• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

I remember when Dryden went out and signed Joseph when we already had Potvan between the pipes. You can never have enough good goaltending as we should know after watching the Leafs the past 6 years. In that case it allowed the Leafs to trade Potvan for Bryan Berard.

If we have to trade Reimer then so be it. That would allow us to fill in other spots that need help.

Burke should be all over signing Bryz.

I love Reimer, who doesn't but I am not willing to bet it all on him yet. He is only 22 after all. If he was to back up Bryz for a couple of seasons it might not be the worst thing in the world. After the terrible luck we have had with the goaltending position since the lockout...Stock up I say.
 
Last edited:
Exactly.

If Reimer is good enough to push Bryz off the #1 position next season, well, great! Now we can trade either and net a good return.

Potvin brought us Berard (I know, I know ... mad Mike ... stilll ... )
 
We can survive without a legit #1 center. We can survive without a legit #1 defenseman but we simply cannot survive without a #1 goalie. It absolutely has to be the top priority this summer. I don't care how good you think Reimer is, he can survive being backup or even 1b goalie here. It's just way to risky to go into next season with a Reim-Gus Combo. Sign a #1 and let Reims and Gus battle it out in training camp.
 
Keep making the same mistakes. good idea.

Like so many of the other top teams in the league, we have the very realistic chance of getting topnotch goaltending for peanuts next year. Spending money on goaltending is a fool's game. There's a million good goalies out there - locking yourself into one is a bad idea.

We have four young very talented goalies with great track records. One of whom is outright dominating the NHL right now. Blocking that talent with a superexpensive goalie would be ridiculous.

Young goalie talent is the strongest part of our roster and system right now - it is the absolute last place we need to be spending money. We don't have enough top talent forwards in the system, we don't have enough top talent dmen in the system, but we have more top young goalie talent than most any other team in hockey.

Let's use that to our advantage, and use the money to fill the gaps where we DON"T have the budding talent ready to contribute.
 
Right.. and there's no such thing as a sophomore slump.. Let's throw all our eggs in Reimer's basket and pray he plays the same for an entire NHL schedule with no backup plan in case he falters/gets injured. Great Idea.
 
they owe komisarek $13mn alone.

they're paying finger $7mn not to play for the team

lebda would be $2.5mn.

$6mn for giguere.

there's just no way mlse has $30mn in contracts on the marlies.

so then just start with Giguere.
 
Zeke will argue that we would be just fine picking up 2 kids putting up .950 save percentages in beer leagues. The reality of the situation, however, is not that simple. It's going to be tough for Burke to resist bringing in a vet next year.

and axl will need to needlessly exaggerate what Zeke would argue just to barely make a point.


While Zeke will argue that having four young and very talented goalies who have put up elite numbers in the best leagues in the world, including one who's doing it in the very best league in the world, is not a situation where a team should be looking to go out and sign an expensive goalie.
 
Just a joke, Zeke. It's a legit question. We have already learned that Gustavsson is not very good. Can he turn it around? Sure, but if he doesn't, and Reimer struggles, you're banking on 2 kids with very little pro experience. If we get subpar goaltending again next year, we will struggle to make the playoffs. Again.

I'm not saying that we must sign one of the big-ticket guys, but if we don't it's very risky. Do we really want to go through that again and waste another year?
 
we won't be making the 'same mistake'.

The mistake we (well, JFJ and then Burke) made was they spent big $$ on goalies who's the farthest from a sure thing.

JFJ traded Rask for Raycroft, gambling the 26 year old Raycroft could rebound from a poor sophomore season into Calder form. That never happened. Worse, he gave him a big contract before Raycroft even proved anything, and eventually we had to buy him out. This trade basically killed JFJ's career as a GM.

Next thing JFJ did, to 'fix' the problem with Raycroft, he signed Toskala to a big contract. Toskala was a career backup but momentarily stole the #1 job from Nabokov when he had a hot run, and JFJ gambled the hot run was the "real" toskala, and that the backup would have no problem maintaining those good numbers when he takes on a full time load. Of course we all know how that panned out.

Then came Burke. I can't call it a bad trade, because he DID rid Blake and Toskala's contract. However, when he anointed Giguere and Gustavsson as the tandem for the 10/11 season, he was again counting on Giguere rebounding from what was then 2 year of subpar goaltending. He was hoping that reuniting him with Allaire would rebound Giguere's career. He was also hoping Gustavsson could improve on his inconsistent rookie season. Neither happened, and Burke lost both gambles.

All 3 decisions are gambles. Signing a Vokoun or Bryzgalov won't be any gamble. You can't even compare these moves.
 
With a Bryz/Reimer combo the Leafs just aren't a playoff team, they are competing for home ice.

And with all their cap space they could afford to sign Richards ($7-$8 million), Bryz ($3-$4 million) and still have $3-$5 million to spend on a defenseman. They have a **** load of cap space. And I truly do not believe cap space can ever be wasted on elite players.

Lupul-Richards-Kessel
Mac-Grabo-Kuli
Kadri-Bozak-Armstrong
Boyce-Brent-Brown

McCabe-Schenn
Phaneuf-Aulie
Gadiner/Blacker-Komi
Gunnar

Bryzgalov
Reimer

Thats a contender. And if you really want more cap space, you'd still be wasting $4.5 million on Komi that I'd have no problem waiving.

Like i said, its not a necessity, but it would certainly be a luxury.
 
Top-10 Teams:

1) VAN: $6.3m goalie caphit
2) PHI: $2.7m
3) DET: $2.1m
4) TBL: $4.7m*(actually less because only part of Roly's contract counts)
5) BOS: $6.3m
6) PIT: $5.6
7) SJS: $4.0m (2 $2m goalies)
8) WAS: $1.6m
9) LAK: $2.6m
10) CHI: $2.1m

Exactly three of the top 10 teams have an expensive goalie in the fold.

In all three cases you could argue that those 3 teams would be better off spenidng that money elsewhere and going with other options, except for Boston this year because Thomas is putting in the best goalie season in history - if it was a typical Thomas year, though, they'd likely be better off going with Rask and spending the money elswhere.

Even if we DIDN'T have four great young goalie talents in the fold, it would still be a very questionable decision to get a big ticket goalie signed.....but when we have the depth of young talent that we have there, I think it's crazy to even think about it.
 
JFJ's problem was that he traded for those guys, so the pressure was that much greater for them to perform.

Signing a goalie isn't a problem IMO, even if it means sharing the net with Reimer. I agree that you cannot have "too much" goaltending.
 
With a Bryz/Reimer combo the Leafs just aren't a playoff team, they are competing for home ice.

And with all their cap space they could afford to sign Richards ($7-$8 million), Bryz ($3-$4 million) and still have $3-$5 million to spend on a defenseman. They have a **** load of cap space. And I truly do not believe cap space can ever be wasted on elite players.

Lupul-Richards-Kessel
Mac-Grabo-Kuli
Kadri-Bozak-Armstrong
Boyce-Brent-Brown

McCabe-Schenn
Phaneuf-Aulie
Gadiner/Blacker-Komi
Gunnar

Bryzgalov
Reimer

Thats a contender. And if you really want more cap space, you'd still be wasting $4.5 million on Komi that I'd have no problem waiving.

Like i said, its not a necessity, but it would certainly be a luxury.




I like McCabe, but if we're going to sign an offensive defenseman he needs to be a smart, calm puck mover. Signing McCabe would be a lot like adding an older, less mobile Phaneuf that fans already booed.
 
@zeke - teams can get away with cheap/mediocre goaltending only if they have incredible forward depth.
 
Haaaaa? You know, it kills me to see people who STILL don't understand that goaltending is 80% of the game. STILL. Our horrible team here in Toronto, looks like a team now that Reimer is here. IMAGINE if we had him and Bryzgalov. Imagine. Imagine if CHICAGO had someone who could stop a puck. Imagine.

Crawford is putting up a 923 sv% and 2.13 G.AA you twit
 
Back
Top