• Moderators, please send me a PM if you are unable to access mod permissions. Thanks, Habsy.

Leaf Rumours

yes, i am a leafs fan. and as a leafs fan know that the leafs did not play clark on that line with regularity (except on special teams).

he was on the 2nd line with anderson and then gartner.

borschevsky played on the top line. when he was hurt i'm sure clark spent some time there. so did rob pearson.

clark was not a regular member of the leafs top line in 93-94.

As a matter of fact he was that year due to injuries. The Leafs ran with a stacked top line that year, producing quite the statistical anomaly for him.
 
As a matter of fact he was that year due to injuries. The Leafs ran with a stacked top line that year, producing quite the statistical anomaly for him.

as a matter of fact, borscehvsky played in 45 games that year.

as a matter of fact, clark played with anderson for most of 93-94 (gartner after the trade, including the playoffs) just like he did in 92-93.

clark did not play with andreychuk and gilmour.
 
Yeah, too bad he's only reached 70 points once in the past 5 years, and 35 goals twice.

A very good player no doubt, but we obviously have very different definitions of "superstar". I don't choose to apply that label to someone who struggles to score 70 points, regardless of where they play. So, once again...overrated.

6/7 seasons had him on pace for over 35 goals.

5/7 had him pacing to 70 points or over.

And he's 26.

I'll meet you half-way and call him just a "star". He'd be a god here though. There's too much ignorance on him.
 
Nash is soft and fat.

His skill is through the roof - but not nearly an ovechkin level skillset. There's something special about watching a big man dangle like that that seduces everyone who watches him, though.

but he's nothing like Perry, or Staal. Those guys are rugged.

And I would say their physicality is:

Perry - He's the toughest and most rugged, scrappy almost but in a big body. Perry is just sick though. Love him.
Staal - He's more grinder-ish, fights in the corner battles, strong big body guy, not overly aggressive though. But does have a temper/edge, most likely from being the eldest of the Staals and having to whip some ass here and there.
Nash - Bump and grind protection style. Forsberg or Sundin-ish in that sense. He's the least physical in nature of the three, but he's not soft by any means. Just watch his fight with Vandermeer.
 
A one year spike due to Lafontaine being there for him.

maybe. but then, nobody (including mogilny) did that before, or after lafontaine (who was more of a goal scorer himself, anyways... you could just as easily say that lafontaine's assist total was inflated that year because of mogilny's goal scoring prowess. to wit: he had 95 assists that year. his second highest total was 51)

A second spike due to Bure being injured.

his production spiked because the only other top line talent on hte team was out with an injury?

how does that make sense?

A third spike when he was with a pass-first centre (Gomez) and a playmaker on the other side (Sykora) who combined for 95 assists.

sykora played with elias and arnott.

and bozak is a pass-first centre, too. good for gomez for being a pass-first centre.

you're just reaching here. first, it's playing with better talent. then it's playing with 'pass first players.' the truth is, what you'll find is that most players who play with hihg impact players, like nash, become 'pass first players' because their coach tells them... pass the puck to player X.

Zhamnov and Steen were no slouches when it come to being playmakers.

teemu selanne led winnipeg forwards in assists in his rookie year. he had 50 more points than any other forward.

attributing the season he had to his linemates is a slap in the face to selanne.

Then tailed off gradually until Mike Modano and back up to 39. And then 37 in Detroit.

tailed off WITH modano. he had arguably the worst season of his career, goal scoring wise, during his second season in dallas.

Cassels was a pretty good set-up man. He propelled Sanderson to a 46 goal year himself.

andrew cassels was a second line centre. at best.

and attributing sanderson's season to cassels, just to suit your argument, is silly.

Add to that previously his spikes were from playing on a line with Brett Hull and Craig Janney (who you tremendously underrate, but we'll get to that).

no i don't. craig janney had the good fortune of playing with two of the very best goal scorers of all time during the peaks of their career. it is no surprise that as soon as he stopped playing with those guys he was little more than a 50-60 point player.

wouldn't be the first second rate player to produce inflated numbers.

Technical career high was with Savard. When he matched that he played with Hossa, Kozlov, Recchi, and White. So 1 star, 2 good players (at the time) and a mediocre one.

what do you mean 'technical career high'?

he has scored 52 goals twice

once with savard and hossa

and the other time without them (and a basically useless kozlov, to boot)

You tremendously underrate Janney. The guy was a PPG player, who was a PURE pass-first guy. Reassess that one.

no, i don't. he was a second rate set up man who got really really lucky.

kind of like kevin stevens, getting to play with jagr and lemieux, or rob brown getting to play wtih lemieux

I don't think Kunitz is all that good to be fair. Overrated at its finest. And I touched on my Heatley thoughts.

who overrates kunitz? what does that have to do with anything, anyways? if rick nash would get better playing with better players then why wouldn't that hold true for just about anybody?

You mean when Brind'Amour and Recchi stepped in? And Lindros didn't miss all that much time in either season to have drastic results.

certainly, if leclair couldn't play at as high a level without lindros he wouldn't have finished tied for 3rd in the league (1 out of first) for goals in 97-98, when lindros missed 20 games.

That was a whole lot of fluff from you. You can do better.

where is the fluff?

leclair scored just as many goals when lindros missed a quarter of the season as he did in any season where lindros did not miss time.

kovalchuk scored just as many goals with hossa playing on the secnod line (and in pittsburgh for the final quarter) as he did with savard and hossa flanking him.

selanne was just as productive with second line talent like macdonald as he was with decent first line talent like zhamnov, or a bonafide star like kariya. going to colorado and spending time on a line with forsberg and kariya did not result in increased productino (in fact, he slipped badly).

playing with thornton has not led to an increase in heatley's production.

kovalchuk's production slipped afte rhte trade in 09-10 when he went from playing with antropov and afinogenov, to playing with parise and zajak.

mogilny had a 100 point season playing with a diminished trevor linden, and an (adjusted) 90 point season playing with a second (gomez) and third (brylin) liner.
 
maybe. but then, nobody (including mogilny) did that before, or after lafontaine (who was more of a goal scorer himself, anyways... you could just as easily say that lafontaine's assist total was inflated that year because of mogilny's goal scoring prowess. to wit: he had 95 assists that year. his second highest total was 51)



his production spiked because the only other top line talent on hte team was out with an injury?

how does that make sense?



sykora played with elias and arnott.

and bozak is a pass-first centre, too. good for gomez for being a pass-first centre.

you're just reaching here. first, it's playing with better talent. then it's playing with 'pass first players.' the truth is, what you'll find is that most players who play with hihg impact players, like nash, become 'pass first players' because their coach tells them... pass the puck to player X.



teemu selanne led winnipeg forwards in assists in his rookie year. he had 50 more points than any other forward.

attributing the season he had to his linemates is a slap in the face to selanne.



tailed off WITH modano. he had arguably the worst season of his career, goal scoring wise, during his second season in dallas.



andrew cassels was a second line centre. at best.

and attributing sanderson's season to cassels, just to suit your argument, is silly.



no i don't. craig janney had the good fortune of playing with two of the very best goal scorers of all time during the peaks of their career. it is no surprise that as soon as he stopped playing with those guys he was little more than a 50-60 point player.

wouldn't be the first second rate player to produce inflated numbers.



what do you mean 'technical career high'?

he has scored 52 goals twice

once with savard and hossa

and the other time without them (and a basically useless kozlov, to boot)



no, i don't. he was a second rate set up man who got really really lucky.

kind of like kevin stevens, getting to play with jagr and lemieux, or rob brown getting to play wtih lemieux



who overrates kunitz? what does that have to do with anything, anyways? if rick nash would get better playing with better players then why wouldn't that hold true for just about anybody?



certainly, if leclair couldn't play at as high a level without lindros he wouldn't have finished tied for 3rd in the league (1 out of first) for goals in 97-98, when lindros missed 20 games.



where is the fluff?

leclair scored just as many goals when lindros missed a quarter of the season as he did in any season where lindros did not miss time.

kovalchuk scored just as many goals with hossa playing on the secnod line (and in pittsburgh for the final quarter) as he did with savard and hossa flanking him.

selanne was just as productive with second line talent like macdonald as he was with decent first line talent like zhamnov, or a bonafide star like kariya. going to colorado and spending time on a line with forsberg and kariya did not result in increased productino (in fact, he slipped badly).

playing with thornton has not led to an increase in heatley's production.

kovalchuk's production slipped afte rhte trade in 09-10 when he went from playing with antropov and afinogenov, to playing with parise and zajak.

mogilny had a 100 point season playing with a diminished trevor linden, and an (adjusted) 90 point season playing with a second (gomez) and third (brylin) liner.

And this is why I can't post here too often. I could go back and forth with this all day. It's a great debate though.

In the end though, Nash is a star and I don't think that can be disputed, but of course if I did I wouldn't be arguing so vehemently for my point.

It would be interesting to do a draft with 30 teams like back in the old fanhome days and start a keeper league. I'd be curious to see who has the best eye for talent.
 
that's not a half bad idea. can't we do that through yahoo or espn? think i read somebody say there are keeper leagues. though i don't now if those can be set up to hold drafts, etc.
 
I think Yahoo has a platform for it.

And I think there are 30 good solid hockey minds that post here that could get involved.

$150 for a season and we're talking a pot of $4500 a year in prizes. Plus bragging rights.

Then 5 players to protect on a yearly basis.

Could be interesting.
 
Zeke wins that hands down. Its got nothing to do with what consitutes a TEAM though does it? Just speculating on who will produce stats.
 
Zeke wins that hands down. Its got nothing to do with what consitutes a TEAM though does it? Just speculating on who will produce stats.

Unfortunately that's about all we can do.

Unless...... we take that $4500, let you invest it for us in some nice speculative stocks, become filthy rich, buy the NHL, make our own rules, and do it for real.

Got any hot picks??
 
ok. not sure if $150 is reasonable, that could be a pretty big discouragement to some, and maybe most. especially per year. $4500 is also a lot more than 'bragging rights'

also keep in mind -- the more teams you have in this, the better. keeper leagues are only good if you have to dig and think beyond this year.

though you need some incentive to keep people interested (i.e. money)

i'll start a threat to gauge interest and look into it. we can do a draft at some point in the summer. if enough are interested then we can talk about some wagers.
 
heh that's not a bad idea. if we can get 30 teams in, and people were all willing to put in $150 to be invested by teeder. winner takes some cut in 5 years. something like that.

that's not a bad idea at all.
 
heh that's not a bad idea. if we can get 30 teams in, and people were all willing to put in $150 to be invested by teeder. winner takes pot in X years.

that's not a bad idea at all.

Shoot, if everyone invests $150 in October and the winner takes the loot in April, that could be a lot more than $4500. Even if it only moves slightly. And then teeds can take a cut of the difference of increase.
 
Count me in for a keeper league. I'm sure HabsPatrol would be interested as well as he is the commish of the other Forum Ice Keeper league.
 
Damien Cox had this in his blog post today on The Star. An editor removed this portion and he then removed the entire blog post in protest:

Currently, The Star is in an ongoing minor dispute with the Maple Leafs, having had our access restricted by president/GM Brian Burke in retaliation for a story published last week that Burke deemed unfair. Attempts to resolve the dispute so far have failed; the league has not be asked to intervene.

http://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?q=http://thestar.blogs.com/thespin/2011/04/to-vote-or-not-to-vote.html&d=344233616852&mkt=en-CA&setlang=en-CA&w=e32a5c23,af4c395b

And here's an article on Grabovski in the Sun today:

Driven Grabovski eats, breathes and dreams hockey

The maturation of Mikhail Grabovski, hockey player savant, has been a stunning development of this Maple Leafs season gone right and wrong.

Grabovski wakes up and thinks hockey. He eats breakfast and thinks hockey. He goes home and thinks hockey. And in between, just about all he thinks about is hockey.

“To get to this level, all players are competitive,” said Keith Acton, the Leafs assistant coach. “But Mikhail is driven. He’s the kind of kid who is consumed by hockey. He’s the kind of young man when he leaves the rink he’s all about hockey and when he’s here he watches video of his last game or video or of good players like (Sidney) Crosby or (Henrik) Zetterberg to see what he can learn from them.

“I’ve seen a lot of players. I haven’t seen very many as totally consumed as he is,” Acton said.
...

“I can’t think of a more professional guy than Grabo,” said Wilson, who has coached the centreman for three seasons, one good, one poor, this one close to great. “He spends every waking moment studying his own shifts and his line’s shifts and trying to make himself better. He’s totally focussed on being the best player he can be.”
...

“Right now, my life is hockey,” he said. “I try to think about something different, but always it’s hockey. Now, I have my baby, and now it’s hockey and my family. That’s more important than anything.

“My life is more serious now. More maturation. I don’t this just for myself, now for the baby and family. I want to make my baby’s life more happy in the future.”

...

“I love talking to him,” Acton said. “He thinks the game continually. He’s the kind of player who brings strategy to coaches. You have to listen to him. He’s just a wonderful, wonderful young man who keeps getting better and better.”

His next goal will be his 30th, and for some that would mark a milestone. Grabovski doesn’t care much for 30, he wants 31.

“Thirty would mean nothing to me. It would mean more to my agent, my dad, maybe my coach or my linemates. For me, every goal is important. I want 31. I was born on 31 (January). I try to make it against Washington.”

So what’s next for Grabovski, other than his upcoming diaper change?

“I want to be in the playoffs,” he said. “It doesn’t matter how many goals I score, I want that. My future is all about my life in hockey. I can’t do anything else. I can’t think anything else.”

And as for his daughter, he said jokingly: “I hope she doesn’t look like me.”


http://www.torontosun.com/sports/columnists/steve_simmons/2011/04/04/17875216.html
 
Yeah, we did pretty good in the Grabo deal.

As for that access restriction thing, what story was it that pissed Burke off?

And I loved this quote:

The teams and the league love to daydream of a day when the independent media has been drowned out by their propaganda and fans don't see the difference

Why is it that guys like Cox and berger love to wax poetic about how they're the voices of truth, and all else is "propaganda"? It seems to be some kind of delusional complex they have.
 
Because their job depends on that belief ... which unfortunately, just isn't true.

I mean, honestly, many on this forum have better insight and can write better than say, Cox ....
 
Back
Top