defence, he got Colton Orr, Mike Komisarek and Colby Armstrong. In my mind that doesn't invalidate the plan, just the execution.
In terms of identifying which talents you pay big money for, well, those tend to be big talents as well. If you're arguing that Zach Parise or Ryan Suter or Brad Richards or whoever would be a better use of cash than Komisarek and Armstrong, well of course they would. Who has been a louder advocate of this team not acquiring enough top talent than me? Those needs are not mutually exclusive though, you can have both and the reason we don't is because a) Leaf ownership doesn't want to pay top money for any player, as they don't need that to get into the playoffs or fill the building and b) because a lot of the guys Burke has brought in haven't worked out or produced in the roles they were to fill.
Anyway, I think McClement is more of a "superelite 4th liner" so to speak. I'm not necessarily that happy with him being the 3C either, but let's see what else shakes down...I don't think he's inked in there quite yet. That aside, I don't get what else you'd be unhappy about, the Leafs are paying an appropriate price and term for this player. And he will help us, again, in areas of the game our team is very weak in. All that remains is whether they're going to overplay him like they did Steckel towards the end of the season.