• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

Hiller might become available as well.

There are always guys that come available.

jimmy-stewart4.jpg
 
Could easily be Raycroft 2.0. Bobrovski looks eerily similar on paper ... high save p in rookie year, not so much second year. I don't think the Leafs should touch anyone like that given recent history. Potentially high reward but the Leafs have to be done taking that kind of risk with goalies at this stage. If they're going to trade assets to get a goalie they need a more established guy.
 
Bobrovski doesnt really represent enough an upgrade for Toronto or Chicago to give up real assets for IMO, and isnt young enough liek a Bernier to be considered high ceiling
 
I like Frattin but he is easily replaced by Ross (maybe not right away but hopefully by the end of the season) so it would not be that big of a loss
 
I don't see a huge difference between Brobovski and Bernier.

In fact, Brobovski at least established himself as a successful #1 for a short period in this league, Bernier never did. I see a lot of Toskala in Bernier - smallish goalie who played for a good team as a backup, unproven, overrated.

I really, really hope Bernier is just a smokescreen for Burke to bargain with Gilles on Luongo.
 
Chicago would have won the CUP with Quick perhaps.

Not really teeds. Most people don't realize but after Chicago won the Stanley Cup and got rid of some key pieces in Byfuglien, Ladd, Niemi and so on, they didn't get that their style of play wasn't going to work going forward. Imagine a Leafs team with better goaltending but still weak/small players up front...We'd be better for sure but would still never have a shot vs teams like Philly, Boston, Vancouver and so on. The reason they were able to play more attacking is because of puck possession play of some of the bigger guys like Byfuglien and their overall depth. All that and throw in solid goaltending made them tough to beat no matter what style they played. Now, they think they can do the same with weaker goaltending (although still not bad imo) and more importantly without big pieces missing.
 
Not really teeds. Most people don't realize but after Chicago won the Stanley Cup and got rid of some key pieces in Byfuglien, Ladd, Niemi and so on, they didn't get that their style of play wasn't going to work going forward. Imagine a Leafs team with better goaltending but still weak/small players up front...We'd be better for sure but would still never have a shot vs teams like Philly, Boston, Vancouver and so on. The reason they were able to play more attacking is because of puck possession play of some of the bigger guys like Byfuglien and their overall depth. All that and throw in solid goaltending made them tough to beat no matter what style they played. Now, they think they can do the same with weaker goaltending (although still not bad imo) and more importantly without big pieces missing.

Thing is, that was a very, very good team that won with mediocre goaltending. Even losing that awesome depth they had, if they have elite goaltending, they're clearly a contender.
 
Why do I feel that Burke is going to throw a first rounder at a goalie, in desperation? I don't think L.A. is going to trade Bernier for a guy who is a third liner and just finished trashing his knee and a third rounder.
 
I'm not on board with giving up anything of value (and Frattin is of value) to get an unproven goalie.

Been there, done that, with spectacularly disastrous results.

If we're going with unproven goalies, let's go with our own.
 
The problem with Raycroft & Toskala was that they were shit, not that they were unproven. They were proven shit before we traded for them.
 
Raycroft had an .879 save percentage the year before. Toskala's was ten points below league average on a powerhouse team.

They were both shit.
 
You know who was unproven....Tuukka f*cking Rask.


The idea that there's some sort of correlation between how Raycroft and Toskala produced and how another goalie coming in would, simply because he isn't an established starter, is patently absurd.

At the very worst Bernier doubles our chances of having a quality starting goaltender for the foreseable future.
 
27. Have to believe that, yes, Toronto's inquired about Jonathan Bernier. Brian Burke isn't doing his job if he doesn't. But there are doubts Burke is incredibly serious about him. Was he serious about Martin Brodeur? Yes. Is he more serious than he lets on about Luongo? Yes. Bernier doesn't really fit Toronto's stated criteria of a veteran in goal.

- Elliotte Friedman
 
Back
Top